Religion
In reply to the discussion: what is the most important aspect of the interaction between belivers and non believers [View all]AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)Also, I forgot to address one error you made. (Error or unsupported assertion)
"The atheist also accepts the proposition as valid and answers 'no'."
No. I don't. I don't accept the proposition as valid at all. Hell, that's my first response when people ask me 'why are we here'. I immediately object. That's begging the question that there must be a 'why' AT ALL.
If it seems that I am being an ass, please keep in mind, I've been wrangling with people on this for years. Most of those people, clearly trolls. It gets tiring and it wears away at the veneer of civility to keep getting the same bullshit arguments thrown in my face over and over.
So if you meant that proposition in earnest, well, then I apologize for my tone. It didn't strike me as being earnest.