Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Science

In reply to the discussion: Is interstellar travel possible? [View all]

longship

(40,416 posts)
6. Yes, but I suspect that few are doing it, if anybody.
Mon Dec 21, 2015, 06:14 PM
Dec 2015

And those kooks who talk about warp drives are not doing real science. Everybody knows that the only purpose of a warp drive is to get the Enterprise past the next commercial.

Plus, one cannot ignore the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, which everybody positing interstellar travel conveniently does ignore. This is basic physics 101, stuff that is not likely to be overturned ever. In Star Trek it was a plot device that everybody basically ignored, just like the transporter ignored the continuity problem -- well, everybody but McCoy.

But as far as anybody who understands basic science, none of this is real, and none of it is likely ever to become real. It is what could be called, a Star Trek wet dream.

However, it does make for a great background for a fictional narrative. That's why Star Trek is so damned compelling and long lived. But it is what it is. Fiction.

I suspect that the reason we have not been visited by space aliens is that interstellar travel is so fucking difficult that virtually nobody is doing it. Also, there's the issue that we live in a really, really huge galaxy and even small interstellar distances are fucking ginormous.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Very, very interesting. SheilaT Dec 2015 #1
I suspect that most would say it's not impossible. Igel Dec 2015 #2
I really like the generational ship idea SoLeftIAmRight Dec 2015 #14
I don't - I think humans will conquer death from aging. Then a slow ship is possible without requiri MillennialDem Dec 2015 #19
Most likely any society that can create a generational ship... won't Johonny Dec 2015 #23
My two cents. Half-Century Man Dec 2015 #3
One more name SCantiGOP Jan 2016 #36
Most assuredly Half-Century Man Jan 2016 #37
I wasn't criticizing your list SCantiGOP Jan 2016 #38
I didn't read your post as a critique. Half-Century Man Jan 2016 #39
Interstellar travel Fluothane Dec 2015 #4
TheSun will wipe out life on Earth in about 1 billion years. longship Dec 2015 #5
Plenty of time to move the planet to a more distant orbit Fumesucker Dec 2015 #8
That would work! longship Dec 2015 #10
temp fix at best qazplm Dec 2015 #17
How would 0.4c make it easy to hop from star system to star system? That's still 10 years to alpha MillennialDem Dec 2015 #22
Yes, but I suspect that few are doing it, if anybody. longship Dec 2015 #6
Alcubierre drive bypasses classical mechanics concerns... samson212 Dec 2015 #7
No thrust means no movement. longship Dec 2015 #9
actually by altering the geometry qazplm Dec 2015 #18
No thrust == no space travel. longship Dec 2015 #12
I'll wait and see what they figure out is making the em drive work Warpy Jan 2016 #26
No thrust? No go! longship Jan 2016 #27
NASA has determined it does produce thrust Warpy Jan 2016 #29
Well, here's what physicists are saying. longship Jan 2016 #31
A 'Star Trek wet dream'? LongTomH Dec 2015 #11
How long do you got SoLeftIAmRight Dec 2015 #13
I believe it is Marrah_G Dec 2015 #15
I believe it is, but I think humans conquering death from aging is a much easier nut to crack than MillennialDem Dec 2015 #20
while I think FTL travel qazplm Jan 2016 #25
Bookmarked. Thanks, LongTomH. n/t bvf Dec 2015 #16
Assuming any mission will take multiple generations goldent Dec 2015 #21
Yes and its myopic, dogmatic, parochial to say we won't Ichingcarpenter Dec 2015 #24
I hope so. I want off this rock. Nailzberg Jan 2016 #28
Physicist son says that we are probably SheilaT Jan 2016 #30
The human body is mechanically frail. ladjf Jan 2016 #32
Doesn't mitigate the other challenges getting old in mke Jan 2016 #33
Thanks for the calculation. I was guessing that it would have taken longer than that. nt ladjf Jan 2016 #34
A First Real-World ''Interstellar'' Wormhole? Octafish Jan 2016 #35
Greg Meholic Advanced Space Propulsion Concepts for Interstellar Travel Ichingcarpenter Jan 2016 #40
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»Is interstellar travel po...»Reply #6