Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
129. :) though of course we need to remember that many/most of us
Thu Nov 11, 2021, 05:31 PM
Nov 2021

would have been part of that progressive movement. Government should be used by the people to serve the people. We just wouldn't be among the radicals/extremists drawn to it.

Just try to find a liberal who isn't a strong believer in progressivism. Many conservatives also, though they're trained to see it as a dirty word it in this era. But both Teddy Roosevelt and Dwight Eisenhower were moderate conservative progressives, and trumpists are passionately protective of their Social Security, etc.

Speaking of extreme behaviors than and now, another commonality through all, including the New Deal era: Each time, the radicals and extremists drawn to progressive movements believed they could take over or destroy the mainstream party(ies) as part of their reforms. And of course failing that, each time they then passionately opposed, and attempted to kill, the parties' progressive reforms.

“History Doesn't Repeat Itself, but It Often Rhymes” – Mark Twain. Let's hope in the Biden era it merely hums a bit harmlessly.


Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Establishment Liberal EYESORE 9001 Nov 2021 #1
That's where I landed too Dorian Gray Nov 2021 #73
Establishment Liberals underpants Nov 2021 #2
I ended up "Progressive Left, along with 6% of the country. Just 6%?--very disappointing. tblue37 Nov 2021 #3
I'm there with you nt intrepidity Nov 2021 #11
This message was self-deleted by its author bluewater Nov 2021 #122
I was Progressive Left MineralMan Nov 2021 #4
Me too Freddie Nov 2021 #7
Well, I thought the questions and choices were too limited. MineralMan Nov 2021 #10
No kidding intrepidity Nov 2021 #13
that is exactly the one I struggled with OriginalGeek Nov 2021 #131
I had that same thought. n/t piddyprints Nov 2021 #24
I was struck by that on the first question. skypilot Nov 2021 #27
Same for me. Diablo del sol Nov 2021 #63
That's why I ended up as Progressive Left too mcar Nov 2021 #72
I thought the Dorian Gray Nov 2021 #74
Maybe all 6% of us are here on DU. tblue37 Nov 2021 #16
:) Not quite, but "most politically engaged," after all. Hortensis Nov 2021 #50
Same here... piddyprints Nov 2021 #25
Same. sakabatou Nov 2021 #130
Outsider Left IbogaProject Nov 2021 #5
Same, and after reading the description I can see it Amishman Nov 2021 #142
Progressive Left Piasladic Nov 2021 #6
This message was self-deleted by its author Elessar Zappa Nov 2021 #8
Progressive left. Elessar Zappa Nov 2021 #9
Progressive Left Bettie Nov 2021 #12
Establishment liberal hauckeye Nov 2021 #14
interesting radicalleft Nov 2021 #15
egads, the so called questions are based on conservative talking points and tell to ShazamIam Nov 2021 #17
Democratic Mainstay bottomofthehill Nov 2021 #18
Establishment Liberal SarasotaDem Nov 2021 #19
Progressive Left. panader0 Nov 2021 #20
Democratic Mainstay... Wounded Bear Nov 2021 #21
Me too. But we're only 16% of the Electorate says Pew. Did you see that?! msfiddlestix Nov 2021 #32
Yeah, Pew has tended to lean a bit rightwards over the last few years... Wounded Bear Nov 2021 #40
My first instinct as read through questions and limited options for responses. msfiddlestix Nov 2021 #42
Yeah, me too. Haggard Celine Nov 2021 #82
Same here. n/t FSogol Nov 2021 #103
Progressive Left 7wo7rees Nov 2021 #22
Establishment Liberal... Peacetrain Nov 2021 #23
progressive left but... jcgoldie Nov 2021 #26
Progressive Left nocoincidences Nov 2021 #28
Progressive Left. mentalsolstice Nov 2021 #29
Democratic "Mainstay" is where I fall on Pew msfiddlestix Nov 2021 #30
Outsider Left BeerBarrelPolka Nov 2021 #31
Progressive Left BlueJac Nov 2021 #33
Progressive Left Generic Brad Nov 2021 #34
Progressive leftie ! kimbutgar Nov 2021 #35
"question on a scale if 1-100 how I feel about repukes, I put 0." BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #108
Progressive Left, 6% RainCaster Nov 2021 #36
Progressive left Politicub Nov 2021 #37
Another Establishment Liberal here. Shrike47 Nov 2021 #38
Democratic Mainstay StarryNite Nov 2021 #39
Progressive Left. Coventina Nov 2021 #41
Progressive Left, which surprises me. I think of myself as a moderate liberal. sinkingfeeling Nov 2021 #43
Democratic Mainstay Patterson Nov 2021 #44
Progressive left iemanja Nov 2021 #45
Wo! I was surprised at what a small percentage Progressive Left are of Democrats. nt LAS14 Nov 2021 #46
not of Democrats iemanja Nov 2021 #52
Apparently you can't go back and look at those stats without taking the quiz again... nt LAS14 Nov 2021 #65
Unless you save your results (as HTML) like I did BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #67
Can you tell me how to do that without getting into a tutorial? LAS14 Nov 2021 #70
Well once you reach the end of the survey and they show the results BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #76
Thanks VERY much!!! nt LAS14 Nov 2021 #134
You are welcome! BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #135
Some of the categories are odd iemanja Nov 2021 #80
Exactly and I agree BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #97
We need a left radical category. By far most who fit Pew's progressives Hortensis Nov 2021 #100
I think they are actually missing that from both extreme ends BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #101
Yes, what's that about? WTF, Pew? It's a much bigger can of worms Hortensis Nov 2021 #102
I was still stuck on them fantasizing about BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #105
! They're not the only ones pushing populism as a RW phenomenon, Hortensis Nov 2021 #107
Well interestingly enough BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #109
TR ran as a Progressive iemanja Nov 2021 #113
Yes that was also the name of the 3rd party that he eventually founded BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #125
:) though of course we need to remember that many/most of us Hortensis Nov 2021 #129
This quiz asks about positions on issues iemanja Nov 2021 #112
loons iemanja Nov 2021 #110
It had me at Democratic Mainstay... LiberalFighter Nov 2021 #47
Progressive Left. nt DLevine Nov 2021 #48
Estabishment liberal. Though the choices left much to be desired. Hortensis Nov 2021 #49
I voted like that too, on that question. I also agree more with you... electric_blue68 Nov 2021 #90
Exactly. We and many other nations actually have been downsizing Hortensis Nov 2021 #98
Progressive Left JanMichael Nov 2021 #51
Establishment Liberal. nt Tommy Carcetti Nov 2021 #53
Establishment Liberal sciencescience Nov 2021 #54
Democratic Mainstay W_HAMILTON Nov 2021 #55
Progressive Left mvd Nov 2021 #56
Progressive Left Leith Nov 2021 #57
Outsider Left. That feels right. SYFROYH Nov 2021 #58
Democratic Mainstay. Greybnk48 Nov 2021 #59
Democratic Mainstays Kaleva Nov 2021 #60
Progressive Left MustLoveBeagles Nov 2021 #61
progressive left. Akacia Nov 2021 #62
Wow. Surprising for me - Progressive Left BumRushDaShow Nov 2021 #64
Democratic Mainstay Mossfern Nov 2021 #66
Beyond Red vs. Blue: The Political Typology Klaralven Nov 2021 #68
Establishment Liberal. highplainsdem Nov 2021 #69
Progressive Left mcar Nov 2021 #71
Me too. Not really me. betsuni Nov 2021 #89
Democratic Mainstay marble falls Nov 2021 #75
Same here! Democratic Mainstay Rhiannon12866 Nov 2021 #138
Thought I had a definate left streak. marble falls Nov 2021 #140
Guess. Solly Mack Nov 2021 #77
Ha ha......please tell us....bet I know tho. 😄 a kennedy Nov 2021 #81
I think the quiz needed more answer choices. Solly Mack Nov 2021 #83
I agree about the answers MustLoveBeagles Nov 2021 #84
Dammit! I'm only an Establishment Liberal Poiuyt Nov 2021 #78
Outsider left here. NewHendoLib Nov 2021 #79
Progressive Left FakeNoose Nov 2021 #85
I'll post my answers, too mvd Nov 2021 #86
Cool! We are almost identical on just about everything FakeNoose Nov 2021 #87
You were WAY kinder to Republicans than I was Bettie Nov 2021 #115
I know - I came from a midwestern Republican family FakeNoose Nov 2021 #117
Progressive Left YoshidaYui Nov 2021 #88
Progressive Left electric_blue68 Nov 2021 #91
Interesting! burrowowl Nov 2021 #92
Democratic Mainstay. nt Progressive Jones Nov 2021 #93
Democratic Mainstay. How could this be? Earth-shine Nov 2021 #94
Take a look at my answers on post #85 FakeNoose Nov 2021 #119
Democratic Mainstays pfitz59 Nov 2021 #95
Progressive Left. n/t LuckyCharms Nov 2021 #96
progressive left onethatcares Nov 2021 #99
Democratic Mainstay... Kahuna Nov 2021 #104
Progressive Left budkin Nov 2021 #106
Progressive Left blogslug Nov 2021 #111
Progressive Left here Dave says Nov 2021 #114
Progressive Left. GoneOffShore Nov 2021 #116
Democratic Mainstays!!! demtenjeep Nov 2021 #118
This message was self-deleted by its author Celerity Nov 2021 #120
Your best fit is... Progressive Left Celerity Nov 2021 #121
My result: "Trotsky, is that you?" bluewater Nov 2021 #123
Establishment Liberal (13% of population) IcyPeas Nov 2021 #124
Outsider Left what ever that means marie999 Nov 2021 #126
Establishment Liberal Jimbo S Nov 2021 #127
Democratic Mainstays NutmegYankee Nov 2021 #128
Democratic Mainstays UTUSN Nov 2021 #132
Processive Left here. Xavier Breath Nov 2021 #133
Message auto-removed Name removed Nov 2021 #136
Establishment Liberal n/t shanti Nov 2021 #137
Progressive Left mnhtnbb Nov 2021 #139
Progressive Left.... Upthevibe Nov 2021 #141
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Take the Pew Research qui...»Reply #129