Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Sky Jewels

(9,148 posts)
8. This is counterproductive.
Sun Jul 23, 2023, 01:39 PM
Jul 2023

We want white people (and people of all colors) to learn real history and acknowledge that white privilege is real and to have a multifaceted understanding of history and current times in terms of racial dynamics. But if you want to push the "you SHOULD be ashamed of being born white!" thing, then you will only make some white people defensive and angry and create unnecessary backlash. It plays into the hands of the far right.

Nobody has control over their genetics or what their ancestors did. I am, however, in favor of programs that give Black people a boost, a foot in the door, access to affordable higher education, etc., etc., because there is an enormous historical deficit in opportunities and wealth that needs to be overcome.

But shaming people for being born with pale skin is not helpful at all.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

This country was literally built on white supremacy ismnotwasm Jul 2023 #1
Hogwash wryter2000 Jul 2023 #2
This message was self-deleted by its author Stardust Mirror Jul 2023 #4
Zappa didn't say he wanted to be black Stardust Mirror Jul 2023 #5
I have no problem with that wryter2000 Jul 2023 #9
Exactly NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #6
IMHO, the whole thing about children feeling guilty is made up wryter2000 Jul 2023 #10
Agreed NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #11
As so often happens here at DU cyclonefence Jul 2023 #18
Often enough, that's the desired effect. Iggo Jul 2023 #21
I read the post wryter2000 Jul 2023 #31
Nope cyclonefence Jul 2023 #38
From the end of the post wryter2000 Jul 2023 #45
How long should we be ashamed for events that we had no control over? Chainfire Jul 2023 #3
Starts with the Children NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #13
Just treat everyone fairly in life. It's that simple. No one should be ashamed... brush Jul 2023 #17
But don't you see cyclonefence Jul 2023 #39
Well of course, but the chances of reparations paid to descendants of... brush Jul 2023 #40
I don't dare speak of financial reparations cyclonefence Jul 2023 #43
You understand. Reparations will probably never happen. brush Jul 2023 #44
Fostering unpleasant feelings only centers white people in discussions about race, which isn't super WhiskeyGrinder Jul 2023 #7
I partly agree with you gulliver Jul 2023 #12
This is counterproductive. Sky Jewels Jul 2023 #8
No one should be ashamed, even if family history has... brush Jul 2023 #16
Well put TheProle Jul 2023 #33
Depends on what you want to produce. Iggo Jul 2023 #22
People should be ashamed of their skin color? Sympthsical Jul 2023 #14
Great post. So well stated. brush Jul 2023 #15
bad messaging treestar Jul 2023 #19
Agree 💯👍 NT Tickle Jul 2023 #24
"Quit teaching black kids they are victims of racism and they won't feel like they are" Stardust Mirror Jul 2023 #26
how often does that happen in the 2020s? treestar Jul 2023 #27
how often do blacks experience racism in the 2020s? Stardust Mirror Jul 2023 #29
the police were tried and do lose the job treestar Jul 2023 #35
Teach the truth. And teach also of the great successes of Black people... brush Jul 2023 #42
Well, that's a weird thing to say. Iggo Jul 2023 #20
If we didn't write nonsense like this, the RW would have to invent it. tritsofme Jul 2023 #23
Well, I see I'm late to the party again DFW Jul 2023 #25
Actually, the Zappa lyrics are maxsolomon Jul 2023 #28
That makes a lot more sense than him saying he wished he was black. ShazzieB Jul 2023 #41
No thanks, I'm not playing that game. nt Raine Jul 2023 #30
I think the term woke is hopelessly cheesy and lame BannonsLiver Jul 2023 #32
I s'pose if I've ever felt pride towards the actions of my ancestors, Torchlight Jul 2023 #34
Message auto-removed Name removed Jul 2023 #36
I know people whose parents and grandparents were actual Nazis. Should they feel bad? hunter Jul 2023 #37
after watching Joy today, I was wondering if maybe the real reason tiny d is against black history ecstatic Jul 2023 #46
I think there's truth in what you say cyclonefence Jul 2023 #47
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I think being "woke" ough...»Reply #8