Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
Joe BidenCongratulations to our presumptive Democratic nominee, Joe Biden!
 

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
1. Welcome to DU. :) I thought this'd be about the census.
Sat Mar 30, 2019, 10:59 AM
Mar 2019

THAT is the revolutionary power that either will serve representative democracy OR the Republicans will harness to overset it further.

We got a good start on influencing it for good in the midterms, but 2020 will either open the gates to a new era of greatness and widespread prosperity of a progressive liberal republic OR build on and consolidate the power cemented in with the 2010 census of the increasingly authoritarian white male Christian supremacist party.

As for your idea, interesting, but I'm afraid offering a cabinet before being elected president, much less before the primary election, doesn't strike me as even remotely possible. Or desirable. The best qualified and in-demand people simply would not commit to being used by one candidate to try to get elected, becoming identified with policies and processes that may not actually represent their beliefs, and in the process slamming the door on serving whoever was elected (along with a prechosen cabinet). People of top stature don't have to and most wouldn't. This would lead to most or all candidates having to name a bunch of opportunistic, (at best) second-stringers.

As for the future of that first candidate who'd presumably "force" the others to follow suit, I'm guessing it could be very ugly. The other candidates might instead choose to just watch as swiftboaters working for opponents smeared dozens of virtual unknowns to attack the candidates themselves and obscure their agendas. And what about when the cabinet appointees become future declinations 2 years later, as would happen?

The opportunities for partisan ugliness and voter manipulation seem endless to me. Because the majority of people don't bother to properly (thoroughly and honestly to themselves!) vet any presidential candidates, even the one they end up voting for. They're going to do their homework on dozens of faceless people for each?

But, that's just my reaction. Is there any nation that does this, and how has it worked out?

If I were to vote in a presidential
primary today, I would vote for:
Joe Biden

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Welcome to DU. :) I thought this'd be about the census. Hortensis Mar 2019 #1
I don't know if other countries have tried this. Luvapottamus Mar 2019 #2
But they could all ask the same people to serve. Hortensis Mar 2019 #3
I could list poorly selected democrat cabinet members Luvapottamus Mar 2019 #4
You mean Democratic cabinet members. MrsCoffee Mar 2019 #5
Oops Luvapottamus Mar 2019 #6
Please DO and post here. Truth is allowable under the TOS Hortensis Mar 2019 #7
Revolving Door Luvapottamus Mar 2019 #8
These both result from ideological and goal positions Hortensis Mar 2019 #9
You're moving the goalpost. Luvapottamus Mar 2019 #10
Hortensis didn't move the goal posts mcar Mar 2019 #11
And: Luvapottamus Mar 2019 #12
Again.... ehrnst Apr 2019 #26
Parliamentary systems usually have an opposition "Shadow Cabinet" of policy experts... brooklynite Apr 2019 #22
Why this is a Golden Opportunity Luvapottamus Mar 2019 #13
What "traditional campaign" are voters "sick of?" ehrnst Apr 2019 #15
Reinhold Richard "Reince" Priebus Luvapottamus Apr 2019 #16
No idea what Priebus has to do with your answer concerning elections. ehrnst Apr 2019 #18
Per forum rules Luvapottamus Apr 2019 #20
"How come we can't beat George W. Bush or Donald Trump in a LANDSLIDE? " ehrnst Apr 2019 #21
We lost those elections. Luvapottamus Apr 2019 #24
So if that's such a simple way to win by a landslide, why has no one done that? ehrnst Apr 2019 #25
I am reminded of the Lone Ranger joke that ends- rzemanfl Apr 2019 #27
No, they DON'T traditionally choose a defeated Primary opponent. brooklynite Apr 2019 #23
Warren, Beto, Bernie Luvapottamus Mar 2019 #14
Pete Buttigieg Luvapottamus Apr 2019 #17
Cory Booker Luvapottamus Apr 2019 #19
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Democratic Primaries»2020 is a Golden Opportun...»Reply #1