General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: You Can't Get Conservative White Women To Change Their Minds [View all]Hortensis
(58,785 posts)synonymous. They are not. AND as if all conservatives were the same. They are not.
I'm in no way defending the choices of those who've voted for Trump AND of most of those in elective office these days. The Republican Party has been on a downward slide into political depravity and corruption for a long time now.
But even in normal times, much less now, many people here have no more tried to learn about what conservatives believe in and how and why they react than the most conservatives have bothered to educate themselves about what liberals believe and why we make the choices we do. For those indulging in both sides, understanding is rejected and what they want to believe embraced, often proudly and passionately, even if not even close to true.
This is an essay from a moderate conservative who holds views on both sides of the spectrum depending on issue about the kind of treatment he might receive at Thanksgiving from a "Crazy Uncle Al" if he was stupid enough to engage in political discussion with him. Significantly, note that this fairly reasonable, intelligent man ascribes this behavior only to those who actually engage in it, in his experience most typically some on the farther left, not to all. I don't quite agree with how he characterizes left wing views, but we'd have little trouble understanding each other.
Before I ventured into the realm of Mad Mikes America I had never really considered political bigotry. I sort of knew it existed all I had to do was listen to politicians and there it was smacking me in the face but it didnt affect me in the slightest. I tended to ignore it. Not always I have to admit as, sometimes, it was difficult to ignore it as it could, from time to time, annoy me enough for me to get mildly irritated or even, on occasion, downright angry.
Political bigotry is not, by any stretch of the imagination, entirely the province of the right wing either. That, more than anything, is what has surprised me the most really.
I always, clearly naively, assumed that bigotry tended to be a right wing ethos whether against someone of a different colour or ethnicity or religion or whatever it may be.
Finding out that those of a more left wing political persuasion can also be bigoted has, I freely admit, come as something of a surprise to me.
A recent commenter pointed out that he was surprised, given my right of centre credentials, that I was alarmed at the prospect of a President Trump. His surprise was actually a surprise to me. Trump is not right of centre he is just a nutcase. If he qualifies as anywhere on the right then, frankly, hes probably fallen off the edge.
Politically I can be right of centre but, equally, I can be left of centre. It depends entirely on the topic in question. In fact I dont consider myself right or left or, indeed, anything politically. I am, by nature, quite a pragmatic person. Being pragmatic however does mean that if I think someone of the left or the right is talking tosh then I will say so.
If someone wants to pigeon hole me there isnt much I can do about it.
A regular commenter, Cherries, for example is clearly under the impression that I am a 21st Century version of Attila The Hun or someone of that ilk. Personally I couldnt care less and consider her Ive always assumed its a her anyway probably the most bigoted left wing person Ive come across.
To me, your views are your views. If your views are that you deny the Holocaust happened then your views are insane and there is no point whatsoever debating or discussing with you.
If your views are that mass immigration is great then there is little point in debating with you as the moment anyone does you will, if you are so entrenched in your views, call them racists or xenophobes and, as I have discovered, no amount of gentle suggestion at intelligent debate will stop the screeching and rabid bigotry.
I am slowly coming to the conclusion that democratic politics may actually be in its death throes at the moment. Recovery is starting to seem unlikely as the polarisation of views is reaching a stage where the actual idea of sensible debate and an exchange of views is becoming increasingly difficult if not impossible.
This, I believe, is due to the increasing bigotry of both left and right. Both sides are determined that their view of the world in general is correct therefore the opposite argument is the spawn of Satan or something like that.
I will give you an example.
I have, on more than one occasion, ridiculed Trump regarding his wall across the Mexican border. Its a stupid idea. By the same token I have consistently stated that it is my belief that mass immigration into any nation will always be an unmitigated disaster.
Some seem to have failed to realise the nuances and my opposition to any type of mass immigration makes me the bastard brother of Sarah Palin. Ludicrous.
If I was racist or xenophobic I assume I would be rabidly against anyone coming to Britain who wasnt born here and was white. I assume I would be a fully paid up member of some far right party.
For some reason, some have pointed to UKIP as said far right party. Firstly, I am not and have never been a member of UKIP. I have voted for them as a protest vote but I have also, in my past, voted both Labour and Conservative. I have also voted for a couple of independent candidates locally. One was particularly keen on protecting the environment.
It seems to me that it is not fashionable to be pragmatic any more. If you do not nail your flag to the pole of either the left or the right then you get it in the neck from both sides for being a racist, xenophobic, environment hating, capitalist (left) along with being an immigrant lover, traitor to your country, left wing tree hugger, and etc.
Oh well.
I will just carry on being a racist, xenophobic, environment hating, capitalistic, immigrant loving, traitor to my country whilst hugging trees and did I mention loving animals as well?
What I will never be is a bigot.
I leave that to the far left and far right.
Extremism isnt my cup of tea.
Democratic politics is under threat. Freedom of speech is under threat. Our right to hold and express an opinion is under threat. The right to express an opinion that may offend someone is under threat.
The above is not under threat from ISIS. Its under threat from our very own left and right mainly because they dont like it if you have the audacity to hold an independent view that doesnt happen to coincide with theirs.
https://madmikesamerica.com/2016/06/the-dangers-of-political-bigotry/