Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Religion

CJCRANE

(18,184 posts)

16. Do you believe Ganesha existed?

Reply to rug (Reply #13)

Sun Apr 1, 2012, 06:57 PM

Apr 2012

Or any of the other Hindu gods and legends? Or the Norse gods or Egyptian gods etc.

Things don't need to physically exist to have an impact on history.

And again I reiterate that I believe Jesus probably existed but the evidence quoted in the OP is not convincing.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

40 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

'Did Jesus Exist?': A Historian Makes His Case [View all] rug Apr 2012 OP

There is, for example, no historical evidence of Nazareth until circa 200 CE. Warren Stupidity Apr 2012 #1

I'll mark you down as a mythicist. rug Apr 2012 #3

Jesus doesn't get a free pass. The evidence is not compelling. Warren Stupidity Apr 2012 #11

Are you intending that to be derogatory? nm rhett o rick Apr 2012 #14

There is reference to Nazareth in Matthew, which dates from the mid-to-late first century struggle4progress Apr 2012 #39

"Paul knew Jesus' brother, James CJCRANE Apr 2012 #2

Careful now, if you dare question the existence of Jesus... eqfan592 Apr 2012 #4

It doesn't hurt. rug Apr 2012 #6

Now that you mention it, it's amazing we know anything at all. rug Apr 2012 #5

I know a guy called James. CJCRANE Apr 2012 #7

Talk to me when you know a guy who knew Archimedes. rug Apr 2012 #10

The thing is...we can recreate Archimedes' experiment... CJCRANE Apr 2012 #15

Not in the least. eqfan592 Apr 2012 #9

someone of profound charisma spoke enough truths that generations of individuals roguevalley Apr 2012 #23

I agree with your analysis and most of your conclusions... CJCRANE Apr 2012 #26

I love science. I just love it and read the new things constantly. My spirituality roguevalley Apr 2012 #27

As a card carrying atheist, I feel obligated to say... Ferretherder Apr 2012 #8

I agree with you about his message CJCRANE Apr 2012 #12

Yeah, I think this book is just about whether he existed. rug Apr 2012 #13

Do you believe Ganesha existed? CJCRANE Apr 2012 #16

No. I haven't studied these beliefs but I suspect their etiologies are quite distinct. rug Apr 2012 #21

Ehrman is very smart longship Apr 2012 #17

I'm halfway through the book. earthside Apr 2012 #20

Tomb and Ossuary longship Apr 2012 #24

Jesus Tomb Probable earthside Apr 2012 #30

Yes, that's the irony... CJCRANE Apr 2012 #40

Is there much more in the book beyond arguing from the Bible as if... Silent3 Apr 2012 #31

I will need more proof than... Kalidurga Apr 2012 #18

"wanted to provide evidence" well quelle surprise what his conclusion was going to be nt msongs Apr 2012 #19

Before I read this I need to know what his conclusion will be. Speck Tater Apr 2012 #22

As a mythicist, I'd suggest that mr blur Apr 2012 #25

Did the Angel Moroni exist? edhopper Apr 2012 #28

Now you're saying Juan Diego didn't exist? rug Apr 2012 #29

Yeah, but the money wasn't good enough to quit his day job. jeepnstein Apr 2012 #32

I can see that. rug Apr 2012 #33

Yes edhopper Apr 2012 #34

It's interesting that some of the strongest of the critics, including Poole, a Vincentian priest, rug Apr 2012 #36

I do not know if he existed or not. The claims about him are highly dubious and edhopper Apr 2012 #38

A long rebuttal, based on the Huffington Post article Ehrman wrote a couple of weeks ago muriel_volestrangler Apr 2012 #35

Why is he pushing "evidence"? I thought I was supposed to have "faith". brooklynite Apr 2012 #37