Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Religion

In reply to the discussion: Religion and the new technology [View all]

intaglio

(8,170 posts)
45. Interesting
Tue Feb 7, 2012, 05:21 PM
Feb 2012

I think you had better inform William Lane Craig of your opinion immediately! He needs to know that he and his ilk hold outdated views about the nature of deity.

For the rest you are talking nonsense; what is more it is evidence free nonsense because it depends upon the lack of evidence for its conclusions. The God you believe in is a retreat; no longer incarnate but spirit, no longer above the firmament but in an undetectable aetherial realm, no longer interventionist but only a prime cause, no longer a judge but an observer. You make an assumption, that there is a deity, and then modify that deity to fit in the vanishing gaps current knowledge. If the deity is what you say then how can it have informed the world of its existence?

If this ghost has, somehow, broken down the barriers between spirit and matter then why has the message been different or non-existent for every age, every culture, every nation and every individual? If this deity has this power and chooses not to use it is not that deity guilty of deceit? If this deity does not have that power then explain how it is a deity.

Regarding your OP. The question is imprecise for you ask about the way the brain functions. That "way" is electrochemical activity modified by inputs from the senses, customary pathways, genetics and perhaps, if Penrose is right, quantum effects from cellular architecture. If however you mean "is brain function changed by technology?" then the answer is yes, a trivial example is the effect of video games upon the sensory and emotional functions in the brains of games players or less trivially the apparent loss of verbal memory in literate as opposed to non-literate cultures.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Religion and the new technology [View all] Thats my opinion Feb 2012 OP
I'm interested in spirituality and tech. napoleon_in_rags Feb 2012 #1
Very helpful! nt Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #5
Another response. Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #8
"This is not a response" napoleon_in_rags Feb 2012 #13
"the vanishing of the media" reminds me of Marshall McLuhan and Bob Dobbs bananas Feb 2012 #34
LOL! I meant to say "vanishing of the medium" napoleon_in_rags Feb 2012 #36
For me this is easy intaglio Feb 2012 #2
Interesting perspective. Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #9
So prove that any of this has happened to you intaglio Feb 2012 #15
You are correct in your suspicion of manipulative religion. Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #19
It is normal intaglio Feb 2012 #24
What this poster and so many others skepticscott Feb 2012 #25
Regarding your last two paragraphs, you are talking about some other form of religion, Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #29
You have to explain that a great deal more Angry Dragon Feb 2012 #31
For every complex question there is a simple answer Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #38
And for every question that's actually pretty simple skepticscott Feb 2012 #40
The reason I asked the question is it Angry Dragon Feb 2012 #41
you raise some sound interesting questions Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #44
You need to grease the wheels on those goalposts... cleanhippie Feb 2012 #33
What straw men? intaglio Feb 2012 #35
"Just making it up as you go along" skepticscott Feb 2012 #37
You are certainly entitled to your opinion, Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #39
I think you mean I am an outsider to the conversation with God intaglio Feb 2012 #42
Religious thought has long since gone way past the idea of God Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #43
Interesting intaglio Feb 2012 #45
So who exactly is this "we" skepticscott Feb 2012 #46
Instant access to information; but usually a quick, shallow stab at this information. Jim__ Feb 2012 #3
As do you, Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #6
About post-modern theology Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #10
Information is almost completely commodified. rrneck Feb 2012 #4
So I wonder if you may believe that much of what is happening is manipulative? Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #7
I don't necessarily think it's manipulative rrneck Feb 2012 #11
So when will you be telling skepticscott Feb 2012 #12
Probably after you stop. rug Feb 2012 #14
If I were championing a new theology skepticscott Feb 2012 #16
Considering the OP is not about that, I'm not surprised. rug Feb 2012 #18
The OP IS about a new theology skepticscott Feb 2012 #21
............... Angry Dragon Feb 2012 #32
Were you at Claremont this week? Sal316 Feb 2012 #17
Yes i was? Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #20
I was. Sal316 Feb 2012 #27
That was the one session I missed. nt Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #28
Religion and moren technology could not mix NinjaKid Feb 2012 #22
Yes Chinita Feb 2012 #23
Speaking from the inside, Thats my opinion Feb 2012 #26
Uhh... you couldn't be more wrong. Sal316 Feb 2012 #30
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»Religion and the new tech...»Reply #45