Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Democratic Primaries
Showing Original Post only (View all)Harris: My Plan is So 'Superior' To Warren's MFA That 'I Don't Feel the Need' to Take it Apart [View all]
Video at the link:
https://www.mediaite.com/news/kamala-harris-my-plan-is-so-superior-to-warrens-medicare-for-all-that-i-dont-feel-the-need-to-take-it-apart/
On Thursday mornings edition of MSNBCs Morning Joe, former Obama official and MJ regular Steve Rattner spent a portion of the show laying out his objections to Warrens recently-released plan to fund her Medicare for All plan, and when Senator Harris sat for an interview later in the show, co-host Willie Geist asked about those objections.
Steve walked through the charts suggesting that the numbers dont add up, not suggesting but proving that they dont add up, Geist said, and asked For people who dont pay attention closely, whats the distinction between Elizabeth Warrens plan and your plan to change the healthcare system?
Im not taking away peoples private plan options, Harris replied, adding that I supported Medicare for all at the beginning of the process, and I heard from people. And they said, we want choice.
-snip-
So you say you will not raise taxes on the middle class, Elizabeth Warren has said the same, Geist said. Do you believe she is telling the truth, with that 34 trillion dollars of new revenue shell have to find?
I think the voters will make that decision, Harris replied.
-snip-
Rattner then cut in, telling Harris he appreciated her focus on a positive campaign, but added what people come to me and say is Why arent the other Democrats pointing this out? Why arent the other Democrats doing in effect what Im doing, which is taking apart her numbers and showing that the numbers dont work? So why arent you and your fellow Democrats taking apart her numbers and showing that they dont work?
I am so convinced that my plan is superior to that plan that I dont really feel the need to do that, Harris replied. I am really convinced, and I know that we have done the work on my plan. I am not going to take away peoples choice about having a public or a private plan, I am going to give people a transition that allows folks like organized labor to actually renegotiate their contract.
But shes going to add 34 trillion dollars of spending that she hasnt paid for, and doesnt the public have a right to understand that from people like you? Rattner pressed.
Absolutely, and Im glad youve done that work Steve, Harris said with a laugh.
-snip-
Steve walked through the charts suggesting that the numbers dont add up, not suggesting but proving that they dont add up, Geist said, and asked For people who dont pay attention closely, whats the distinction between Elizabeth Warrens plan and your plan to change the healthcare system?
Im not taking away peoples private plan options, Harris replied, adding that I supported Medicare for all at the beginning of the process, and I heard from people. And they said, we want choice.
-snip-
So you say you will not raise taxes on the middle class, Elizabeth Warren has said the same, Geist said. Do you believe she is telling the truth, with that 34 trillion dollars of new revenue shell have to find?
I think the voters will make that decision, Harris replied.
-snip-
Rattner then cut in, telling Harris he appreciated her focus on a positive campaign, but added what people come to me and say is Why arent the other Democrats pointing this out? Why arent the other Democrats doing in effect what Im doing, which is taking apart her numbers and showing that the numbers dont work? So why arent you and your fellow Democrats taking apart her numbers and showing that they dont work?
I am so convinced that my plan is superior to that plan that I dont really feel the need to do that, Harris replied. I am really convinced, and I know that we have done the work on my plan. I am not going to take away peoples choice about having a public or a private plan, I am going to give people a transition that allows folks like organized labor to actually renegotiate their contract.
But shes going to add 34 trillion dollars of spending that she hasnt paid for, and doesnt the public have a right to understand that from people like you? Rattner pressed.
Absolutely, and Im glad youve done that work Steve, Harris said with a laugh.
-snip-
primary today, I would vote for: Joe Biden
44 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Harris: My Plan is So 'Superior' To Warren's MFA That 'I Don't Feel the Need' to Take it Apart [View all]
highplainsdem
Nov 2019
OP
Sen Warren will either prepare for Rattner and Harris' talking points or she will not. She knows
Ninga
Nov 2019
#1
You complain about my "Warren bashing" but 4 of your last 5 OPs were bashing Biden:
highplainsdem
Nov 2019
#8
Hey!!! Thx highplainsdem.... some posters just don't have anything positive to say
Thekaspervote
Nov 2019
#14
The bashing of Biden daily by Warren supporters mostly is undeniable. And somewhat humorous.
Demsrule86
Nov 2019
#28
LOL! Of course it disproves your point. But I wouldn't expect you to ever admit it.
highplainsdem
Nov 2019
#44
You have bashed Biden more than almost any other Warren supporter...so too bad if you
Demsrule86
Nov 2019
#17
It is bashing and it was kind of ironic today with some supporter all worried about how Something
Demsrule86
Nov 2019
#25
I've posted a lot already about why I believe MFA would be a disaster in the GE, why the public
highplainsdem
Nov 2019
#12
It seems to me that Harris was going after Warren...not the OP... who only repeated her words.
Demsrule86
Nov 2019
#29
The OP presented a news story about what Harris had to say, which was actually not an attack
emmaverybo
Nov 2019
#30
That has been done and ignored ....remaking the entire health care system from scratch
Demsrule86
Nov 2019
#26