2016 Postmortem
In reply to the discussion: Have we really reached a place where if you aren't a PoC [View all]elljay
(1,178 posts)I expect everyone to make up their own opinions and, if different from mine, that's ok. I also don't have a problem, as a Sanders supporter, with PoC saying that Bernie has not connected well with that community. He presents a very traditional left-wing/Socialist economic narrative that does not explicitly discuss race/religion/ethnicity but focuses on the economics that drive racial and economic disparity. I certainly understand why AAs/PoC want to hear these issues addressed directly, rather than indirectly and may not believe that Bernie has properly explained his positions. However, that in no way means that Bernie doesn't understand the issues and that he hasn't consistently supported them throughout his life; it is a matter of presentation. My, and other peoples', problem with John Lewis' statement is the implication that Bernie was lying about his support and actions for racial equality. Bernie did not claim to be a key figure in the struggle, to have worked with the leaders like Mr. Lewis, MLK, etc. and any statements he did make are very thoroughly documented and true. The fact that John Lewis didn't know him is probative only of the simple fact that Bernie and John never met. So, we are not at all attacking Lewis for his opinion about Hillary vs. Bernie - he may endorse whomever he chooses and there are many excellent factual reasons for his choosing Hillary. It is by crossing the line from fact to incorrect innuendo that he has laid himself open to very well-deserved criticism.