Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Democratic Primaries
In reply to the discussion: Sanders' women and minority supporters say it's a false narrative that he only appeals to white, [View all]TexasTowelie
(128,150 posts)123. The article stated this:
Rodriguez said she became a US citizen in September 2015 and her support for Sanders was central to this.
I don't know about Mrs. Rodriguez's personal circumstances, but even if she had been in the most favorable circumstance (married to a U.S. citizen and meeting the residency requirements) and it took only six months from the date she applied to taking the oath with all of the steps along the pathway aligned perfectly with minimal delays, then it still would have meant that she filed the application in March 2015. That means that Bernie's candidacy was not central to her filing the application because Bernie had not announced his intentions and that there were other factors that influenced her to apply for citizenship as you mentioned.
However, in the statement that I highlighted Rodriguez is conflating her citizenship with her support for Bernie. In that case someone might ask did she swear a oath of allegiance to the U.S. or did she swear an oath of allegiance to Bernie? Considering that she was previously from Bolivia which is run by a socialist president, does it mean that she supports the current political, social, and economic status of the U.S. or does she want to change the U.S. so that it is more like Bolivia?
Rodriguez's own statement provides the ammunition for people to question her loyalty:
I actually became a citizen so I could vote for Bernie, Rodriguez said. I believe in him more than anyone else.
If I picked up on the inconsistencies in what was reported in the article as a lifelong Democrat, then imagine how that statement would get twisted and amplified by right-wing zealots in their anti-immigrant fervor. Mrs. Rodriguez created a credibility problem with her statements and she may have created a legal problem for herself if she lied when taking the oath of allegiance to the United States.
If Mrs. Rodriguez stated that she was a naturalized citizen and that she supported Bernie Sanders, then there wouldn't be an issue--she has the right to vote for whomever she chooses. However, when she links her decision to apply for citizenship based upon a candidacy that Bernie hadn't announced yet, then it raises questions--no crystal ball required.
primary today, I would vote for: Joe Biden
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
143 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Sanders' women and minority supporters say it's a false narrative that he only appeals to white, [View all]
melman
Mar 2019
OP
Me too, and I will not get into the fights that happen here. At least I hope.
rusty quoin
Mar 2019
#3
Frankly, I'm more interested in platform and policy over person and personality.
earthshine
Mar 2019
#4
I am interested in winning which is why I do not support Sen. Sanders in the primary.
Demsrule86
Mar 2019
#51
Me too!! But, that's ok... knowing Bernie keeps growing in popularity and will clean tRump's clock
InAbLuEsTaTe
Mar 2019
#76
The coolest... there's a reason Bernie had a historic, record campaign rollout.
InAbLuEsTaTe
Mar 2019
#78
Bullshit-It can be done in around six months if you have a green card and meet residency requirement
Hassin Bin Sober
Mar 2019
#36
That's in THEORY. The reality is much different. It is ovious you are not familiar with people who
lunamagica
Mar 2019
#118
Yeah, except for the immigrant who is being called a liar. She doesn't count?
Hassin Bin Sober
Mar 2019
#122
Mrs. Rodriguez created her own credbility problems with her own statements.
TexasTowelie
Mar 2019
#124
Seriousy...As if looking at things online was the same as living the reality. Please
lunamagica
Mar 2019
#119
I noticed that myself. It takes six months or more to become a citizen. April to September is...
George II
Mar 2019
#44
Did she say she became a US citizen in September 2015 so she could vote for Bernie in 2016?
Autumn
Mar 2019
#75
Without knowing more about Rodriguez's situation it isn't possible to offer many more comments.
TexasTowelie
Mar 2019
#126
WA Post, Feb 2019: "Bernie struggled to win black voters. It could be even worse in 2020."
pnwmom
Mar 2019
#11
Oh look, there's someone blaming the messenger for their candidate's shortcomings.
BannonsLiver
Mar 2019
#58
Oh, right. It's the WA Post's fault that Bernie alienates black people by saying stuff
pnwmom
Mar 2019
#69
What does Jeff Bezos have to do with what Eugene Scott writes in his WaPo column?
lapucelle
Mar 2019
#116
Nobody is saying he doesn't have *any* POC or non-millennial women supporting him.
Garrett78
Mar 2019
#12
I don't see this Watson guy or anyone else saying that Sanders has zero support...
Garrett78
Mar 2019
#17
I don't link to or support Jill Stein acolytes like Tim Black and Anthony Zenkus or their admirers.
lapucelle
Mar 2019
#100
Says the author of the infamous (and odious) Not good enough, Bernie!!" thread??
stranger81
Mar 2019
#136
You posted in the thread commenting on the tweet before the troll was banned and
Autumn
Mar 2019
#121
Actually, the OP I replied to claims that people are saying Sanders only appeals to white people.
Garrett78
Mar 2019
#31
Look at the subject line of the OP, it says "only". That is equivalent to "any".
George II
Mar 2019
#53
Yet, speaking from experience you will take a person to task for using a word that's different
Autumn
Mar 2019
#62
Why am I undecided? I'm waiting to hear more from Inslee, who was great on the View this
Autumn
Mar 2019
#98
As I noted elsewhere, there's Susan Sarandon, Nina Turner, Cornell West, and Killer Mike!!!
George II
Mar 2019
#45
What's your point? That 1-1/2 year old "study" was published long before Mueller concluded....
George II
Mar 2019
#141
Brooklyn is 49.5% white, 35.8% black. That crowd doesn't represent the demographics of Brooklyn.
George II
Mar 2019
#30
I think C-SPAN was still covering the Jubilee Sunday events in Selma last night. N/T
lapucelle
Mar 2019
#86
No disputes that some women and POC support Sen. Sanders but is it enough? I don't think so.
Demsrule86
Mar 2019
#47