General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: "libertarianism" [View all]DirtEdonE
(1,220 posts)I posted the link for explanation. Here are partial excerpts. Much more at the link below.
1. Libertarian values are repellent--Libertarianism celebrates greed and selfishness. Of course not all libertarians follow Ayn Rand in saying that openly, but thats really what its all about. Am I being unfair? After all, libertarians sincerely believe in the wonders of free markets, and it just happens that greed and selfishness work well with free markets. So, you might argue, libertarians dont necessarily have different values from you and me, just different beliefs about what works and what doesnt. I dont buy that. The plain fact is, libertarians by and large are simply not much bothered by social and economic inequality: their hearts bleed for the rich and successful, not for the underprivileged.
2. Libertarianism is intellectually myopic--Libertarians cherish freedom above all, but their concept of freedom is constricted and myopic. They understand freedom almost exclusively in terms of freedom from government, not recognizing that unfettered capitalism--the libertarians beloved free market economy--can be as great a threat to freedom as government action.
3. Libertarianism is utopian--An active state is a universal feature of advanced societies. The minimal government society that libertarians envision doesnt exist anywhere in the industrial or post-industrial world, and never has, for good reason. Advanced capitalism simply doesnt function without a fairly active, interventionist public sector.
4. Libertarianism is politically hopeless--You might well agree with me on the three preceding points but still feel that libertarianism has to be reckoned with politically--hasnt Ron Paul shown that his creed has real popular appeal? My short answer would be that Pauls ability to garner the vote of 20% of Iowa and New Hampshire Republican Party enthusiasts says very close to nothing about libertarianisms mass appeal. My longer answer is that libertarians can never achieve mass appeal because libertarians, unlike conservatives, are hobbled by their principled consistency. Libertarian and conservative economic programs basically serve the interests of a relatively small portion of the population.
https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2012/1/17/1055627/-