Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Peace Patriot

(24,010 posts)
26. The Universe AS WE UNDERSTAND IT RIGHT NOW forbids time travel and perpetual motion.
Sun May 5, 2013, 10:51 PM
May 2013

You write as if we understand everything. That is very, VERY improbable, from our ant-like point of view of the Universe, and considering how recently scientists began to understand even the most basic concepts--really just in the last hundred years or so.

It is a very dangerous--and I would say, unscientific--thing to say that something "applies to everything - no exceptions." Truly, we are at the edge of an ocean of knowledge, like ants on a leaf floating on a wavelet. We barely know "what's out there." We only barely understand our own DNA. As for subatomic particles, they do such strange, inexplicable things, that physicists plainly admit that they are mystified, and no one has yet come up with a 'unified theory.'

It's NOT a time to be dogmatic, to pretend that there are fixed "verities" that no one--not even a Nobel prize winner--dare challenge. That kind of thinking dumbs people down. Considering the breadth of the ferment in numerous sciences right now, I would advise you not to use words like "never" and "impossible" without that caveat "as far as we know now."

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I understand only a minute portion of all that - enlightenment Apr 2013 #1
And I love the fact that we are witness demwing Apr 2013 #2
and I would add: yonder May 2013 #9
be positive demwing May 2013 #10
I positively agree, especially the corporations. nt yonder May 2013 #11
I second that. tclambert May 2013 #12
Me too matt819 May 2013 #29
It makes one wonder why NASA has shifted faster than light travel to the category of "speculation" gordianot Apr 2013 #3
The human race is not advancing in a linear manner but in an exponential one. colorado_ufo Apr 2013 #4
A lot of those medieval countries are that way Rozlee May 2013 #24
So, these guys yesphan Apr 2013 #5
. eppur_se_muova Apr 2013 #6
Just being able to devise an experiment Moondog Apr 2013 #7
Interesting. Yet another couple of Star Trek plots Warpy Apr 2013 #8
I used to love this stuff, now I just feel that most of these people are just the A Simple Game May 2013 #13
When I see articles like this, it reminds me how little progress has been made in theoretical goldent May 2013 #14
Perpetual Motion Machine = Junk Science montex May 2013 #15
interesting opinion. tomp May 2013 #16
Strange! FlaGranny May 2013 #17
Your post reads like you haven't read the article (n/t) thesquanderer May 2013 #18
It. Can. Happen. longship May 2013 #20
Thanks for posting. DetlefK May 2013 #22
The Universe AS WE UNDERSTAND IT RIGHT NOW forbids time travel and perpetual motion. Peace Patriot May 2013 #26
You're right. This guy obviously doesn't know what he's talking about. Ask for the Nobel gateley May 2013 #27
Time Travel was proved possible by these guys... nikto May 2013 #19
Oooo star trek neener neener xtraxritical May 2013 #21
Energy is the generator of temporal alterations. DetlefK May 2013 #23
Blinx No!!!!!!, Planet B1Q64 is done for!!! Throckmorton May 2013 #25
I wonder how many time crystals can dance on the head of a pin...... kestrel91316 May 2013 #28
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»‘Time Crystals’ Could Upe...»Reply #26