Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

MellowDem

(5,018 posts)
12. Not for any good (IMHO) logical reason...
Sun Aug 18, 2013, 04:20 PM
Aug 2013

Might as well ask why someone would want to be a member of the KKK, a uniquely bigoted organization itself, except, at least there you still get to have sex, and their philosophy isn't entirely supernatural, you do have some psuedoscience, though a lot of apologetics seems like psuedoscience to me.

Seriously, why would someone young want to throw away their sexuality and young years for an institution based on lies, fear, hate and bigotry, with clear beliefs on women being inferior and homosexuals being "disordered", and with a vengeful god that killed millions in their own holy book, and of which there is zero proof or evidence? It's a good question. What would drive someone to do that?

My guess? For most, childhood indoctrination first and foremost (which is very sad really), tradition, comforting beliefs, and community, all mixed with a big dose of intellectual dishonesty and cognitive dissonance, and a splash of ingnorance (add more if need be). What else? Well, maybe the fear of hell and the opportunity to help others. What's depressing is that religion is not needed for tradition, community, comforting philosophies, etc., and religion can twist even good intentions because it is based on such an illogical premise. Hence, Pope Francis wanting to help the poor, but homosexuals organizing for rights? The devil.

While I can respect the good intentions of some of those who become nuns and priests, I can never respect their decision to carry out those intentions through such a terrible, horrible, hateful belief system that continues to cause so much pain and suffering and recruits almost entirely through indoctrinating the gullible, mainly young children. Indeed, for pushing gullibility as a virture in "faith". Not to mention, the sheer lunacy of celibacy and the totally disgusting, guilt-ridden idea of "original sin". At the same time, I feel for them, because for many, if they hadn't been indoctrinated in the faith, they would have never chosen such a twisted role in service to such a terrible belief system, regressive in so many ways.

Easy way to make a living? Cool outfits? Glorfindel Aug 2013 #1
I think most people want a job that makes them LuvNewcastle Aug 2013 #2
Some of the statistics are eye opening. cbayer Aug 2013 #3
The new priest in our parish was born in 1980. rug Aug 2013 #4
i simply refuse to believe any one was ever born after 1960. nt xchrom Aug 2013 #5
Lol, I refuse to believe anyone had sex before 1950. rug Aug 2013 #6
i believe that to be a statement of Fact. nt xchrom Aug 2013 #8
According to Dixon's okasha Aug 2013 #11
Depends on what one considers "thoughtful" and "compelling"... MellowDem Aug 2013 #13
As an example, your post is the opposite. rug Aug 2013 #14
No, yours represents how many priests and nuns must justify themselves... MellowDem Aug 2013 #15
Again, a quite reflexive and far from compelling post. rug Aug 2013 #16
Again, you fail to respond in any meaningful way MellowDem Aug 2013 #17
To what? A prediigested regurgitation of talking points? rug Aug 2013 #18
Post removed Post removed Aug 2013 #20
And there you go. QED. rug Aug 2013 #22
I thought about going into the clergy but I am not suited for it. hrmjustin Aug 2013 #7
As a young child, I thought I wanted to be a nun, even though I wasn't catholic. cbayer Aug 2013 #9
Well It is a calling and I told god it was not for me. hrmjustin Aug 2013 #10
Not for any good (IMHO) logical reason... MellowDem Aug 2013 #12
So, the priesthood is out for you? kwassa Aug 2013 #19
Yeah, I'm not a misogynist or homophobe, so the priesthood isn't for me MellowDem Aug 2013 #21
Not clergy is homophobic or misogynistic. hrmjustin Aug 2013 #23
Then why are they part of a misogynist, homophobic institution? MellowDem Aug 2013 #26
Not all clergy belong to homophobic or misogynistic organizations. hrmjustin Aug 2013 #27
This is the Catholic Church from the article... MellowDem Aug 2013 #32
The RCC is not the KKK and should not be in the same sentence. hrmjustin Aug 2013 #33
there are many types of priests in this world kwassa Aug 2013 #24
All Catholic priests are part of a misogynist, homophobic institution MellowDem Aug 2013 #25
Wow, just wow. hrmjustin Aug 2013 #28
If you have a point, make it... MellowDem Aug 2013 #29
First of all I am gay and a former member of the church so I know what homophobia is all about. hrmjustin Aug 2013 #31
How is that a bad comparison? MellowDem Aug 2013 #35
What is religious privilege? hrmjustin Aug 2013 #38
I never said the RCC was the KKK... MellowDem Aug 2013 #40
Religion does not get threated with kid gloves on DU. hrmjustin Aug 2013 #41
Even on DU... MellowDem Aug 2013 #43
I am sorry but... hrmjustin Aug 2013 #45
Or if enough people leave the church... MellowDem Aug 2013 #46
Are you kidding? BainsBane Aug 2013 #47
In defense of this bullshit institution .... kwassa Aug 2013 #36
But that's a poor rationale... MellowDem Aug 2013 #39
No, it isn't. This is not a binary world. kwassa Aug 2013 #42
The religions provide none of the good... MellowDem Aug 2013 #44
The core message of the Catholic Church is social justice BainsBane Aug 2013 #48
What exact part of you is mellow, MellowDem? kwassa Aug 2013 #30
Yes, people will join the church for different reasons... MellowDem Aug 2013 #37
Job security - G-d's work is unlikely to be outsourced or automated. leveymg Aug 2013 #34
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»Why Would a Millennial Be...»Reply #12