Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: "libertarianism" [View all]
 

DirtEdonE

(1,220 posts)
36. I'll post them from the link
Wed Apr 17, 2019, 07:17 PM
Apr 2019

I posted the link for explanation. Here are partial excerpts. Much more at the link below.

1. Libertarian values are repellent--Libertarianism celebrates greed and selfishness. Of course not all libertarians follow Ayn Rand in saying that openly, but that’s really what it’s all about. Am I being unfair? After all, libertarians sincerely believe in the wonders of free markets, and it just happens that greed and selfishness work well with free markets. So, you might argue, libertarians don’t necessarily have different values from you and me, just different beliefs about what works and what doesn’t. I don’t buy that. The plain fact is, libertarians by and large are simply not much bothered by social and economic inequality: their hearts bleed for the rich and successful, not for the underprivileged.

2. Libertarianism is intellectually myopic--Libertarians cherish freedom above all, but their concept of freedom is constricted and myopic. They understand freedom almost exclusively in terms of freedom from government, not recognizing that unfettered capitalism--the libertarians’ beloved free market economy--can be as great a threat to freedom as government action.

3. Libertarianism is utopian--An active state is a universal feature of advanced societies. The minimal government society that libertarians envision doesn’t exist anywhere in the industrial or post-industrial world, and never has, for good reason. Advanced capitalism simply doesn’t function without a fairly active, interventionist public sector.

4. Libertarianism is politically hopeless--You might well agree with me on the three preceding points but still feel that libertarianism has to be reckoned with politically--hasn’t Ron Paul shown that his creed has real popular appeal? My short answer would be that Paul’s ability to garner the vote of 20% of Iowa and New Hampshire Republican Party enthusiasts says very close to nothing about libertarianism’s mass appeal. My longer answer is that libertarians can never achieve mass appeal because libertarians, unlike conservatives, are hobbled by their principled consistency. Libertarian and conservative economic programs basically serve the interests of a relatively small portion of the population.

https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2012/1/17/1055627/-

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

"libertarianism" [View all] DirtEdonE Apr 2019 OP
I read a comment Ohiogal Apr 2019 #1
Yep. And yet today we have members here who identify as libertarian. DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #2
I've used that one many times... Wounded Bear Apr 2019 #5
libertarianism, like republicanism, sounds more like a mental disease than anything else. nt DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #10
Libertarians believe no one lives downstream. WTF? n/t TygrBright Apr 2019 #3
Wrong. Greedy objectivists don't care about downstream because they are not libertarians. Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #9
You seem to be a real defender of the "libertarian" cause DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #11
tRump is not a libertarian or even an Objectivist. He is a gordito. Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #14
You write: "if you ever grow up". Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #15
I seem to have struck a discord with your unflailing "libertarian" mental miasma DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #20
My "mental miasma", huh. And "discord" does not mean what you think it does. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #21
Bernardo de La Paz ... DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #24
Nope. Not at all. Not one bit. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #31
Yep. He's the Lunar Bernardo de La Galt. Moonchild of ayn rand. DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #38
You are trolling. You are wrong. The character specifically states in the novel he is NOT a Randite. Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #40
"libertarian" equals "randite" IMO DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #41
It's not disagreement. It's the WAY you disagree. DU members will read & know. nt Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #42
LOL - how can anyone tell someone else how to disagree? DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #43
The OP completely misunderstands libertarianism, sets up straw man and knocks it down with fallacies Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #4
Yawn. nt DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #6
You're right-- the two are often confused but libertarianism is all about freedom of thought... TreasonousBastard Apr 2019 #12
"libertarians" in America today have as much to do with their pure philosophy DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #16
Many who call themselves libertarian have, but that's no reason to... TreasonousBastard Apr 2019 #19
ayn rand spread more misinformation about it than I ever could. DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #22
Two wrongs don't make a right. Stop spreading the disinformation. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #32
Oh man. Defending ayn rand! DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #35
I'm not defending Ayn Rand, as all readers here can see. You are just trolling. Stop. . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #37
Now you speak for "all readers"? DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #39
read the virtues of selfishness by rand with an open mind. Kurt V. Apr 2019 #7
I remember seeing the rand interview with Mike Wallace DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #8
Believe it or not, a lot of people have no clue who Ayn Rand was FakeNoose Apr 2019 #13
Could you get me an introduction to this "The Left"? TygrBright Apr 2019 #17
You have to realize, it's a "libertarian" chart DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #25
You'll have to ask a Libertarian FakeNoose Apr 2019 #26
It's what comes from trying to Igel Apr 2019 #33
Yes, many self-styled Libertarians are not libertarians (small ell). . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Apr 2019 #18
Libertarianism is like communism qazplm135 Apr 2019 #28
+1 Kurt V. Apr 2019 #34
libertarians: even dumber than republicans if that can be imagined. KG Apr 2019 #23
repubicans love libertarians DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #27
If we all take care of ourselves, what happens to Hortensis Apr 2019 #29
I too reject libertarianism vlyons Apr 2019 #30
I'll post them from the link DirtEdonE Apr 2019 #36
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»"libertarianism"»Reply #36