Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

onager

(9,356 posts)
29. LOL! Pulled that one out of their (Balaam's) asses...
Sun Apr 7, 2013, 02:00 PM
Apr 2013
I had been taught that 5000 or so historical references to Christ exist but i didnt read the list. caesar had 1400 and a. the graet had 600. i dont have proof...

That's straight out of the Josh McDowell School of Apologetics Debate - throw out an impressive "academic" stat that sounds authoritative. Then hope nobody checks.

I mean, who's going to go and actually count the damn references? But we do know this...

(pedant mode)

Julius Caesar - Oh, even an amateur dumbass like me could probably find a LOT more than 1400 historical references to Caesar. A master of P.R. and spin, Caesar kept 2 secretaries with him at all times to take down his thoughts, brag about his victories, and re-write his defeats.

He probably started the world's first daily newspaper, the Acta Diurna, and had it delivered to the Roman provinces. Again, full of his sayings and doings.

If you want to really confuse a believer, bring up Caesar's book The Alexandrian War. Which was most likely written by one of his staff officers, Hirtius. You'll find that when Caesar was in Egypt, his biggest supporters were the Jewish communities along the Palestinian coast. They raised money for him and even sent a cohort of 3000 Jewish soldiers - who Caesar thanked profusely in the book.

Watching all that was a kid whose father spearheaded the efforts to help Caesar. That kid grew up to be Herod The Great, famous Rug-Rat-Killer of the New Testament. And try finding a historical reference to THAT! Flavius Josephus hated Herod and practically recorded his every stray belch and fart. But not even he mentions the Massacre Of The Nazarene Brats.

(Double pedant note - Xians, always trying to pull a fast one to support their fairy tales, often refer to Josephus as a "contemporary" of Jesus. But Josephus wasn't born until circa 37 CE.)

Alexander The Great - now what was the name of that city where I lived for 4 years again? Kind Davidia? Jesusia? Why no, it was Alexandria. Where I often amused myself by strolling down Iskander al-Akbar Street. Which is apparently Arabic for "Loser Who Only Rated A Few Contemporary Historical References."

And one of at least 10 cities Alexander The Great named after himself, in a geographical spread ranging from Egypt to Persia to Afghanistan to India. e.g., Alexandria Eschate ("The Furthest&quot was located in modern Tajikistan.

Yes, it's true that no written contemporary accounts of Alexander's life have survived, apart from a few fragments. (For that we can partly thank those wonderful folks who liked to burn "pagan" libraries.) But some of the ancient writers, like Arrian, named their sources. So we can be pretty sure they existed.

And like Caesar, Alexander invaded/pillaged a lot of places. Maybe "history is written by the victors," but the sore losers often have long memories about that sort of thing. (Ask a native of Atlanta, GA...) And they leave behind their own kind of evidence.

Speaking of evidence...what's this? A news story from January 2013...

Alexander the Great presence still felt in modern Afghanistan

http://www.isaf.nato.int/article/news/alexander-the-great-presence-still-felt-in-modern-afghanistan.html

(/pedant mode)




Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Ask him to support his claims with the evidence. cleanhippie Apr 2013 #1
Indeed, they always use Julius Caesar and Alexander the Great in that claim arcane1 Apr 2013 #2
I asked him to show me the money. OriginalGeek Apr 2013 #3
We do have a few of the Sumerian texts Warpy Apr 2013 #4
We don't have Paul's original copy of any letter he wrote, for example. Bolo Boffin Apr 2013 #5
simple answer? None. ChairmanAgnostic Apr 2013 #6
Seriously fascinating OriginalGeek Apr 2013 #7
How could there possibly more documentation for Jesus than Caesar? Ron Obvious Apr 2013 #8
this is what I got in reply: OriginalGeek Apr 2013 #9
Josephus Ron Obvious Apr 2013 #10
Time to pull up some quotes.... defacto7 Apr 2013 #25
one ancient scholar and biblical expert was famous for dissing ChairmanAgnostic Apr 2013 #30
Yep. He is parroting apologists nonsense that he has been fed. cleanhippie Apr 2013 #13
ANd he thinks he's thought of something new OriginalGeek Apr 2013 #14
Good luck. I had a close friend that went full-on fundie... cleanhippie Apr 2013 #15
"not only believe, but to try and get others to do so as well" FiveGoodMen Apr 2013 #17
LOL! Pulled that one out of their (Balaam's) asses... onager Apr 2013 #29
Your DU avatar is my youtube avatar. ZombieHorde Apr 2013 #26
Optical illusions... Ron Obvious Apr 2013 #27
When I first saw that illusion, I printed out several copies and cut out the labeled squares. ZombieHorde Apr 2013 #28
If your brother is into reading, Curmudgeoness Apr 2013 #11
I'll give it a try OriginalGeek Apr 2013 #12
The fundies have gone full-bore blasphemer on Ehrman Stuckinthebush Apr 2013 #33
Of course they would attack him. Curmudgeoness Apr 2013 #34
I've seen fragments of the Old Testament yellerpup Apr 2013 #16
The translation problem isn't really so serious. The NT was mainly written in Greek, and we dimbear Apr 2013 #18
Translators and scribes skepticscott Apr 2013 #19
A curious Christian should certainly have a hard look at the Gnostic gospels, which weren't in the dimbear Apr 2013 #20
gnostics were too cooperative, too communal, ChairmanAgnostic Apr 2013 #21
On a completely unrelated side note OriginalGeek Apr 2013 #23
There are no contemporary sources for the Jesus of the Bible. sakabatou Apr 2013 #22
As far as I know amuse bouche Apr 2013 #24
The notion that we have "original texts" is laughable Act_of_Reparation Apr 2013 #31
Note that Julius Caesar thought his ideas were worth the trouble of being written down. dimbear Apr 2013 #32
Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»Dumb question time: What...»Reply #29