General Discussion

Eliot Rosewater

(34,285 posts)

19. Over what?

Thu May 31, 2018, 04:59 PM

May 2018

I think I remember now, and he was wrong there.

He does try to be consistent though, he pisses me off all the time especially when he insults his audience for not thinking he is funny.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

151 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Who will Bill Maher defend more tomorrow? [View all] Trumpocalypse May 2018 OP

Pretty good guess I'd say. OnDoutside May 2018 #1

No. What Roseanne wrote was not a joke There was no setup, no provocation, no satire. Just harmful. TheBlackAdder May 2018 #33

I agree with you. Rosanne's comments was meant to be hurtful and vile... Raster May 2018 #35

Maher doesn't always think that way though. OnDoutside May 2018 #38

I want to be absolutely filthy with my response. joshcryer May 2018 #2

Bill and other comedians have watched stand up be greatly harmed by Eliot Rosewater May 2018 #3

Bet $50 bucks he does Trumpocalypse May 2018 #9

He may have some defense of Roseanne and sometimes it is personal but usually Eliot Rosewater May 2018 #12

He defended Laura Ingraham Trumpocalypse May 2018 #18

Over what? Eliot Rosewater May 2018 #19

This message was self-deleted by its author Trumpocalypse May 2018 #14

Oops! betsuni Jun 2018 #75

That was several weeks ago Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #79

And last night's show was different how? betsuni Jun 2018 #82

Well it was after her racist tweet Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #84

No he didn't. betsuni Jun 2018 #87

Yes he did Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #91

He brought up more than once. betsuni Jun 2018 #98

Laugh all you want Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #99

He spent the whole show ripping her and this is your reaction? Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #105

Whole show? Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #109

Try and watch it for the examples I gave Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #112

I did Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #115

You didn't hear the quotes I gave? Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #118

No he didn't Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #122

You must not be familiar with him Bradshaw3 May 2018 #4

He was ahead of the curve... lame54 May 2018 #5

I am familiar with him defending conservatives Trumpocalypse May 2018 #10

He doesn't "defend" conservatives - he defends free speech Bradshaw3 May 2018 #29

Bill's language is on a par with Samantha's, so I see no reason why he would disparage her. dameatball May 2018 #6

Didn't say that he would. Trumpocalypse May 2018 #11

You going to come back to this thread if you're wrong? Bradshaw3 May 2018 #30

Actually your OP specifically mentions Bee or I probably wouldn't have commented on her. dameatball May 2018 #32

I think he will do like he did in April when it comes Barr. Hoyt May 2018 #7

He will tread lightly, many on both sides would like to see him silenced Va Lefty May 2018 #8

If you watched his show, you'd know. Iggo May 2018 #13

I've watched his show and seen him defend Laura Ingraham, Trumpocalypse May 2018 #16

And did you see him defend Roseanne Barr for being a Trumper? Iggo May 2018 #17

This is not about being a Trumper. Trumpocalypse May 2018 #21

You've got your narrative. Have fun with it. Iggo May 2018 #37

Yes it is called reality. Trumpocalypse May 2018 #41

What I have fun with.... quickesst Jun 2018 #102

Well said leftynyc Jun 2018 #120

Agreed quickesst Jun 2018 #141

There is another distinction between Barr & Bee MichMan Jun 2018 #76

I think Samantha Bee leftynyc May 2018 #15

But he's defended racists in the past. Trumpocalypse May 2018 #22

No he hasn't defended racists Bradshaw3 May 2018 #31

He defending Don Imus Trumpocalypse May 2018 #40

Again, defending free seech is NOT defending racists Bradshaw3 May 2018 #43

No, but arguing that they shouldn't face Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #46

Last night he agreed they should face consequences Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #104

Yeah, he nodded his head Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #108

You're going to have to provide leftynyc May 2018 #39

He defended Don Imus Trumpocalypse May 2018 #42

How? leftynyc Jun 2018 #44

Sure anyone has the right to be an Ahole Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #45

I'm a first amendment leftynyc Jun 2018 #51

And the 1st amendment is only a Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #53

I understand that leftynyc Jun 2018 #57

And should public and private corporations be forced to support hate speech? Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #58

Exactly leftynyc Jun 2018 #61

There is another big distinction between the two MichMan Jun 2018 #77

I see your point. Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #100

Public schools are considered part of govt for the spooky3 Jun 2018 #101

He criticized Roseanne not long ago for lunatica May 2018 #20

He supported Don Imus for making a racist joke. Trumpocalypse May 2018 #23

That was decades ago lunatica May 2018 #25

Only one decade. Trumpocalypse May 2018 #26

Both are great examples lunatica May 2018 #34

He Did NOT Defend Laura Ingraham ProfessorGAC Jun 2018 #48

Criticizing the backlash is defending her. Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #52

No, It Is Not ProfessorGAC Jun 2018 #56

Yes it is. Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #60

Totally false claim - and he didn't last night Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #106

Not false at all. Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #111

Totally false characterization of his postion Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #114

Not false Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #124

No Rosanne defense. When ABC unloaded her and gave up millions, oasis May 2018 #24

ABC fired Maher too. Trumpocalypse May 2018 #27

Maher was "perceived" as praising the bravery of the 9/11 terrororists. oasis May 2018 #28

Maher has no love for quick hook ABC Johonny May 2018 #36

This message was self-deleted by its author disillusioned73 Jun 2018 #47

A question only someone who doesn't know Bill Maher would ask. betsuni Jun 2018 #49

+1 BannonsLiver Jun 2018 #50

No a question from someone who Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #54

Wrong. You are wrong. betsuni Jun 2018 #55

Sure Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #59

I have no idea. But I guaran-damn-tee you he'll tell the right wing guest how brave they are for Guy Whitey Corngood Jun 2018 #62

The important thing is that you find additional targets of opportunity. LanternWaste Jun 2018 #63

So you can't defend Maher Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #64

And the answer is, of course, that nobody on the show defended Roseanne. betsuni Jun 2018 #65

No but Maher tried to give her a pass Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #67

No he didn't. betsuni Jun 2018 #69

Then why did he bring it up? Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #70

What? Bill Maher is a comedian. He makes jokes. betsuni Jun 2018 #71

Sure that was a joke Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #73

What? Brought it up later in the discussion when? betsuni Jun 2018 #74

When they discussed it on Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #78

LOL betsuni Jun 2018 #81

The results are in BannonsLiver Jun 2018 #66

I love when people who don't (or shouldn't) watch a show.... RhodeIslandOne Jun 2018 #68

+1 betsuni Jun 2018 #72

Yes I saw the show Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #92

He'll defend Dinesh Cartoonist Jun 2018 #80

No he won't. betsuni Jun 2018 #83

Here I agree with you :-) Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #126

And, we have our answer. Crunchy Frog Jun 2018 #85

And said it was due to mental illnesses Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #93

There was no defense of her. Crunchy Frog Jun 2018 #123

No defense of the statement Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #125

Sam Bee's show hasn't been cancelled. Crunchy Frog Jun 2018 #129

That's a qualified statement. Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #133

Heh. Sucks to be wrong, huh? LexVegas Jun 2018 #86

How? Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #94

He didn't support her. What show were you watching? Hoyt Jun 2018 #132

And he repeated Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #134

So what? We attribute trump's problems to mental illness, that ain't supporting him. You were wrong, Hoyt Jun 2018 #135

I don't Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #138

So, no apology for being wrong? betsuni Jun 2018 #88

I wasn't Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #95

Yes you were and no he didn't phleshdef Jun 2018 #127

Nothing to be embarrassed about Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #130

He didn't defend her at all. He said her comments were abhorrent. phleshdef Jun 2018 #143

Don't accuse me of lying Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #144

I criticize the fuck out of Bill Maher for his instances of Islamophobia and sticking his foot... phleshdef Jun 2018 #145

He condemned the comment Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #146

Wrong. betsuni Jun 2018 #147

Right Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #148

You know, you should thank me for kicking your wrong post. betsuni Jun 2018 #150

OK then Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #151

You owe Bill an apology, and should self delete this post IMO. nt USALiberal Jun 2018 #89

Why? Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #96

Weren't you quoting bill Maher to me a while back over something I didn't even say? LostOne4Ever Jun 2018 #90

I don't play team politics Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #97

I hope you return and admit you were wrong Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #103

I wasn't Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #107

Total and complete lie Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #110

He never attacked Barr Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #113

Then refute the exampes I gave Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #116

I don't need to refute them Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #117

Good grief Bradshaw3 Jun 2018 #119

With you maybe. Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #121

Or most of the people who responded to this thread. phleshdef Jun 2018 #128

No Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #131

He may well defend Barr. I'm okay with that. bitterross Jun 2018 #136

Thanks for an intelligent post. Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #139

The show aired Friday night (6/1) BannonsLiver Jun 2018 #142

This thread resembles the Argument Clinic. Crunchy Frog Jun 2018 #137

A Python classic, 😂 Trumpocalypse Jun 2018 #140

The result of this episode and this thread really highlight one thing Blue_Adept Jun 2018 #149