Religion

Ian David

(69,059 posts)

11. The dude was being held in the psych ward. I don't think he got to choose his hospital. n/t

Reply to lunasun (Reply #9)

Sun Jun 3, 2012, 11:11 AM

Jun 2012

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

42 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

�For Going Against God�s Will� Catholic Hospital Denies Gay Man HIV Meds [View all] Ian David Jun 2012 OP

Has this been reported and substantiated anywhere else? skepticscott Jun 2012 #1

Really? Is sounds 'a bit fishy'? Why? Be specific, please... Bluenorthwest Jun 2012 #2

There are two obvious questions. rug Jun 2012 #3

I take your questions as seriously as those of the other poster... Bluenorthwest Jun 2012 #4

That's informative but it answers neither question. rug Jun 2012 #5

I'm doing unto others. The OP did not so much as address the facts presented Bluenorthwest Jun 2012 #8

The fact is she is a psychiatrist. rug Jun 2012 #10

Well the knee jerk rhetoric was in the fist post I responded to Bluenorthwest Jun 2012 #14

No you're not skepticscott Jun 2012 #18

The first post of yours I responded to questioned the drug resistance information Bluenorthwest Jun 2012 #20

I was specific skepticscott Jun 2012 #12

I already offered you a link to UC SF's HIV Institue which will offer you all Bluenorthwest Jun 2012 #21

Wow, you went on at great length skepticscott Jun 2012 #23

I'm confused about just what kinds of things SkepticScott is actually skeptical ABOUT. Ian David Jun 2012 #27

Well, feel free to be confused skepticscott Jun 2012 #33

Those are actually two good points. n/t Ian David Jun 2012 #37

The convicted murderer identified himself as such. And as for the drug resistance... Ian David Jun 2012 #26

As I said, I'm aware of how drug resistance evolves skepticscott Jun 2012 #32

Yes, it does. That is basic, BASIC knowledge. Ian David Jun 2012 #36

No, I don't skepticscott Jun 2012 #39

Call your doctor's office & ask to speak to a nurse. Unless it is your INTENTION to remain ignorant. Ian David Jun 2012 #41

Cross posted from my response to the thread in GD intaglio Jun 2012 #6

This denial of treatment is acceptable under no dogma and under no sense of humanity. rug Jun 2012 #7

well, i don't know about that. research mother theresa. ret5hd Jun 2012 #13

Research moral theology. rug Jun 2012 #15

So you are claiming that mother theresa was acting contrary to either/both dogma.. ret5hd Jun 2012 #22

Actually you claim the opposite but the OP is about a hospital in Elizabeth NJ. rug Jun 2012 #28

You might want to check the doctrine of "Due Proportion" before you make such statements intaglio Jun 2012 #16

Treatment of HIV at this stage is far from that. rug Jun 2012 #17

You haven't actually read my post, have you? intaglio Jun 2012 #19

I did. Nevertheless, the situation remains far outside the realm of extraordinary treatment. rug Jun 2012 #29

Essentially you have conceded that Catholic teaching permits such actions, intaglio Jun 2012 #30

What are you smoking? rug Jun 2012 #31

Oh, I do comprehend what you are saying intaglio Jun 2012 #34

The OP is about HIV medicine, not dialysis or DNR. rug Jun 2012 #35

I refer you to my post 19 and my post 6 intaglio Jun 2012 #38

I stay away from any Catholic institutions lunasun Jun 2012 #9

The dude was being held in the psych ward. I don't think he got to choose his hospital. n/t Ian David Jun 2012 #11

That also explains why a psychiatrist was doing this. backscatter712 Jun 2012 #24

If true, this is despicable, but there are a lot of questionable areas of this story. cbayer Jun 2012 #25

Agree 100%. Explosive accusations need to be accurate and documented. dimbear Jun 2012 #40

Borga needs to realize God didn't die and leave her in charge meow2u3 Jun 2012 #42