Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Some may disagree, but it is my strong opinion that if you cannot tag your deer using a bolt action [View all]Ocelot II
(131,577 posts)21. It's more than that; it's the velocity, which causes far more tissue damage.
A bullet with more energy can do more damage. Its total kinetic energy is equal to one-half the mass of the bullet times its velocity squared. The bullet from a handgun is---as absurd as it may sound---slow compared to that from an AR-15. It can be stopped by the thick bone of the upper leg. It might pass through the body, only to become lodged in skin, which is surprisingly elastic.
The bullet from an AR-15 does an entirely different kind of violence to the human body. Its relatively small, but it leaves the muzzle at three times the speed of a handgun bullet. It has so much energy that it can disintegrate three inches of leg bone. It would just turn it to dust, says Donald Jenkins, a trauma surgeon at University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio. If it hits the liver, the liver looks like a jello mold thats been dropped on the floor. And the exit wound can be a nasty, jagged hole the size of an orange.
These high-velocity bullets can damage flesh inches away from their path, either because they fragment or because they cause something called cavitation. When you trail your fingers through water, the water ripples and curls. When a high-velocity bullet pierces the body, human tissues ripples as well---but much more violently. The bullet from an AR-15 might miss the femoral artery in the leg, but cavitation may burst the artery anyway, causing death by blood loss. A swath of stretched and torn tissue around the wound may die. Thats why, says Rhee, a handgun wound might require only one surgery but an AR-15 bullet wound might require three to ten.A bullet with more energy can do more damage. Its total kinetic energy is equal to one-half the mass of the bullet times its velocity squared. The bullet from a handgun is---as absurd as it may sound---slow compared to that from an AR-15. It can be stopped by the thick bone of the upper leg. It might pass through the body, only to become lodged in skin, which is surprisingly elastic.
Then, multiply the damage from a single bullet by the ease of shooting an AR-15, which doesnt kick. The gun barely moves. You can sit there boom boom boom and reel off shots as fast as you can move your finger, says Ernest Moore, a trauma surgeon at Denver Health and editor of the Journal of Trauma and Acute Surgery, which just published an issue dedicated to gun violence.
https://www.wired.com/2016/06/ar-15-can-human-body/
The bullet from an AR-15 does an entirely different kind of violence to the human body. Its relatively small, but it leaves the muzzle at three times the speed of a handgun bullet. It has so much energy that it can disintegrate three inches of leg bone. It would just turn it to dust, says Donald Jenkins, a trauma surgeon at University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio. If it hits the liver, the liver looks like a jello mold thats been dropped on the floor. And the exit wound can be a nasty, jagged hole the size of an orange.
These high-velocity bullets can damage flesh inches away from their path, either because they fragment or because they cause something called cavitation. When you trail your fingers through water, the water ripples and curls. When a high-velocity bullet pierces the body, human tissues ripples as well---but much more violently. The bullet from an AR-15 might miss the femoral artery in the leg, but cavitation may burst the artery anyway, causing death by blood loss. A swath of stretched and torn tissue around the wound may die. Thats why, says Rhee, a handgun wound might require only one surgery but an AR-15 bullet wound might require three to ten.A bullet with more energy can do more damage. Its total kinetic energy is equal to one-half the mass of the bullet times its velocity squared. The bullet from a handgun is---as absurd as it may sound---slow compared to that from an AR-15. It can be stopped by the thick bone of the upper leg. It might pass through the body, only to become lodged in skin, which is surprisingly elastic.
Then, multiply the damage from a single bullet by the ease of shooting an AR-15, which doesnt kick. The gun barely moves. You can sit there boom boom boom and reel off shots as fast as you can move your finger, says Ernest Moore, a trauma surgeon at Denver Health and editor of the Journal of Trauma and Acute Surgery, which just published an issue dedicated to gun violence.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
111 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Some may disagree, but it is my strong opinion that if you cannot tag your deer using a bolt action [View all]
Atticus
Jul 2022
OP
The AR15 ammunition isn't any more powerful than that of standard rifles.
Elessar Zappa
Jul 2022
#11
You are correct. It's a common misconception that the AR-15's round is bad bc it's "too powerful"
Oneironaut
Jul 2022
#108
I don't understand those who think that hunting with a semi auto rifle
MarineCombatEngineer
Jul 2022
#69
My dad shot many deer with a bolt action rifle. I have shot 4 with a pump action shotgun
doc03
Jul 2022
#8
Except its legal to shoot and kill deer without provocation depending on state law
SYFROYH
Jul 2022
#94
True, but the legitimate use of guns is for hunting, self defense and target practise.
TigressDem
Jul 2022
#23
My dad always hunted with Springfield 1913 30-06 with the original military peep sight.
brewens
Jul 2022
#26
Well you know when you're up against an Abrams tank or an M777 or an atomic bomb
localroger
Jul 2022
#49
So you would rather have them die slowly from lack of graze cause by overcrowding
ripcord
Jul 2022
#44
I am quite sure that the deer that I manage to spot, track and kill are not the "best" of the herd.
WhiskeyGrinder
Jul 2022
#64
I don't hunt be be "bad ass," I hunt to get some good meat, among other reasons.
WhiskeyGrinder
Jul 2022
#63
I use a Mini 14 that fires the same overloaded .22 round as the AR 15 to hunt pigs
ripcord
Jul 2022
#43
Who said "gun rights are about hunting"? It is just that some DO use hunting as an
Atticus
Jul 2022
#93