2016 Postmortem
In reply to the discussion: SLATE: Bernie Sanders Claims He’s a Longtime Champion of Marriage Equality. [View all]thesquanderer
(13,084 posts)re: "even under your scenario, he supported civil unions, then evolved into supporting gay marriage, which was the point of the OP article."
Really, I can't imagine anyone taking Bernie Sanders to task for supporting civil unions in 2000 on the basis that he should have been supporting gay marriage instead. Is that your position, are you actually criticizing him for his 2000 support of civil unions?
As I said earlier, it is silly to say that support for one means you couldn't have also supported the other. Many activists were supporters of civil unions, not because they were against gay marriage, but because they thought civil unions were a more immediately acheivable goal, so support for one didn't necessarily mean you didn't also support the other. As also evidenced by the poll numbers I posted, where clearly lots of people supported both, in the same poll.
Support for civil unions simply does not equate to being against gay marriage. And bragging that he supported civil unions in 2000 does not prove that he did or did not support gay marriage in 2000, in 2006, or today. And the only way you get to "did not" is by choosing to change the tense of his answer and then selectively apply it to the portion of the question you choose to apply it to. To me, that's the tortured interpretation!
If you watch the video and want to say he didn't clearly come out in favor of gay marriage when given the opportunity, fine, I'll give you that. But to watch that video and come away thinking that he was actually trying to say that he was against gay marriage is a real stretch, IMO. He certainly didn't criticize MA for doing it.