Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Science

In reply to the discussion: Are killer whales persons? [View all]

MADem

(135,425 posts)
25. I don't agree about the "marriage" word. All marriage means is "union."
Mon Jun 29, 2015, 03:08 AM
Jun 2015

A marriage between honey and barbecue sauce....for example. A marriage of wit and wisdom. A marriage of disparate ideas. The idiots who tried to redefine marriage in the tortured fashion you mention just failed in their effort--and good thing. If you try to add to the definition beyond the concept of a union, you're going far afield.

People, to my view, are homo sapiens. Orcas may be intelligent, sentient, self-actualized beings, but they aren't people. People can be mean, stupid, cruel, dumbass racists--there's nothing "noble" or "better" in the word itself. "People" killed those bible students in the church, and those moviegoers in Aurora, and those young students at Sandy Hook. There's nothing terribly recommending about the word "people," in and of itself.

People can be assholes!

As for sapiens, I regard that more as capacity--the gas tank, as opposed to the gas.

Rather than try to expand the definition of "people" to fit animals, I say, instead, just make room for the doggone animals where appropriate. It's simpler than trying to torture the language.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Are killer whales persons? [View all] RandySF Jun 2015 OP
Yes, deathrind Jun 2015 #1
No modern and forethinking definition of "person" would require "human only". nt greyl Jun 2015 #2
+1 n/t Alkene Jun 2015 #12
I don't think they are persons. MADem Jun 2015 #3
What's your definition of person? greyl Jun 2015 #5
Let's start with the obvious...they need to be homo sapiens. MADem Jun 2015 #8
Obvious in an infantile sense, maybe, but not justified. That's a foregone conclusion. nt greyl Jun 2015 #11
I come from the "words have meanings" school of thought. MADem Jun 2015 #14
Like I don't? greyl Jun 2015 #16
I'm rather surprised that you're taking offense, given you MADem Jun 2015 #17
Right, you couldn't imagine... nt greyl Jun 2015 #18
Quite right--I couldn't. I don't see a need for name calling simply MADem Jun 2015 #19
Hate to break this to you... you aren't a homo sapiens. DetlefK Jun 2015 #27
I'm from multiple regions, not just Europe, though I have some MADem Jun 2015 #28
Can you prove that you are a person? DetlefK Jun 2015 #29
I think it depends on how we define personhood. RandySF Jun 2015 #6
Well, then they are self-actualized beings who are dolphins, then--but not MADem Jun 2015 #9
if corporations are people, why not killer whales? elehhhhna Jun 2015 #22
I try never to get stuck on the meanings of words. Words are very shifty things. hunter Jun 2015 #24
I don't agree about the "marriage" word. All marriage means is "union." MADem Jun 2015 #25
I'm not going to repeat everything you've said on this post simply because you've.. BlueJazz Jul 2015 #32
Thank you!!! MADem Jul 2015 #33
“Right now, there is no one besides a human who is a person,” Huh? Citizens United has made valerief Jun 2015 #4
also +1 n/t Alkene Jun 2015 #13
Maybe that awful decision can do some good BrotherIvan Jun 2015 #15
One of the TV commercials on for GE right now is boasting about their Erich Bloodaxe BSN Jun 2015 #21
Or what about the booms Obama approved? BrotherIvan Jun 2015 #23
No, they aren't persons awoke_in_2003 Jun 2015 #7
Human superiority has always been a myth. Live and Learn Jun 2015 #10
we are superior in several measurable ways qazplm Jul 2015 #34
I suspect all cetaceans are. nt Erich Bloodaxe BSN Jun 2015 #20
So, how shall we define a person in the broadest sense? DetlefK Jun 2015 #26
No qazplm Jul 2015 #30
we have to keep our minds open RussBLib Jul 2015 #31
Only if they can rise above their cetacean. Orrex Jul 2015 #35
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»Are killer whales persons...»Reply #25