Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Meshuga

(6,182 posts)
15. I didn't see the author as appealing "to the supernatural"
Sun Feb 24, 2013, 10:31 AM
Feb 2013

The author is merely saying that he personally sees a use for religion in seeking comfort from the reality of death and suffering. And that (to a group that shares a similar world view and set of beliefs) it is okay to stay within that world view to seek meaning and comfort in these situations. In addition, the author points out that he has difficulties with certain beliefs but sees usefulness in the "opiate of religion" (for him personally) when it comes to grieving and facing these situations. People choose to grieve as they see fit. If the author states that he "believes in God and prayer" we don't know much of what that means in this article since it is besides the point.

The author has to assume that the preacher literally believes in what he is preaching otherwise the preacher would be in the wrong place and being dishonest. And assuming that the preacher literally believes in what he himself is preaching, what the preacher prescribes in this situation is the appropriate prescriptions for the people who follow his world view.

For example, if I were to go to the funeral for this 17-year-old, it would be wrong and out of line for me (in my personal opinion) to be honest about my own views on what happens after death since it goes totally against the grieving family's world view. In other words, honesty is not always a virtue in my opinion. Expressing how ugly someone truly is or looks or making someone feel bad because he/she interrupted me with the "I am making you feel bad for the sake of honesty" justification are not virtues in my personal opinion. I see honesty in this case as justification to hurt other people and I see that as harmful.

And I don't think the author was trying to say he was more enlightened than the people attending the funeral and I can see he was just assuming that everyone attending the funeral believed literally in what the preacher was prescribing since he said that he doubts "that a single person in that chapel doubted for even an instant that every word that preacher said was literal fact." But again, he is stating this in support to his main point (that the opiate is perhaps the best prescription for people holding this world view and that the opiate may be useful to himself for self help) and not that he was more enlightened and (even less) that he was trying to be rude by seeing these people as inferior in any way.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I Find the Article at the Link to be a Further Example... dballance Feb 2013 #1
You are conflating that which can't be proven with a lie. cbayer Feb 2013 #2
Well, you can't prove god DOESN'T hate gay people.... trotsky Feb 2013 #5
at least the author admits to believing in banal nonsense. Warren Stupidity Feb 2013 #3
I don't think he escaped the harsh reality at all. cbayer Feb 2013 #4
What's the harm? trotsky Feb 2013 #7
Sure he did, and he admits as much in the title. Warren Stupidity Feb 2013 #8
The point and the harm skepticscott Feb 2013 #9
However, that is a non sequitur Meshuga Feb 2013 #20
The point is that believing in things skepticscott Feb 2013 #21
Opiates are legitimately used for pain relief as well. cbayer Feb 2013 #10
Yes they are used to escape the reality of severe pain. Warren Stupidity Feb 2013 #12
Lol, you mean I could get all edumacated and stuff if I hang out with you? cbayer Feb 2013 #17
No I mean you start out arguing "a" and then end up arguing "not a" and you do so Warren Stupidity Feb 2013 #18
Oh, yes I am horribly embarrassed. Thank god it's only you! cbayer Feb 2013 #19
The Franciscans Have a History and Reputation of Being Willing to Not Always dballance Feb 2013 #6
Not unexpected: I heard the same type of thing at the funeral of a 23-year-old Lydia Leftcoast Feb 2013 #11
I didn't see the author as appealing "to the supernatural" Meshuga Feb 2013 #15
... 2ndAmForComputers Feb 2013 #13
Fake psychics make people edhopper Feb 2013 #14
What does this have to do with money. It was a funeral? cbayer Feb 2013 #16
This reminds me of a story Ligyron Feb 2013 #22
Is this a true story? And how does it apply to the article? cbayer Feb 2013 #23
How obtuse can you really be? cleanhippie Feb 2013 #24
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»If Religion is the Opiate...»Reply #15