Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: 3 clip magazines max [View all]

moriah

(8,311 posts)
6. It makes sense, but sadly 3 for all guns wouldn't work.
Thu Feb 22, 2018, 03:08 PM
Feb 2018

The five capacity magazine limit for any long gun platform set in Canada and several states in the US (only for hunting, though, which shows the inanity of people sometimes -- deer have more protection than kids) means that's the smallest magazine probably available and manufactured enough to become a standard.

With handgun magazines, 7-8 is the standard size for a single stack 1911-style pistol's magazine (Kimber's cut-down to handle 9mm vs .45 ACP in that style holds 8, their .45s hold 7). I don't know what most plastic handguns come with standard, but there's probably a current standard that couldn't be exceeded we could find -- essentially, the factory magazine capacity only. I think 10 is a good number and there are probably people who shoot plastic handguns who could tell me what standard mag was on the one they bought and if a 10 limit would make it illegal from the factory.

Someone else in another post showed the huge difference between what even a .45 can do compared to a .223 cartridge fired from a rifle. We NEED rifle magazine restrictions, no doubt, and handgun magazines no larger than standard.

But we also have to look at industry standards on what would actually pass.

Edit to add: I really want us to go full Canada and require registration and background checks for ammunition purchases, and for ammunition makers to be required to serialize their casings, because ammo degrades faster than guns and while it might still take 15-20 years before everyone goes through their stockpiles, eventually controlling access to and tracking ammunition purchases, along with serialization, will make tracking of people responsible for gun crimes easier than targeting the guns themselves. Magazine limits are the *minimum* I'm willing to settle for.

3 clip magazines max [View all] SHRED Feb 2018 OP
Turned in for verified destruction, or felony samir.g Feb 2018 #1
Gitmo SHRED Feb 2018 #2
Gitmo, Leavenworth, whatever samir.g Feb 2018 #3
What the fuck Crabby Appleton Feb 2018 #4
Okay...you know what I mean SHRED Feb 2018 #5
Lol, I was wondering the same thing Drahthaardogs Feb 2018 #9
Yuck yuck yuck SHRED Feb 2018 #14
I really don't, considering a non-magnum bolt action rifle magazine Drahthaardogs Feb 2018 #16
I see SHRED Feb 2018 #17
Then it's probably more polite to say that it's idealistic but not practical. moriah Feb 2018 #18
It makes sense, but sadly 3 for all guns wouldn't work. moriah Feb 2018 #6
What do you define as a weapon of war? Marengo Feb 2018 #7
The kind with clips in magazines pintobean Feb 2018 #10
Look, you can mock people's terminology all you want, but... moriah Feb 2018 #13
This isnt directed at you, but equally as unhelpful is the implication that firearms knowldege is.. Marengo Feb 2018 #20
Meh, we have these discussions every couple of months. pintobean Feb 2018 #24
i feel a 10 shot clip would be a good starting point! bluestarone Feb 2018 #8
What do you mean by full automatic? Marengo Feb 2018 #11
Fully automatics have had restrictions since 1934. yagotme Feb 2018 #12
right i mean semi ONLY no way to make them fully auto bluestarone Feb 2018 #15
John M. Browning made a semi-auto rifle out of a lever action yagotme Feb 2018 #32
If you want to have a say in how something is regulated, you need to understand how it works. WhiskeyGrinder Feb 2018 #19
Magazines can be 3D printed by any number of technologies out there. Calista241 Feb 2018 #21
By "good luck" you really don't mean "good luck" it sounds SHRED Feb 2018 #25
It will be like the drug war, prohibition, or any other law that is Calista241 Feb 2018 #48
So, how would you prevent that from happening? TheSmarterDog Feb 2018 #50
I just think they're here to stay. Calista241 Feb 2018 #53
So, no suggestions then. TheSmarterDog Feb 2018 #54
Beware the gun nerds. mac56 Feb 2018 #22
I'm well aware thanks SHRED Feb 2018 #23
Then say 3 bullets when you mean 3 bullets. pintobean Feb 2018 #26
Holy shit SHRED Feb 2018 #28
I assumed you wanted to be taken seriously. pintobean Feb 2018 #33
Seriously SHRED Feb 2018 #39
Seriously pintobean Feb 2018 #41
Amazing that many understood SHRED Feb 2018 #42
Don't you mean "rounds"? ProudLib72 Feb 2018 #30
Round round we go. pintobean Feb 2018 #37
Dont you mean rounds? Bullets are the projectile portion of the round. Hmm? Hassin Bin Sober Feb 2018 #38
You'll have to ask shred pintobean Feb 2018 #44
Rounds, cartridges, bullets, suppositories. Everyone knows what he meant expect for obfuscating gun- Hoyt Feb 2018 #51
Why not just make it one round and be done with it? SlimJimmy Feb 2018 #34
not rocket science but if that was the case, even less would care beachbum bob Feb 2018 #27
Yeah I've actually just removed that sentence SHRED Feb 2018 #29
in the underground world of white militias which have MILLIONS of members across america is beachbum bob Feb 2018 #35
When hunting deer, I never used more than one shot. MineralMan Feb 2018 #31
Yep SHRED Feb 2018 #40
Confirms that both extreme ends of the bell curve have similar denizens aka-chmeee Feb 2018 #36
What does hunting have to do with anything? EL34x4 Feb 2018 #43
The second amendment is an ugly relic just like the three-fifths of a person rule. hunter Feb 2018 #45
Oh SHRED, modern "hunters" use 4-wheelers and SUVs. joshcryer Feb 2018 #46
Gun ownership database and you buy it you own it...PERIOD. Lots can be done without 'infringing' on Kirk Lover Feb 2018 #47
You want to confiscate my legally purchased items with no grandfathering huh Calculating Feb 2018 #49
Right. The 2nd Amendment is about national defense. TheSmarterDog Feb 2018 #52
Lots of "gunsplaining" in here johnpowdy Feb 2018 #55
Gunhumpers cling to semantics, I have noted. LexVegas Feb 2018 #56
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»3 clip magazines max»Reply #6