2016 Postmortem
In reply to the discussion: I continue to be utterly mystified. [View all]Nonhlanhla
(2,074 posts)Yes, I tied the public image of Hillary as mean, cold hearted, ruthless woman who will kill people out of sheer ambition, to decades-old sexist attacks on Hillary. Do you really want to dispute that?
I then said that I refuse to buy into that image of her when I look at her war vote. I DO criticize her war vote, but I am not willing to simply assume certain nefarious motivations on her side, because I realize that any such assumptions I might make will probably be shaped by the public image of her as ruthless, which comes from decades of right wing smears. Therefore I am going to start with the assumption that she was thoughtful about the vote, even though I think she was wrong. Just as I'm going to assume that Bernie was thoughtful with regards to his votes on crime or guns, even though I think he's wrong, since I'm not going to start with the assumption that he is badly-motivated.
I therefore adopt a stance of neutrality with regards to both of our front runners, and am willing to give BOTH of them the benefit of the doubt with regards to motivation even when I disagree with their votes.