Religion

cbayer

(146,218 posts)

26. I agree that at some point you are better leaving, but respect the choice of those

Tue Mar 5, 2013, 08:16 PM

Mar 2013

who feel they can do more good inside than outside.

Unfortunately, I share your view on the prospects for getting a more progressive pope.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

54 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

3 Reasons Pro-Choice and Pro-LGBT Folks Won't Leave the Catholic Church [View all] cbayer Mar 2013 OP

The article, at the end, apples/oranges compares other organized religions to Catholicism saying.... Moonwalk Mar 2013 #1

+10000000000000 cleanhippie Mar 2013 #2

Catholics for Choice - pinto Mar 2013 #3

You might consider posting your thoughtful reply directly to the author. cbayer Mar 2013 #4

I will certainly do so. Moonwalk Mar 2013 #7

Since you posted the article here skepticscott Mar 2013 #20

Great points all around Meshuga Mar 2013 #13

They can't really be described as Pro-LGBT, then. n/t Plantaganet Mar 2013 #5

Why not? Are they not permitted to have individual positions that differ from their church? cbayer Mar 2013 #6

Moonwalk's response addresses this brilliantly. Plantaganet Mar 2013 #22

I strongly disagree. cbayer Mar 2013 #23

No, it's the members who won't leave who are allowing skepticscott Mar 2013 #25

Personal meanings = 0 unless they fit the "right" category. wow! That's opposite the life of Christ, patrice Mar 2013 #42

Why care about reforming the Catholic Church? Why not just be something else? ButterflyBlood Mar 2013 #8

Very good questions! backscatter712 Mar 2013 #9

I guess if you are the kind of person that thinks homeless people should be pepper sprayed cbayer Mar 2013 #11

When you can't cruelly defend your position, make an absurd ad hom attack instead. cleanhippie Mar 2013 #12

Only if they're violently assaulting you or threatening to do so. backscatter712 Mar 2013 #14

In the case described, no one was being "violently assaulted". cbayer Mar 2013 #15

He was threatened, and that's enough. backscatter712 Mar 2013 #16

Why pepper spray someone when you can just walk away? cbayer Mar 2013 #17

He tried walking away at first, the guy followed him. backscatter712 Mar 2013 #18

You are reading far more into it than I did, but that's ok. cbayer Mar 2013 #19

The author outlines a number of reasons why one might choose to stay. cbayer Mar 2013 #10

It's not a matter of what "works", and you know that skepticscott Mar 2013 #21

I was quite surprised to learn of people that make a fuss about it, as my family never did ButterflyBlood Mar 2013 #34

That's really helpful in terms of understanding why it was not particularly cbayer Mar 2013 #35

Again, your decision is unique to you, but I respect the individual decision cbayer Mar 2013 #27

For some, it isn't about reforming the RC church. It's more about honestly being who you know patrice Mar 2013 #28

Those are all very interesting and commendable personal opinions of yours. trotsky Mar 2013 #29

I'm still a Christian so I accept the Nicene Creed ButterflyBlood Mar 2013 #30

Some people have some pretty superstitious notions about what the Transbustantiation is. Vatican II patrice Mar 2013 #31

What you are describing sounds more like memorialism, not the RCC position ButterflyBlood Mar 2013 #33

Oh? I lived it with thousands of others. 45 years of my life. Catholic schools, except patrice Mar 2013 #38

You're defining transubstantiation as far broader than what I'm referring to ButterflyBlood Mar 2013 #49

I always found Communion to be most powerful on a symbolic level. kwassa Mar 2013 #36

Sharing food: it's all so deeply human & therefore catholic, with a small c. patrice Mar 2013 #39

I think the process of trying to know the divine ... kwassa Mar 2013 #40

Yes it is! I'm glad you said that. This thread is so much more respectful than this kind of issue patrice Mar 2013 #41

It would be great if it was always like this. kwassa Mar 2013 #43

Symbolic communion is memorialism ButterflyBlood Mar 2013 #50

This will clarify everything. kwassa Mar 2013 #51

The last bit is what I agree with ButterflyBlood Mar 2013 #52

You forgot skepticscott Mar 2013 #53

This is all well and good, but at which point is enough is enough SpartanDem Mar 2013 #24

I agree that at some point you are better leaving, but respect the choice of those cbayer Mar 2013 #26

And at what point skepticscott Mar 2013 #46

Many American grassroots Catholics don't pay that much attention to the pope. And some of those patrice Mar 2013 #32

The pope doesn't own the faith. Nor do the cardinals or bishops. kwassa Mar 2013 #37

There's a quote from Anna Lapp� - Plantaganet Mar 2013 #44

Correct me if I'm wrong, kwassa, Episcopalians ordain women and have a Gay bishop. In my universe, patrice Mar 2013 #45

I agree. The current head of the Episcopal church is a woman. kwassa Mar 2013 #54

Since attendance in Europe has fallen off a cliff, that must mean that only lgbt people Warren Stupidity Mar 2013 #47

Number four: Zoeisright Mar 2013 #48