Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Religion
In reply to the discussion: 'Islam no longer religion of peace' Muslim Charlie Hebdo journalist hits out at extremists [View all]muriel_volestrangler
(106,229 posts)107. Albertoo did refer to this, but you don't seem to have picked it up
(he mentioned "mass abduction and rape"
.
Why Context Matters
Even the Boko Haram image, the one that seems to defy explanation and understanding can be read. In this cartoon, there are a group of women, all pregnant, all angrily shouting Touchez pas a nos allocs (Hands off our welfare.).The legend reads Les Esclaves Sexuelles De Boko Haram en Colère (The Angry Sex Slaves of Boko Haram.)
Everything about it suggests that they are treating the victims of kidnapping and sexual slavery as the welfare queen of conservative nightmares. But the immediate reading does not take into account Charlie Hebdos tradition of combining two topics into one image. In this case, in addition to the news about Boko Haram, Charlie was taking on the issue of potential cuts to welfare. Through this combination, they mock the French anxieties, giving life to nightmares through reductio ad absurdum: victims of violence are the greatest threat to France. This is the Rights nightmare vision of the welfare queen. It is a Charlie Hebdo version of Stephen Colbert.
http://souciant.com/2015/01/why-context-matters/
Even the Boko Haram image, the one that seems to defy explanation and understanding can be read. In this cartoon, there are a group of women, all pregnant, all angrily shouting Touchez pas a nos allocs (Hands off our welfare.).The legend reads Les Esclaves Sexuelles De Boko Haram en Colère (The Angry Sex Slaves of Boko Haram.)
Everything about it suggests that they are treating the victims of kidnapping and sexual slavery as the welfare queen of conservative nightmares. But the immediate reading does not take into account Charlie Hebdos tradition of combining two topics into one image. In this case, in addition to the news about Boko Haram, Charlie was taking on the issue of potential cuts to welfare. Through this combination, they mock the French anxieties, giving life to nightmares through reductio ad absurdum: victims of violence are the greatest threat to France. This is the Rights nightmare vision of the welfare queen. It is a Charlie Hebdo version of Stephen Colbert.
http://souciant.com/2015/01/why-context-matters/
You can tell it's not just a straightforward attack on Muslim women in France, because it explicitly names them as the Boko Haram slaves; but they don't get welfare, so we know there's more to it than just an attack on a real group of women. As the article I kink says, you may or may not thinks it works well, but the context of what the news was when the cartoon is published is useful.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
125 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
'Islam no longer religion of peace' Muslim Charlie Hebdo journalist hits out at extremists [View all]
trotsky
Oct 2016
OP
The cartoonists of Charlie Hebdo practiced their own brand of racism and hate.
guillaumeb
Oct 2016
#2
My bet is Sam Harris. The tone is too moderate for Geller's type of hate. eom
guillaumeb
Oct 2016
#18
If the mere existence of the death penalty proves a predisposition for violence,
guillaumeb
Nov 2016
#36
Again, that same old confusion? A poor diversion from the quantification of Islam's violence
Albertoo
Nov 2016
#46
My evidence is the large number of people - Muslims, ex-Muslims, non-Muslims who report so.
trotsky
Nov 2016
#23
Your invitation to ride the endless carousel of accusation and selective verse mining
guillaumeb
Nov 2016
#41
What I object to is the immediate response whenever the Charlie Hebdo murders are mentioned...
trotsky
Nov 2016
#24
Why did you immediately bring up that people were offended by the cartoons?
Goblinmonger
Nov 2016
#68
I fully understand what trotsky was saying before he spelled it out to you step by step
Goblinmonger
Nov 2016
#71
The fact you do not understand gallows humor does not prove anything about Charlie Hebdo
Albertoo
Nov 2016
#47
There are considerable examples of continental french being unable to understand canadian french
AtheistCrusader
Nov 2016
#116
Albertoo did refer to this, but you don't seem to have picked it up
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#107
But it was using a specific story from that month about Boko Haram holding girls/women
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#125
Nice points, and I agree that your first point about this one specific cartoon is correct.
guillaumeb
Nov 2016
#126
You do know that those cartoons were satirizing the racism of France, right?
Goblinmonger
Nov 2016
#30
So you tried to hijack the thread by posting something not from CH?
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#63
"hijack this story when it appeared over the weekend"? This is the first thread about it
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#78
And the 'Google gish' was to explain to you, and anyone else, who the artist was
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#64
Your posts are just name calling. You can't ever admit when you're wrong.
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#79
It's a play on words. The cartoonist is saying religions claim they are 'untouchable'
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#89
I don't think religion is above mocking, or should get special protection
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#106
Again, the black woman is saying she is being treated like a slave
muriel_volestrangler
Nov 2016
#109
First person I noticed that liked to attack Hebdo with bullshit claims of racism
AtheistCrusader
Nov 2016
#117