Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

EndlessWire

(8,103 posts)
76. She sounds like an excellent employee.
Tue Feb 15, 2022, 10:37 PM
Feb 2022

Hard working, diligent, dedicated...

She should go and get the unemployment pronto. Just because he said he wouldn't dispute it, doesn't mean he won't. Also, she should review her employee file for what they really said about her. She should take a portable copier. They do make them very small nowadays. Very discreet. Then, she has to decide how to get a good reference from the company, and then start applying for other jobs. Maybe she could start her own company?

I agree with above. At-will employees are subject to discrimination, and it doesn't sound like anything provable occurred except discrimination against people who work from home. It also sounds like she called his bluff, but still didn't win. That's their decision to make.

Chin up, Baby Girl. One day this will all be in the distant past. You can make it. And, maybe the guy redoing the department will fire all the best people, and get fired himself for screwing it up.

It's also possible that this company is going under or going to be sold, and it's the best thing possible for your daughter. Have her get her unemployment.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

My Daughter Was Fired Today [View all] rustysgurl Feb 2022 OP
So sorry to hear. InAbLuEsTaTe Feb 2022 #1
That stinks XanaDUer2 Feb 2022 #2
Tell her to get a lawyer. Sounds like she's got a good case... brush Feb 2022 #3
Maybe sign up for unemployment? SheltieLover Feb 2022 #6
I'd get the unemployment first as he might try to fight it if... brush Feb 2022 #8
Me too! SheltieLover Feb 2022 #10
There may be texts, emails also that should be saved. brush Feb 2022 #14
Great point! SheltieLover Feb 2022 #20
THIS. MontanaMama Feb 2022 #110
I am a retired lawyer. I don't think there's a case here absent a contract saying she won't be fired Shrike47 Feb 2022 #13
Sad, hard on most people, and standard. Hortensis Feb 2022 #23
This is the correct answer. She should speak with a lawyer. TomSlick Feb 2022 #32
It is a right to work state ...there is no recourse. Demsrule86 Feb 2022 #78
See post 32. It never hurts to consult a good employment attorney. brush Feb 2022 #80
Then they might oppose unemployment as retaliation...and attorney's cost money. I live in Ohio- Demsrule86 Feb 2022 #85
So are you saying not to consult an expert employment lawyer... brush Feb 2022 #86
In a right to work state, I would not. I feel it would be a waste of money. Demsrule86 Feb 2022 #87
See post 77. You never know. brush Feb 2022 #91
I would take the money and get a new job. That is just me. Demsrule86 Feb 2022 #103
You are conflating "right to work" with "at-will employment." "Right to work" is a state rule that WhiskeyGrinder Feb 2022 #94
Add "for retaliatory reasons" to discrimination and contractual obligations. Pacifist Patriot Feb 2022 #106
Unnnn, if he showed some kind of Animus towards women maybe uponit7771 Feb 2022 #89
IMO it wouldn't hurt to consult an expert employment lawyer. brush Feb 2022 #90
In an at will state inthewind21 Feb 2022 #100
Nice people get axed when a department is "reorganized" LakeArenal Feb 2022 #4
That's what it sounds like to me SheltieLover Feb 2022 #7
Sad but true...I lived a similar situation in 2009. Moostache Feb 2022 #22
The real sad part is that HR will protect him, and allow him to do what he does Dan Feb 2022 #5
HR no longer (if it ever did) exists to support or help the employee. CentralMass Feb 2022 #34
HR Zeitghost Feb 2022 #67
When it was called Personnel, they 90% backed the employee - HR is a leftover from Raygun years when Hestia Feb 2022 #102
On behalf of Safety Managers Safety Dawg Feb 2022 #9
So sorry this has happened to her SheltieLover Feb 2022 #11
If She Stayed modrepub Feb 2022 #12
She sounds like a solid, competent person. nilram Feb 2022 #15
Sometimes there things lead to a much better situation. Hoping Tomconroy Feb 2022 #16
Sorry, she's having to deal with this. hippywife Feb 2022 #17
Usually these kind of things have negative consequences for companies Hav Feb 2022 #18
Sounds like a really terrible boss! Desert grandma Feb 2022 #19
This sounds like a case of the new hatchet man needing to leave a few "bodies" somewhere to justify dameatball Feb 2022 #21
Never understood this frame of mind. 2Gingersnaps Feb 2022 #24
So sorry this happened! Chicagogrl1 Feb 2022 #25
This advice is absolutely the best jmbar2 Feb 2022 #41
+1 uponit7771 Feb 2022 #92
+1 ancianita Feb 2022 #98
Goodness, I would hope HR provided separation documentation! Pacifist Patriot Feb 2022 #107
Best advice. All of that. Do not give up until you have it all. LittleGirl Feb 2022 #109
Sorry, good riddance though... RANDYWILDMAN Feb 2022 #26
She should look for a new job & not try to save this one. CrispyQ Feb 2022 #27
So sorry for her. ificandream Feb 2022 #28
My son got fired about 18 months ago MOMFUDSKI Feb 2022 #29
He's a dinosaur. Administrators that think like him won't roam gldstwmn Feb 2022 #30
Don't hold your breath. CentralMass Feb 2022 #35
I've been in the work force for 44 years and am a keen reader of people. gldstwmn Feb 2022 #49
A decade from now what help the young lady losing her job. CentralMass Feb 2022 #56
Unless she is in a union, there is no recourse iemanja Feb 2022 #31
worked for a guy like that once upon a time. He drove people he didn't like out of demigoddess Feb 2022 #33
Just awful Busterscruggs Feb 2022 #36
She wouldn't have liked working for that prick anyway. Nows the time to find a BETTER job. oldsoftie Feb 2022 #37
This happened to me years ago. Almost identical circumstances. llmart Feb 2022 #38
It is unfair to say the least. Did they make her sign anything on the way out the door? waterwatcher123 Feb 2022 #39
A Mercy? FrankTC Feb 2022 #40
Welcome to DU, FrankTC! calimary Feb 2022 #44
I'm sorry to see this GreenEyedLefty Feb 2022 #42
What a jerk move on the part of him and the company. I would bet half the farm that guy LoisB Feb 2022 #43
I doubt that she can do anything about it radical noodle Feb 2022 #45
. WhiskeyGrinder Feb 2022 #59
Actually, employment law is primarily state-based. Ms. Toad Feb 2022 #66
Yes, employment law is primarily state-based. WhiskeyGrinder Feb 2022 #68
The concept of at-will employment is decided at the state level. Ms. Toad Feb 2022 #69
Yes... my bad radical noodle Feb 2022 #72
Most blue states are at will, too. LisaM Feb 2022 #84
Working remotely can decrease job security, giving advantage to Hortensis Feb 2022 #46
This is a layoff and she's getting unemployment. Not much you can do. Tell her to file ASAP. WhiskeyGrinder Feb 2022 #47
++ shitheads gonna shithead, but there is a bright side to this cadoman Feb 2022 #71
I took early retirement about a year before Covid hit slightlv Feb 2022 #48
Slim chance,.... magicarpet Feb 2022 #50
You are conflating "right to work" with "at-will employment." "Right to work" is a state rule that WhiskeyGrinder Feb 2022 #58
Take the unemployment. hamsterjill Feb 2022 #51
I can feel her pain lonely bird Feb 2022 #52
Her husband Rebl2 Feb 2022 #53
No ... rustysgurl Feb 2022 #61
Oh. Okay. Rebl2 Feb 2022 #62
Sadly assholes in the workforce hurt people. live love laugh Feb 2022 #54
Severance in my experience iwillalwayswonderwhy Feb 2022 #55
I'm sorry she has to go through this situation. badhair77 Feb 2022 #57
K&R mvd Feb 2022 #60
Wife had similiar firing and my last job ended quite shitty too, a lot sounded very familiar! Brainfodder Feb 2022 #63
She'd be better off to take the severance and vacation pay. Fla Dem Feb 2022 #64
Thanks everyone rustysgurl Feb 2022 #65
I'm pretty sure retaliation is actionable. gldstwmn Feb 2022 #74
Can all of that be documented? Not sure what EEOC laws there are in Kansas, but there are a bunch... George II Feb 2022 #70
take the package and find a better job... hope she can find nicer bosses :) WarGamer Feb 2022 #73
This kind of thing seems to happen everywhere DFW Feb 2022 #75
She sounds like an excellent employee. EndlessWire Feb 2022 #76
PS! EndlessWire Feb 2022 #77
PPS! EndlessWire Feb 2022 #79
Did they 'downsize' the department or just her? Texin Feb 2022 #81
+1, especially if most of the job duties were kept and handed off to a single person uponit7771 Feb 2022 #93
Since they just posted her job on their website rustysgurl Feb 2022 #96
I am so sorry pandr32 Feb 2022 #82
Sorry but this is, for the most part, the way employment works in the U.S. mrsadm Feb 2022 #83
What a nightmare wendyb-NC Feb 2022 #88
People suck 1WorldHope Feb 2022 #95
Think long and hard about suing Jimbo S Feb 2022 #97
I'm sorry for your daughter. ancianita Feb 2022 #99
Back in the day musclecar6 Feb 2022 #101
Awful, but she's probably best out of it. BlackSkimmer Feb 2022 #104
Senior HR Professional here... Pacifist Patriot Feb 2022 #105
Find a new job and take as many coworkers as you can. The Jungle 1 Feb 2022 #108
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»My Daughter Was Fired Tod...»Reply #76