Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

2naSalit

(102,756 posts)
9. The whole commercialized thing about
Wed Oct 9, 2013, 03:59 PM
Oct 2013

these "holidays" is just a marketing ploy that is also disrespectful of the purpose of the days of recognition in the first place. Co-opting someone's religious celebration for kids in this way is actually promoting the idea that only their religious beliefs are valid and that all others are to be mocked in this way. Perhaps they could just have "celebration days" for the sake of celebration but leave these themes meant to offend and mock out of it. I think this is one of the reasons we have the amount of religious zealotry that we do in this country... because nobody is taught to respect the beliefs of others, only mockery of them.

If school children were taught the actual original meanings of these "holidays" without the mockery and then offered days for celebration without the mockery themes, then I would be okay with them. I, personally, am offended by the way Hallowe'en and Christmas are celebrated in this country... they are measured by profit margins and capitol intake and rarely anything more. They have been co-opted by capitalism and that is all they are anymore in this country, a celebration of corporate profit.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

schools should nix Halloween, Easter, Christmas etc gopiscrap Oct 2013 #1
Every year my kids' elementary school has a Seuss character day. rug Oct 2013 #3
yep gopiscrap Oct 2013 #6
And it worked so well. atreides1 Oct 2013 #8
I love kids and raised two of my own but gopiscrap Oct 2013 #11
In my day - long time ago- my Catholic school was closed on Nov. 1 - All Saints' Day. No Vested Interest Oct 2013 #22
that was my experience also, but we're talking about PUBLIC schools here gopiscrap Oct 2013 #23
Yes, friend, I was replying to your post #6, where you mentioned No Vested Interest Oct 2013 #24
oh ok, sorry my bad... gopiscrap Oct 2013 #25
Guess what? We had parties all the time. High school and college were a breeze. jeff47 Oct 2013 #26
2-3 measly days out of the year? fitman Oct 2013 #4
Parties are disruptive? cbayer Oct 2013 #13
Halloween is religious gopiscrap Oct 2013 #15
All Saints Day is one thing. Halloween quite another, imo. cbayer Oct 2013 #16
Dumb!! Let kids be kids fitman Oct 2013 #2
I didn't know d_r Oct 2013 #5
My local public school allows it.. fitman Oct 2013 #7
cool. d_r Oct 2013 #19
The whole commercialized thing about 2naSalit Oct 2013 #9
What religion does Halloween endorse? cbayer Oct 2013 #10
It doesn't but it stems from All Saints (All Hallows) Day on November 1. rug Oct 2013 #12
November 1 is a huge holiday in southern Europe. cbayer Oct 2013 #14
the word is a derivative of All Hallow's Eve gopiscrap Oct 2013 #17
I could be wrong, but I have never known the american celebration of Halloween to cbayer Oct 2013 #18
I think that's right. longship Oct 2013 #20
There is a difference with christmas, though. cbayer Oct 2013 #21
Not really. Christmas is re-branding of Yule. (nt) jeff47 Oct 2013 #28
The "Christ" part bothers some people. cbayer Oct 2013 #29
Doesn't have to. jeff47 Oct 2013 #30
I agree. I know lots and lots of non-christians that love christmas. cbayer Oct 2013 #32
The name is. Everything else about it isn't. jeff47 Oct 2013 #27
The WORD might be, but, like Christmas, the celebrations and the symbolism pre-date Christianity. PassingFair Oct 2013 #34
Halloween hasn't had a speck of religion in it since they killed all the witches kestrel91316 Oct 2013 #31
I don't like the costume bit Goblinmonger Oct 2013 #33
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»School tries to nix Hallo...»Reply #9