Science
In reply to the discussion: Quantum Biology and the Puzzle of Coherence [View all]tama
(9,137 posts)goes back to David Bohm and "top-down causality" seems a concept related to Bohmian notion of "active information". I've been following the discussion so long that I remember when the argument used to be about micro and macro and quantum effects limited to just micro, which has been proven wrong. Other main argument used to be that warm and moist environments don't allow decoherred quantum states and evidence has blown also that "argument" away. The materialist position wobbles mainly on the Standard Model, which is admittedly inconsistent and string/M-theories that lead to multiverse speculations.
You made strong claim which you cannot prove or defend by any rational argument except by referring to a preacher of the pseudoskeptic movement. But thanks anyway for the book recommendation, I'm currently reading Goldilocks by Paul Davies which I can recommend.