Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

NRaleighLiberal

(60,014 posts)
Thu Oct 15, 2020, 11:09 PM Oct 2020

Slate "It Took Savannah Guthrie 19 Minutes to Give Trump His Toughest Grilling in Years" [View all]

https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2020/10/savannah-guthrie-trump-town-hall-grilling.html

(This is a great read, esp for those - like me - that refuse to watch the orange asshole)

Rather than face former Vice President Joe Biden in a town hall debate on Thursday, President Donald Trump took questions from voters in a one-hour special on NBC. Before the Miami crowd got its turn, however, host Savannah Guthrie interviewed Trump directly, appearing to respond to criticism of the network’s decision to hand Trump air time by giving the president one of the most intense grillings of his four years in office.

Guthrie pressed the president on details related to his own experience with COVID-19, his baffling evasiveness when asked to condemn white supremacy, and the QAnon conspiracy theory, which Trump declined to condemn but did say, “I do know they are very much against pedophilia, they fight it very hard.” While Trump tried to fall back on his usual bluster, Guthrie was a cheerful but firm interviewer, returning again and again to the facts and details of Trump’s answers. As usual, Trump attempted to lie through the barrage of tough questions—and almost every time got pinned down by an interviewer who didn’t back off. At one point, after Guthrie parried one of Trump’s attempts to undermine a question’s premise, the president replied, “So cute.”

Quite a lot happened in 19 or so minutes! Let’s take it topic by topic.

COVID-19
Guthrie wasted no time in launching into Trump’s inconsistencies. After introducing herself, explaining the situation behind the competing presidential town halls, and wishing the first lady and their son good health, she asked Trump to explain his unusually intense medical treatment.

Trump responded that he “didn’t feel good” and that he had a temperature, and that “all I know is I felt good the following day.” Guthrie wasn’t satisfied with the answer. “Did the doctors ever tell you that they saw pneumonia on your lung scan?”

Trump: No, but they said the lungs are a little bit different, a little perhaps infected, and—

Guthrie: Infected with?

Trump: I don’t know. I didn’t do too much asking. I really felt good. I didn’t have much of a problem with the lungs. I did have a little bit of a temperature. Obviously I felt there was something missing. And then I tested, you know, I tested positive.

Guthrie then tried to pin Trump on the dates of his infection, a topic for which the White House’s explanations have shifted. “Your first positive test was Thursday, Oct. 1, OK? When was your last negative test? When did you last remember having a negative test?” Trump didn’t give a definitive answer, but thanks to Guthrie’s persistence he offered a bit more detail—and made a revealing obfuscation:



snip - LOTS more at the link
34 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A more thorough grilling then a trump steak. Salviati Oct 2020 #1
Aptly worded! flibbitygiblets Oct 2020 #4
THEN? CountMyVote4Reality Oct 2020 #20
No worries, Salviati! nutshell2002 Oct 2020 #30
Thanks for posting that!!! BigmanPigman Oct 2020 #2
IF this/THEN that CountMyVote4Reality Oct 2020 #19
Good catch on a very common mistake. We can all use Maru Kitteh Oct 2020 #21
Reading that I'm text, he sounds like an old demented fool underpants Oct 2020 #3
didnt watch MFM008 Oct 2020 #5
Read the link. sheshe2 Oct 2020 #6
The whole article is well worth reading. Shrike47 Oct 2020 #7
I'm in the hospital dying of some disease. I don't know what. I didn't do too much asking. TheBlackAdder Oct 2020 #8
Syphilis COL Mustard Oct 2020 #33
I didn't watch, but I read the Slate piece. It looks like Guthrie did a very good job. PSPS Oct 2020 #9
You Know She Did, COL Mustard Oct 2020 #34
KNR Lucinda Oct 2020 #10
Worth reading the whole article, plus no Trump's voice. chriscan64 Oct 2020 #11
She deserves an Emmy for her performance!! Thekaspervote Oct 2020 #12
I did not watch it but the transcripts of it are killing Trump UCmeNdc Oct 2020 #13
You can tell she did well Grokenstein Oct 2020 #14
KR.. Samantha Guthrie! TY! Cha Oct 2020 #15
Her name is "Savannah." cwydro Oct 2020 #18
Good that she grilled him. wnylib Oct 2020 #16
Kick for link burrowowl Oct 2020 #17
Quote of the night DeminPennswoods Oct 2020 #22
I don't care how well Guthrie did Sunsky Oct 2020 #23
The numbers of nasty women seem limitless. BobTheSubgenius Oct 2020 #24
Yep... UserNotFound Oct 2020 #25
Worth reading in entirety. JohnnyRingo Oct 2020 #26
There will be platinum statues of Savannah Guthrie in decades to come bucolic_frolic Oct 2020 #27
The men who have interviewed Trump have been chicken shit cowards. BlueLucy Oct 2020 #28
BBQ'd Donny Blue Owl Oct 2020 #29
When I'm wrong, I say I'm wrong Justice Oct 2020 #31
Whole article very good cp Oct 2020 #32
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Slate "It Took Savannah G...