German Catholics lose church rights for unpaid tax

[dballance]

3. Perhaps the bishops should examine why they are driving people away

People are probably not just leaving the church. I suspect they have valid reasons why they are leaving. If I could guess it is most likely the actions of the bishops. Your imposing a tax on people and denying them holy rights if they don't pay is not a winner. Who will say a prayer over the pauper who had no money but lived a righteous life?

I recall the story of Jesus throwing the money changers out of the temple. I don't recall him setting up a fee for religion service.

The word "Catholic" is not your's to own. It is a term of great meaning which apparently the bishops have forgotten in their quest for control and power. Catholic has roots in the meaning "on the whole." Yes, that would be rather inclusive. I don't think Jesus had a minimum pay in to be considered religious. Perhaps if you feel the need to require people make a minimum donation you should examine your own morals.