Challenge To Theists

[Silent3]

63. Logic is a whole hell of a lot more consistent...

Last edited Tue Apr 17, 2012, 08:33 PM - Edit history (1)

...than hope and faith and love, and you can explain (no, not to every last detail -- but that would be a red herring) a lot about hope and faith and love using logic.

As for "other dimensions to this one (world)"... dimensions are just convenient conventions, just like you seem to be taking logic to task for being a "mere" tool or convention. If you start treating "other dimension" as if it means "hidden realm of unknown wonders", and if you assume that the logic and math and reason we apply to the "dimensions" we know about don't work there, then what you're talking about would essentially be a totally different world, whether you call it that or not.

Temperature, humidity, pressure... there are three dimensions, just as much dimensions as width, height, and length are dimensions.

Logic is not a physical object that exists outside of our mind

Did I ever say it was? Who are you arguing against, and what are you arguing for? Does any of this going on about dimensions and logic lead to a point?

Is this just a overly-complicated version of the tired old "science doesn't know everything, logic can't be applied to everything... therefore God, ESP, and unicorns!"?