Religion

Act_of_Reparation

(9,116 posts)

46. Shockingly illogical

Fri Mar 22, 2013, 09:25 PM

Mar 2013

Your position is entirely fallacious.

First, you're making an equivocation fallacy. Not paying taxes has swift, assured, and decidedly negative consequences. Not dropping money in the collection plate at church does not. While you may give money to any of the innumerable charitable organizations in existence, a taxpayer can only pay taxes to the IRS. The two scenarios are incomparable.

Secondly, and more importantly, your entire argument is a tu quoque. My position is that funding the Catholic church works in large part against progressive ideology. What I do personally has no bearing on whether or not this position is factually correct.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

61 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Pope enthralls large crowd with message of love, mercy [View all] struggle4progress Mar 2013 OP

"people who, on the one hand want to listen to Jesus, but, on the other hand..." trotsky Mar 2013 #1

There are self-proclaimed liberal and tolerant atheists here, aren't there? BuddhaGirl Mar 2013 #3

Buddhists too, apparently. trotsky Mar 2013 #4

where? BuddhaGirl Mar 2013 #5

Post #3... Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #6

nope BuddhaGirl Mar 2013 #7

Most of what I saw was outrage directed at ostensibly progressive people... Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #8

Apparently not BuddhaGirl Mar 2013 #9

Categorically absurd Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #10

This is exactly the type of stuff Dorian Gray Mar 2013 #11

The heirarchy exists because the congregants allow it Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #14

Not a double standard Dorian Gray Mar 2013 #17

Yes, a double-standard Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #20

My experience Dorian Gray Mar 2013 #58

And if someone said that skepticscott Mar 2013 #56

they aren't analogous Dorian Gray Mar 2013 #57

No, they're not absolutely, 100% the same skepticscott Mar 2013 #60

"Blaming congregants for the hierarchy is misguided." Hassin Bin Sober Mar 2013 #53

Who did that? Dorian Gray Mar 2013 #54

Please consider posting in the new Interfaith group. cbayer Mar 2013 #55

Very disappointing to see intelligence such as yours used to alienate and disparage nt Xipe Totec Mar 2013 #12

That certainly isn't the point Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #15

Unnecessary rudeness BuddhaGirl Mar 2013 #19

You are just repeating the same old stuff BuddhaGirl Mar 2013 #13

Your logic is uncompelling Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #16

... trotsky Mar 2013 #18

and your logic is just as uncompelling kwassa Mar 2013 #21

How much responsibility for pedophilia does the church bear... trotsky Mar 2013 #22

No, that has changed, though not enough kwassa Mar 2013 #25

2 responses: trotsky Mar 2013 #26

respect the relevant local laws in investigating and reporting allegations of sexual abuse kwassa Mar 2013 #27

Sheesh, did you even read what you posted? skepticscott Mar 2013 #28

You still didn't answer my question. trotsky Mar 2013 #30

To answer your question ... kwassa Mar 2013 #35

If that's the way you bow out of the discussion, so be it. trotsky Mar 2013 #38

trotsky, you are such a waste of time. kwassa Mar 2013 #43

All I did was ask a question. trotsky Mar 2013 #47

Logic is subjective. That's new. Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #23

You are only logical up to a point. kwassa Mar 2013 #24

Extortion Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #36

Can you choose where your income taxes go? okasha Mar 2013 #41

Paying taxes isn't voluntary. Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #42

Paying taxes is voluntary okasha Mar 2013 #45

Shockingly illogical Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #46

So you would be willing okasha Mar 2013 #49

Flogging dead horses, again. Act_of_Reparation Mar 2013 #50

Whaterver you say. okasha Mar 2013 #51

"Twaddle." Plantaganet Mar 2013 #52

Financially supporting an organization is ... kwassa Mar 2013 #44

However, the atheists who mock and belittle believers Fortinbras Armstrong Mar 2013 #32

A lecture from you on behavior is laughable. trotsky Mar 2013 #33

I think I am acting in a way that Jesus would approve Fortinbras Armstrong Mar 2013 #37

Awesome. trotsky Mar 2013 #39

So do you approve of bigotry? Fortinbras Armstrong Mar 2013 #40

No, but apparently Jesus does. n/t trotsky Mar 2013 #48

Now that would seem to be a bigoted remark Fortinbras Armstrong Mar 2013 #59

You have been asked at least 2 dozen times now... trotsky Mar 2013 #61

Like keeping woman subservient edhopper Mar 2013 #2

I, for one, am enthralled. Plantaganet Mar 2013 #29

You need to post this in GD skepticscott Mar 2013 #31

Love and mercy indeed. trotsky Mar 2013 #34