Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Religion

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

Phillip McCleod

(1,837 posts)
Mon Jun 10, 2013, 01:11 PM Jun 2013

Atheists use science like believers use faith in times of stress, says study [View all]

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/06/08/atheists-use-science-like-believers-use-faith-in-times-of-stress-says-study/

A new study suggests that science performs the same function in some people’s lives as faith does in the lives of religious believers. According to Science magazine, individuals placed under stress turned to science as a means of coping with feelings of stress and anxiety in a study which was published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology.

Scientists in the study questioned members of competitive rowing teams and recruited 100 of them, mostly in their 20s, who said that they lacked strong religious beliefs. The rowers were divided into two groups, one set of whom were about to race in a regatta, and a second group facing a much less stressful competition.

Group members were then asked whether they agree or disagree with statements like, “We can only rationally believe in what is scientifically provable,” and “All the tasks human beings face are soluble by science,” and “The scientific method is the only reliable path to knowledge.”

Athletes who were preparing to compete were, predictably, under more stress than athletes who were under less pressure. In addition, they were statistically more likely to express a strong belief in scientific principles, 15 percent more than their less stressed counterparts.

..

Scientific thinking and religious thinking derive from very different bases, said the study’s authors. Science is based in “analytical thinking, rational inquiry and an objective weighing of evidence.” Religious thought is “founded on intuition, inner experience, and a valuing of historical revelation.” Both, however, help people make sense of the world around them and gives them a sense of belonging.

“In stressful situations people are likely to turn to whatever worldviews and beliefs are most meaningful to them,” study co-author and Yale University psychologist Anna-Kaisa Newheiser told Science.
37 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
well, at least science is real. ret5hd Jun 2013 #1
And they're STILL not the same thing. Iggo Jun 2013 #2
+1 cleanhippie Jun 2013 #4
+1 Dawson Leery Jun 2013 #6
not even close to similar. Phillip McCleod Jun 2013 #19
more of the usual bs trying to equate "science" with "religious faith in science." mike_c Jun 2013 #3
see i rather took the opposite from it.. Phillip McCleod Jun 2013 #15
Poorly worded questions skepticscott Jun 2013 #5
How significant is it? Well, the test with the rowers had p = 0.006. Jim__ Jun 2013 #7
If all else was done properly skepticscott Jun 2013 #9
They weren't testing for scientific knowledge. Jim__ Jun 2013 #10
I wasn't talking about scientific knowledge, as in facts skepticscott Jun 2013 #11
Just before the battle, mother, I am writing home to you. If I survive I will dimbear Jun 2013 #8
It would be interesting to have a variety of stressful situations goldent Jun 2013 #12
yes unfortunately those wouldn't be controlled experiments. Phillip McCleod Jun 2013 #13
yeah I don't think my examples would get approved goldent Jun 2013 #14
no doubt these experiments (there were two).. Phillip McCleod Jun 2013 #16
I'm not sure if they would want to falsify the results goldent Jun 2013 #17
they would *attempt* to falsify the results.. Phillip McCleod Jun 2013 #18
Why this study is bullshit. edhopper Jun 2013 #20
i disagree. it's a normal experimental model. Phillip McCleod Jun 2013 #21
But their conclusion edhopper Jun 2013 #22
Smells like Templeton. n/t trotsky Jun 2013 #23
I think it's a valid point of inquiry. edhopper Jun 2013 #24
Why do you think the rowers in the high-stress group expressed a significantly stronger belief ... Jim__ Jun 2013 #25
In order to even attempt to answer that question skepticscott Jun 2013 #28
The study is explicit as to the criteria they base the claim on. Jim__ Jun 2013 #29
Uh, no it isn't skepticscott Jun 2013 #37
I am not saying the study doesn't say that edhopper Jun 2013 #30
I asked why you think that is? And why were the testers able to predict that? Jim__ Jun 2013 #33
I don't know edhopper Jun 2013 #34
"... belief in the value of science ... can offer reassurance to secular individuals ..." Jim__ Jun 2013 #35
Social scienes are different edhopper Jun 2013 #36
It IS definitely bullshit Brainstormy Jun 2013 #26
it's not any such attempt to show that atheism is a form of faith. Phillip McCleod Jun 2013 #32
You mean... gcomeau Jun 2013 #27
It's like the way I compulsively do Sudoku puzzles when stressed. cbayer Jun 2013 #31
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»Atheists use science like...»Reply #0