Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Kid Berwyn

(24,771 posts)
158. I'm no trumper.
Wed May 19, 2021, 12:08 PM
May 2021

I’ve read all that I could find worth reading about the subject since I was 9 years old in 1966.



‘Unidentified Aerial Phenomena,’ Better Known as UFOs, Deserve Scientific Investigation

UAP are a scientifically interesting problem. Interdisciplinary teams of scientists should study them


By Ravi Kopparapu, Jacob Haqq-Misra
Scientific American on July 27, 2020

UFOs have been back in the news because of videos initially leaked, and later confirmed, by the U.S. Navy and officially released by Pentagon that purportedly show "unidentified aerial phenomena" (UAP) in our skies. Speculations about their nature have run the gamut from mundane objects like birds or balloons to visitors from outer space.

It’s difficult, if not impossible, to say what these actually are, however, without context. What happened before and after these video snippets? Were there any simultaneous observations from other instruments, or sightings by pilots?

Judging the nature of these objects (and these seem to be “objects,” as confirmed by the Navy) needs a coherent explanation that should accommodate and connect all the facts of the events. And this is where interdisciplinary scientific investigation is needed.

Snip...

But we understand to an extent the nature of GRBs, supernovae and gravitational waves. How? Because we have not dismissed the phenomena or the people who observed them. We studied them. Astronomers have tools, so they can share the data they collected, even if some question their claim. Similarly, we need tools to observe UAP; radar, thermal, and visual observations will be immensely helpful. We must repeat here that this is a global phenomenon. Perhaps some, or even most, UAP events are simply classified military aircraft, or strange weather formations, or other misidentified mundane phenomena. However, there are still a number of truly puzzling cases that might be worth investigating.

Snip...

A template to perform a thorough scientific investigation can be found in James McDonald’s paper “Science in Default.” While he entertains the conclusion that these events could be extraterrestrials (which we do not subscribe to), McDonald’s methodology itself is a great example of objective scientific analysis. And this is exactly what we as scientists can do to study these events.

Continues...

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/unidentified-aerial-phenomena-better-known-as-ufos-deserve-scientific-investigation/

Don’t know, but I find it likely based on what they wrote, the authors of the above probably never heard of the following cases involving Thomas Mantell, Felix Moncla, Robert Wilson and Frederick Valentich.

The first three were flying officers in the United States armed forces. The fourth name was a young Australian air cadet. Each apparently lost their life in association with UFOs. There likely are others. Here's a bit on them:

Thomas Mantell





Mantell Case (1948)

EXCERPT...

Mantell was an experienced pilot; his flight history consisted of 2,167 hours in the air, and he had been honored for his part in the Battle of Normandy during World War II.

On 7 January 1948, Godman Field at Fort Knox, Kentucky received a report from the Kentucky Highway Patrol of an unusual aerial object near Maysville, Kentucky. Reports of a westbound circular object, 250 feet (76 m) to 300 feet (91 m) in diameter, were received from Owensboro, Kentucky, and Irvington, Kentucky.

At about 1:45 p.m., Sgt Quinton Blackwell saw an object from his position in the control tower at Fort Knox. Two other witnesses in the tower also reported a white object in the distance. Base commander Colonel Guy Hix reported an object he described as "very white," and "about one fourth the size of the full moon ... Through binoculars it appeared to have a red border at the bottom ... It remained stationary, seemingly, for one and a half hours." Observers at Clinton County Army Air Field in Ohio described the object "as having the appearance of a flaming red cone trailing a gaseous green mist" and observed the object for around 35 minutes. Another observer at Lockbourne Army Air Field in Ohio noted, "Just before leaving it came to very near the ground, staying down for about ten seconds, then climbed at a very fast rate back to its original altitude, 10,000 feet, leveling off and disappearing into the overcast heading 120 degrees. Its speed was greater than 500 mph in level flight."

Four P-51 Mustangs of C Flight, 165th Fighter Squadron Kentucky Air National Guard already in the air—one piloted by Mantell—were told to approach the object. Blackwell was in radio communication with the pilots throughout the event.

One pilot's Mustang was low on fuel, and he quickly abandoned his efforts. Air Force Captain Edward J. Ruppelt (the first head of Project Blue Book) notes that there was some disagreement amongst the air traffic controllers as to Mantell's words as he communicated with the tower: some sources reported that Mantell had described an object "which) looks metallic and of tremendous size," but, according to Ruppelt in The Report on Unidentified Flying Objects, others disputed whether or not Mantell actually said this.

The other two pilots accompanied Mantell in steep pursuit of the object. They later reported they saw an object, but described it as so small and indistinct they could not identify it. Mantell ignored suggestions that the pilots should level their altitude and try to more clearly see the object.

Only one of Mantell's companions, Lt. Albert Clemmons, had an oxygen mask, and his oxygen was in low supply. Clemmons and a Lt. Hammond called off their pursuit at 22,500 feet (6,900 m). Mantell continued to climb, however. According to the Air Force, once Mantell passed 25,000 feet (7,600 m) he supposedly blacked out from the lack of oxygen (hypoxia), and his plane began spiraling back towards the ground. A witness later reported Mantell's Mustang in a circling descent. His plane crashed at a farm south of Franklin, Kentucky, on the Tennessee-Kentucky state line.

Firemen later pulled Mantell's body from the Mustang's wreckage. His wristwatch had stopped at 3:18 p.m., the time of his crash. Meanwhile, by 3:50 p.m. the UFO was no longer visible to observers at Godman Field. The Mantell Incident was reported by newspapers around the nation, and received significant news media attention. A number of sensational rumors were also circulated about Mantell's crash. Among the rumors were claims that Mantell's fighter had been shot down by the UFO he was chasing, and that the Air Force covered up evidence proving this. Another rumor stated that Mantell's body was found riddled with strange holes. However, no evidence has ever surfaced to substantiate any of these claims. In 1956, Ruppelt wrote that the Mantell Crash was one of three "classic" UFO cases in 1948 that would help to define the UFO phenomenon in the public mind, and would help to convince Air Force intelligence specialists that UFOs were a "real", physical phenomenon (Ruppelt 30). The other two sightings were the Gorman Dogfight and the Chiles-Whitted UFO Encounter.

CONTINUED...

http://www.mufon.com/mantell-case---1948.html



Felix Moncla and Robert Wilson



USAF Radar operator stated he watched the aircraft approach the UFO; then saw the two blips merge into one return that quickly moved off the screen.



Marksville Weekly News

Avoyelles Parish has connections to a UFO mystery that goes back 49 years. Gordon Heath from Surrey, British Columbia was in Marksville recently to investigate the background of Lt. Felix E. Moncla who disappeared along with another crew member, Second Lt. Robert L. Wilson, over Lake Superior on Monday, November 23, 1953.

According to Heath, who is a UFO hobbyist, Moncla was on temporary assignment at Kinross Air Force Base in ...(sic. Michigan)... when he was sent to identify and unidentified craft over the Soo Locks, which is restricted airspace. Moncla, in an F-89C, pursued the craft for about 30 minutes flying at 30,000 feet over the middle of Lake Superior. He was flying about 500 mph when he was instructed by ground radar to descend to 7,000 feet.

When the unidentified craft was finally on radar it was noted that the two radar images, the UFO and the Air Force jet, were very close and at some point they intersected but only one remained. Heath says that the unidentified craft flew north and disappeared from radar.

Lt. Moncla's jet mysteriously disappeared without a trace.

http://www.nuforc.org/mancla.html


No remains of the crew or wreckage of the F-89C have been found.



Frederick Valentich

His late father holds the missing flyer's picture:





Delta Sierra Juliet? Do you read?

Boats and aircraft have found no trace of the 20-year old Australian pilot who disappeared with his plane on Saturday night after radioing that he was being chased by a UFO. Frederick Valentich was on a 125 mile training flight in his single engine Cessna 182 along the coast of Bass Strait when he told air traffic controllers in Melbourne that he was being buzzed by a UFO with 4 bright lights about 1000 feet above him.

Controllers said his last message was taped and was: "It's approaching from due east towards me. It seems to be playing some sort of game... flying at a speed I can't estimate. It's not an aircraft. It's...It is flying past. It is a long shape. I cannot identify more than that. It's coming for me right now." A minute later: "It seems to be stationary. I'm also orbiting and the thing is orbiting on top of me also. It has a green light and a sort of metallic light on the outside." Valentich then radioed that his engine was running roughly. His last words were: "It is not an aircraft."

The Australian Air Force said it had received 11 reports from people along the coast who said they saw UFOs on Saturday night, but the Transport Department was skeptical. Ken Williams, a spokesman for the department, said, "It's funny all these people ringing up with UFO reports well after Valentich's disappearance. It seems people often decide after the event, they too had seen strange lights. But although we can't take them too seriously, we can never discourgae such reports when investigating a plane's disappearance."

SNIP...

ACTUAL TRANSCRIPTION OF MELBOURNE FLIGHT SERVICE

The transcript portion of the communication between Valentich and Melbourne Flight Service as released by the Australian Department of Transport follows: (FS - Flight Service, DSJ - Frederick Valentich aircraft designation).

1906:14 DSJ Melbourne, this is Delta Sierra Juliet. Is there any known traffic below five thousand?

FS Delta Sierra Juliet, no known traffic.

DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet, I am, seems to be a large aircraft below five thousand.

1906:44 FS Delta Sierra Juliet, What type of aircraft is it?

DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet, I cannot affirm, it is four bright, it seems to me like landing lights.

1907 FS Delta Sierra Juliet.

1907:31 DSJ Melbourne, this is Delta Sierra Juliet, the aircraft has just passed over me at least a thousand feet above.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet, roger, and it is a large aircraft, confirmed?

DSJ Er-unknown, due to the speed it's travelling, is there any air force aircraft in the vicinity?

FS Delta Sierra Juliet, no known aircraft in the vicinity.

1908:18 DSJ Melbourne, it's approaching now from due east towards me.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet.

1908:41 DSJ (open microphone for two seconds.)

1908:48 DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet, it seems to me that he's playing some sort of game, he's flying over me two, three times at speeds I could not identify.

1909 FS Delta Sierra Juliet, roger, what is your actual level?

DSJ My level is four and a half thousand, four five zero zero.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet, and you confirm you cannot identify the aircraft?

DSJ Affirmative.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet, roger, stand by.

1909:27 DSJ Melbourne, Delta Sierra Juliet, it's not an aircraft it is (open microphone for two seconds).

1909:42 FS Delta Sierra Juliet, can you describe the -er- aircraft?

DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet, as it's flying past it's a long shape (open microphone for three seconds) cannot identify more than it has such speed (open microphone for three seconds). It's before me right now Melbourne.

1910 FS Delta Sierra Juliet, roger and how large would the - er - object be?

1910:19 DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet, Melbourne, it seems like it's stationary. What I'm doing right now is orbiting and the thing is just orbiting on top of me also. It's got a green light and sort of metallic like, it's all shiny on the outside.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet

1910:46 DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet (open microphone for three seconds) It's just vanished.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet

1911 DSJ Melbourne, would you know what kind of aircraft I've got? Is it a military aircraft?

FS Delta Sierra Juliet, Confirm the - er ~ aircraft just vanished.

DSJ Say again.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet, is the aircraft still with you?

DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet; it's (open microphone for two seconds) now approaching from the south-west.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet

1911:50 DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet, the engine is rough-idling. I've got it set at twenty three twenty-four and the thing is coughing.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet, roger, what are your intentions?

DSJ My intentions are - ah - to go to King Island - ah - Melbourne. That strange aircraft is hovering on top of me again (open microphone for two seconds). It is hovering and it's not an aircraft.

FS Delta Sierra Juliet.

1912:28 DSJ Delta Sierra Juliet. Melbourne (open microphone for seventeen seconds).

SOURCE: http://www.ufocasebook.com/australianpilot.html



So that’s part of the reason why the Pentagon considers UFOs “serious business.”

As for people who ridicule those who report or discuss UFOs, that’s your business.


Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

why? JohnSJ May 2021 #1
They aren't Ours jpak May 2021 #6
Could be ours? bluestarone May 2021 #8
Probably not ours Beaverhausen May 2021 #36
You have no idea whether or not we've invented it yet obamanut2012 May 2021 #50
MACH 18 Beaverhausen May 2021 #59
Ok qazplm135 May 2021 #140
I believe bdamomma May 2021 #9
the ones in the vid on CNN I just saw were from 2004, lolol Celerity May 2021 #131
Great, now the bastard has a time machine? Ligyron May 2021 #149
Not aliens though! Nt USALiberal May 2021 #58
Afraid of what? WhiskeyGrinder May 2021 #2
Apparently details or any type of explanation to start. Bleacher Creature May 2021 #26
+1... myohmy2 May 2021 #91
What ever operates them has technology we don't have jpak May 2021 #93
Unless it's us. Iggo May 2021 #108
They are detected there because that is where we have the technology to find them. gldstwmn May 2021 #109
They are off the East and West Coasts and Guam jpak May 2021 #110
Well maybe they will destroy our planet before... jcgoldie May 2021 #3
Hard to think "they'd" succeed before we do. hlthe2b May 2021 #5
Maybe they are more enlightened and evolved cilla4progress May 2021 #4
That's what I think; or maybe they're just studying us(neither benevolent nor malevalent). triron May 2021 #89
That's the approach I'm taking yonder May 2021 #120
I'll just add it to my growing list of things to worry about. Ocelot II May 2021 #7
Jumping worms should be fear number 1 jpak May 2021 #16
And: Disaffected May 2021 #27
Guilty of all three jpak May 2021 #28
And Asian Murder Hornets leftyladyfrommo May 2021 #75
Jumping worms? nt LAS14 May 2021 #78
Bad, invasive critters - they ruin topsoil. Ocelot II May 2021 #79
Oh, gee..... Thanks for the info.... not. :-( nt LAS14 May 2021 #80
The only thing worrying about aliens visiting us... joshcryer May 2021 #82
Jumping worms?? New one for me. yonder May 2021 #122
They're a real thing and a huge imported threat to our ecosystem. herding cats May 2021 #128
Yes thanks, I just got back from looking around yonder May 2021 #132
That bit about our native earthworms is news to me. herding cats May 2021 #133
Here's one of the things I looked at: yonder May 2021 #138
You mean the revelation that they're unknown? brooklynite May 2021 #10
Maybe that's where what we call COVID-19 came from. Buns_of_Fire May 2021 #11
To be fair, they could have picked a deadlier bug. róisín_dubh May 2021 #139
Much better qazplm135 May 2021 #141
Don't be winetourdriver01 May 2021 #12
This message was self-deleted by its author hamsterjill May 2021 #22
Well, you asked for it.. winetourdriver01 May 2021 #46
This message was self-deleted by its author hamsterjill May 2021 #47
Ah, yes, derived from Die Glocke. lagomorph777 May 2021 #53
What would a new gravitational field have to do with speed, high acceleration, and water resistance? muriel_volestrangler May 2021 #152
We're being set up. LuvLoogie May 2021 #13
You think the aliens are conservatives? BannonsLiver May 2021 #41
No, but it seems that these revelations always come out when there are Democrats leading the country TheBlackAdder May 2021 #55
Interesting point that I had not considered BannonsLiver May 2021 #56
The current news stories are largely based on military info made public in 2017. highplainsdem May 2021 #146
Check this out. The Republicans are more tight-lipped. TheBlackAdder May 2021 #154
They may be greedy as opposed to altruistic. LuvLoogie May 2021 #92
If you watch The Weather Channel cyclonefence May 2021 #14
+1 chowder66 May 2021 #23
+1 chowder66 May 2021 #29
+1. Ball lightning was terrifying dalton99a May 2021 #38
Aliens actually run the Weather Channel. milestogo May 2021 #86
I've heard plausible explanations for all of the sightings. Oneironaut May 2021 #96
Just saw that San Diego footage, crazy stuff JuJuChen May 2021 #15
Ours... anotherOKIE May 2021 #17
Just wait till the govt admits alien abductions are real, then its game on! Shanti Shanti Shanti May 2021 #18
There have been strange aerial things reported for millenia The Blue Flower May 2021 #19
I agree with Vallee that we are witnessing the same phenomena folks have been seeing forever. Midnight Writer May 2021 #62
Meh Johnny2X2X May 2021 #20
Yup jpak May 2021 #33
not me. it's fascinating no matter what. The only thing that scares me are RWNJ NewHendoLib May 2021 #21
The possibilities are endless. good, the bad, wonderful, and ugly.. Stuart G May 2021 #24
It's Estimated That There... ruet May 2021 #30
Exactly. The idea that the earth is the only planet in the UNIVERSE to have intelligent life panader0 May 2021 #65
Here is the falicy in that argument edhopper May 2021 #73
"advanced enough to be peaceful." TxGuitar May 2021 #97
I'm old and don't know the reference. panader0 May 2021 #99
Sorry, Star Trek reference TxGuitar May 2021 #105
In this other OP on this subject I wondered if the aliens could be hostile. A great answer by JuJu: panader0 May 2021 #106
Not really qazplm135 May 2021 #142
I for one would find it monumental if it is aliens mvd May 2021 #111
Gen. James Clapper says report will be usual mixed bag. Kid Berwyn May 2021 #25
i have other things with a priority...keeping a roof over my head...food on the table etc HipChick May 2021 #31
Here is an explanation for some of the videos chowder66 May 2021 #32
Thanks edhopper May 2021 #48
Yes, Disaffected May 2021 #64
I found it pretty evident when watching the footage on the news. chowder66 May 2021 #69
A US cruiser (Princeton) tracked one of these objects on radar jpak May 2021 #94
The Lost Planet Oron has it in for us. Sneederbunk May 2021 #34
Most of these sightings don't seem to follow the laws of physics. mn9driver May 2021 #35
I would bet some sort of anti-gravity drive. roamer65 May 2021 #40
"anti-gravity" would enable an object to climb as easily as go sideways, or to float muriel_volestrangler May 2021 #153
A lot of them are Disaffected May 2021 #43
Marfa Lights jpak May 2021 #49
None of us here know what we have and don't have BannonsLiver May 2021 #44
How do you know that tech doesn't exist? obamanut2012 May 2021 #52
That's a logical fallacy. Disaffected May 2021 #60
Because rewriting the laws of physics in complete secrecy is not feasible muriel_volestrangler May 2021 #155
The F-35 qazplm135 May 2021 #143
The F-35 obeys the laws of physics that have been known since Newton muriel_volestrangler May 2021 #156
CGI qazplm135 May 2021 #159
Do you mean that you think the USA is secretly testing astounding technology muriel_volestrangler May 2021 #161
They're just surveillance ships from Wakanda. Buckeye_Democrat May 2021 #37
It's the Kodan Armada BannonsLiver May 2021 #39
I think it is China or the Russians. applegrove May 2021 #42
I think it's leprechauns in rocket suits. Disaffected May 2021 #61
Perhaps there's an advanced underwater society hidden under the ocean Polybius May 2021 #45
So was Operation Skyhook obamanut2012 May 2021 #51
I'm sure it's real. NurseJackie May 2021 #54
I am a leaf on the wind... Jedi Guy May 2021 #84
It's been renewed for a 2nd season, I believe. NurseJackie May 2021 #88
Why would alien civilizations bother visiting Earth? FakeNoose May 2021 #57
Fresh DNA, every ancient culture has stories of sky gods coming down and mating with earth girls Shanti Shanti Shanti May 2021 #63
Curiosity ... insatiable curiosity Earth-shine May 2021 #66
Sport. BannonsLiver May 2021 #83
Appetizers? nt Buns_of_Fire May 2021 #90
Same reason we do JI7 May 2021 #103
Maybe to test drive the new electric F-150 pickup truck. oasis May 2021 #118
If we can imagine traveling the universe in search of other intelligent life, why can't they? n/t Akoto May 2021 #162
eSkeptic (Mick West) has some things to say about it frogmarch May 2021 #67
Beat me to posting this edhopper May 2021 #70
Obama just gave an interview qazplm135 May 2021 #144
Weather balloons have instrument packages and a parachute jpak May 2021 #151
I'm really going ezgoingrl May 2021 #68
What's disturbing about the fact that something you see is unidentified? brooklynite May 2021 #71
First, ya gotta give me a concrete reason to be afraid. Iggo May 2021 #72
BE VERY AFRAID!!! nt RegularJam May 2021 #74
2 billion people walking around with a camera edhopper May 2021 #76
I just read that we are really in a zoo and the aliens leftyladyfrommo May 2021 #77
No they are not! nt USALiberal May 2021 #81
They don't do anything besides show off. eShirl May 2021 #85
I Want To Believe. Cafe Cat May 2021 #87
They have been here for a long time if it is real. They haven't killed us yet. Irish_Dem May 2021 #95
I find them exciting and interesting. For whatever purpose, they are real. elevator May 2021 #98
Links or it didn't happen. Politicub May 2021 #102
Post removed Post removed May 2021 #121
That's fine. I was fairly certain you would not have any sources to Politicub May 2021 #150
Are they though? I feel like this story rears it's head every few years... Politicub May 2021 #100
Afraid of what? gldstwmn May 2021 #101
See post 93 jpak May 2021 #104
This message was self-deleted by its author ExTex May 2021 #107
For such a major revelation it doesn't seem to be impacting the news I'm reading Silent3 May 2021 #112
the belief that WE are the only (relatively) intelligent life in the galaxy is... WarGamer May 2021 #113
The voices in my head led me here dweller May 2021 #114
LOL jpak May 2021 #116
Me sleep txting dweller May 2021 #119
I was in the Navy, photographer, I never saw this phenomena nor did Shellback Squid May 2021 #115
I spent 2years of my life at sea including a research cruise from Barrow AK to the Ross Sea jpak May 2021 #117
yup, it's a shiny object to distract Shellback Squid May 2021 #123
Well I guess that settles it then. Really? elevator May 2021 #124
yes, that's what I said Shellback Squid May 2021 #126
Post removed Post removed May 2021 #127
lol Shellback Squid May 2021 #129
You might find that finding out about things you don't understand is beneficial elevator May 2021 #136
I'm not "most" and you made my point, thank you Shellback Squid May 2021 #137
This message was self-deleted by its author elevator May 2021 #125
Here's what Chief Delbert Newhouse filmed -- on dry land in 1952. Kid Berwyn May 2021 #148
Likely from Russia or China rather than another world. nt Quixote1818 May 2021 #130
That case would certainly be something to fear. elevator May 2021 #134
hmm ... dweller May 2021 #135
I agree, I find it spooky, disturbing and scary 😱 Raine May 2021 #145
And how did you jump from "there are unidentified flying objects" to "aliens"? brooklynite May 2021 #147
UFO stories are for the trumpers Chakaconcarne May 2021 #157
I'm no trumper. Kid Berwyn May 2021 #158
Are you denying UFO'S exist? BradAllison May 2021 #160
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»These UFO revelations are...»Reply #158