Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Jedi Guy

(3,471 posts)
136. Okay, so...
Fri Apr 26, 2024, 02:37 PM
Apr 2024

The first article from WhyAxis, in the second paragraph, linked to a study in which the abstract states outright, emphasis mine:

Liberals and conservatives are perceived to disagree on most aspects of life, even seemingly trivial things like pet choice. Although the question of whether liberals and conservatives differ in their liking for cats and dogs has been sporadically investigated, few peer-reviewed reports exist, results are mixed, and most reports examine this topic indirectly.

So there's that. In the same abstract, a "negative evaluation" of cats doesn't necessarily equate to hatred.

The second article requires a signup, which I'm not interested in doing, but it looks an awful lot like an opinion piece. The third article states outright that it is an opinion piece. The fourth article is also an opinion piece.

The fifth and sixth articles are about cat lovers being smarter than dog lovers, which does nothing to prove dog lovers "hate" cats or that disliking cats is somehow evidence of dark or sinister personality traits.

The final article's abstract states that dogs tend to be favored by "mainstream American culture", which isn't the same thing as saying cats are un-American.

TL;DR: I think I'll hold on to my skepticism of those three claims.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

What utter pond scum. blm Apr 2024 #1
Cruella DeVil peppertree Apr 2024 #38
To her credit, Cruella had style. cab67 Apr 2024 #178
Makes Romney look Traildogbob Apr 2024 #48
+1 peppertree Apr 2024 #111
WTF? PittBlue Apr 2024 #2
All Trump has to do is validate Noem's actions and MAGA will be onboard with Puppy Killing. TheBlackAdder Apr 2024 #71
I wonder if the MSM will jump on board also? LT Barclay Apr 2024 #109
No doubt. TheBlackAdder Apr 2024 #137
I think you might be right senseandsensibility Apr 2024 #131
South Dakota Codified Laws. Title 40. Animals and Livestock. Chapter 40-1. Cruelty, Abuse and Injury to Animals. brooklynite Apr 2024 #3
Someone needs to make a formal complaint. Baitball Blogger Apr 2024 #6
thank you. barbtries Apr 2024 #8
I think they left enough wiggle room in the law woodsprite Apr 2024 #37
Throwing the dog into a hole filled with rocks doesn't sound humane to me. Maraya1969 Apr 2024 #157
Open and shut - and apparently there were witnesses. dchill Apr 2024 #23
Sick, sick, sick. Elessar Zappa Apr 2024 #4
Not until '26 - but I'll tell you this: there go her Veep hopes peppertree Apr 2024 #42
Actually, I think the complete opposite. TRAITOR** does not give niyad Apr 2024 #58
You might be right - given the sick puppy he is. peppertree Apr 2024 #110
True and not true Dorian Gray Apr 2024 #205
I agree. She killed the dog because she was too lazy and cruel to make the effort Ocelot II Apr 2024 #226
Alpha female. Freethinker65 Apr 2024 #5
I doubt she's alpha anything. Mr. Evil Apr 2024 #17
A real alpha would have known how to train that dog NanaCat Apr 2024 #82
is that legal? barbtries Apr 2024 #7
In most red states it is, sadly peppertree Apr 2024 #39
Glad that animal abusing I_UndergroundPanther Apr 2024 #156
It was sad because it was mostly his father's doing peppertree Apr 2024 #160
My father was I_UndergroundPanther Apr 2024 #166
I'm very sorry to hear that. peppertree Apr 2024 #169
I am sad for the horror that kid faced I_UndergroundPanther May 2024 #232
Here is the article I just read sheshe2 Apr 2024 #9
OMG. I thought I couldn't be shocked any more by Republicans. yardwork Apr 2024 #28
Sadly this is the first article I saw this AM on twitter. sheshe2 Apr 2024 #40
She talks about watching the dog go on a killing spree, killing chickens 70sEraVet Apr 2024 #36
Have not read the article, but if what you say is true Dan Apr 2024 #66
BS NanaCat Apr 2024 #89
Not BS... Dan Apr 2024 #90
It's what many dogs do around chickens womanofthehills Apr 2024 #220
Unfortuntely, it happens all the time NickB79 Apr 2024 #185
Wow kcr Apr 2024 #91
I haven't seen it defended edisdead Apr 2024 #124
The poster I replied to said kcr Apr 2024 #177
Context is always helpful Polybius Apr 2024 #202
I unfortunately had to shoot a dog in just that situation as a teenager in the 90's NickB79 Apr 2024 #186
I have no personal experience to back this up, but they could have been feral dogs. LT Barclay Apr 2024 #189
Thanks, Dan. I hadnt considered that, not having been raised on a farm. 70sEraVet Apr 2024 #97
Yep. My father (a lifelong Democrat if that matters) put down a dog on the farm when I was a kid. progressoid Apr 2024 #122
I was raised in the country, too, and I urge you to read the full passage. yardwork Apr 2024 #128
Smile, as I acknowledged I hadn't read the article Dan Apr 2024 #142
I have volunteered at animal rescues in the past (mostly horses) leftieNanner Apr 2024 #163
What about seeking to rehome in a home with a fenced in yard BlueKota Apr 2024 #132
To answer your question - rehoming the dog... Dan Apr 2024 #140
It answers why it happened in the past when as you point out BlueKota Apr 2024 #147
why in the world did she bring her puppy to that home to begin with? ecstatic Apr 2024 #175
I see your point, Dan Apr 2024 #176
What's wrong with MFM008 Apr 2024 #207
What I do not understand about the chicken story, if true, is WHY she niyad Apr 2024 #214
She sounds like a psychopath making excuses for cruelty. blm Apr 2024 #73
A lot of violent criminals BlueKota Apr 2024 #139
The goat didn't deserve to die either MustLoveBeagles Apr 2024 #77
Apparently the goat was giving her attitude dflprincess Apr 2024 #192
Something is seriously wrong with her MustLoveBeagles Apr 2024 #197
What bdamomma Apr 2024 #10
I totally agree. She had zero justification. benfranklin1776 Apr 2024 #215
My way..... magicarpet Apr 2024 #11
When someone has no conscience dlk Apr 2024 #12
Halfway expecting her to say, "we used all of the carcass though, nothing went to waste" Torchlight Apr 2024 #13
Sadist Wild blueberry Apr 2024 #14
Not just admits, BOASTS. niyad Apr 2024 #53
Wow. What a piece of shit. CrispyQ Apr 2024 #15
Disgusting, absolutely disgusting. What a mean, evil person. Fla Dem Apr 2024 #16
The dog was "having the time of her life." dchill Apr 2024 #18
"No Going Back: The Truth on What's Wrong with Politics" Jerry2144 Apr 2024 #19
This is why we I_UndergroundPanther Apr 2024 #158
A predictable result when every "meaningful" presidential candidate has to be filmed handling a gun in some capacity to LT Barclay Apr 2024 #190
Isn't this how serial killers start? Farmer-Rick Apr 2024 #20
I worked with a guy who killed his dog for a similar reason rurallib Apr 2024 #21
I had neighbor who did the same thing. He was (of course) a rabid Repug. peppertree Apr 2024 #114
Knowing Donald Trump fears and hates dogs, Kristi Noem revs up her VP campaign by writing about killing a dog LetMyPeopleVote Apr 2024 #22
Do she and kimberley go to the same plastic surgeon? And I niyad Apr 2024 #63
Let's hope this is her Romney rooftop kennel moment Blue Owl Apr 2024 #24
Like the dog couldn't have been rehomed to a family PoindexterOglethorpe Apr 2024 #25
We adopted a dog in 2004 Lifeafter70 Apr 2024 #138
Thank you for that story. PoindexterOglethorpe Apr 2024 #187
I imagine she was quite beautiful! MissB Apr 2024 #198
All that botox affecting her mind?? NoMoreRepugs Apr 2024 #26
Well, it might help her with the defendant, but not with very many other people ms liberty Apr 2024 #27
Best dog ever had was a hunting dog reject zeusdogmom Apr 2024 #29
So was my german shorthair pointer. miyazaki Apr 2024 #62
In my life all dogs to heaven zeusdogmom Apr 2024 #80
No not at the moment. miyazaki Apr 2024 #170
"If there are no dogs in Heaven, then when I die I want to go where they went." ― Will Rogers LT Barclay Apr 2024 #191
Me, too. zeusdogmom Apr 2024 #193
Dog Killer is also an adulteress. Prof. Toru Tanaka Apr 2024 #115
A 14 month old dog can easily be rehomed exboyfil Apr 2024 #30
A hateful, spiteful, ugly-minded, vicious, evil, completely-lacking-in-decency one. niyad Apr 2024 #50
'I could shoot a dog on 5th Avenue and get away with it.' bucolic_frolic Apr 2024 #31
She's a definite shoe-in cilla4progress Apr 2024 #32
Laugh out loud..they elect only their best and brightest, don't they? Nt lostnfound Apr 2024 #104
You don't train a bird dog in one outing. Just like all other dogs short sessions which are then repeated. Botany Apr 2024 #33
She also killed the family's goat because "it smelled." catbyte Apr 2024 #34
Last I heard, it was still illegal to kill people in South Dakota DFW Apr 2024 #35
She also killed or got tens of thousands sickened with her response to COVID too. She is really sick. Botany Apr 2024 #108
Hope she Rebl2 Apr 2024 #41
"I hated that dog" Loryn Apr 2024 #43
Sick!! PortTack Apr 2024 #44
Why do Republican hate dogs? BoRaGard Apr 2024 #45
Most dogs are liberal IronLionZion Apr 2024 #65
I even have a magnet that says my dog is a Democrat. BlueKota Apr 2024 #149
But not most chihuahuas Bucky Apr 2024 #171
Little dictators IronLionZion Apr 2024 #172
Most of them don't. They hate cats. Sky Jewels Apr 2024 #105
Sources, please? Jedi Guy Apr 2024 #113
Here you go. Sky Jewels Apr 2024 #118
Okay, so... Jedi Guy Apr 2024 #136
About cat-hating and misogyny? Personal observation. I have niyad Apr 2024 #211
Because they are selfish and have no compassion BlueKota Apr 2024 #143
They hate cats worse I_UndergroundPanther Apr 2024 #161
Plus cats are smarter. Brenda Apr 2024 #206
Bout right I_UndergroundPanther Apr 2024 #227
May she receive everything she deserves. niyad Apr 2024 #46
I christen thee "Dog-Killer Kristi Noem." Paladin Apr 2024 #47
The GOP is a death cult. sop Apr 2024 #49
Whoever runs against her for governor again needs to put this in billboard ads and tv commmercials kimbutgar Apr 2024 #51
Angry beyond anything! North Shore Chicago Apr 2024 #52
Worse than Romney strapping Seamus to the roof Danmel Apr 2024 #54
Empathy CloudWatcher Apr 2024 #55
I use to wonder that too. No more. DontBelieveEastisEas Apr 2024 #204
She's on TSF's VP shortlist, right? 0rganism Apr 2024 #56
As someone who grew up in that area of the country around that type of environment Nac Mac Feegle Apr 2024 #57
As I stated above NanaCat Apr 2024 #78
There is a type of person who likes to cosplay "being a farmer." yardwork Apr 2024 #212
Another trash human Republican. JanMichael Apr 2024 #59
Human? Jilly_in_VA Apr 2024 #180
She was doing a good job of covering up her sociopathy up until now. GoCubsGo Apr 2024 #60
Trump-Noem ticket should lose the dog lover vote IronLionZion Apr 2024 #61
"Donald Trump fears and hates dogs" Prof. Toru Tanaka Apr 2024 #119
I know someone who is a hunter Bettie Apr 2024 #64
The Truth on What's Wrong with Politics and How We Move America Forward patphil Apr 2024 #67
disgusting piece of shit samsingh Apr 2024 #68
She will see Trump in hell. nt TeamProg Apr 2024 #69
I'm no fan of dogs NanaCat Apr 2024 #70
I have 3 dogs UpInArms Apr 2024 #130
I had 1 dog in my life I_UndergroundPanther Apr 2024 #165
JohnSJ ............ Upthevibe Apr 2024 #72
The real "tell" is that she hated certain animals. colorado_ufo Apr 2024 #74
this tweet says it all moonshinegnomie Apr 2024 #75
Snicker niyad Apr 2024 #217
She's a monster MustLoveBeagles Apr 2024 #76
A dog killer Sugarcoated Apr 2024 #79
Seriously sick sociopath Bayard Apr 2024 #81
Dad was a hunter kwijybo Apr 2024 #83
Your dad sounds like a remarkable person. yardwork Apr 2024 #213
Is she up for reelction in 2024? Is there a decent democrat running against her in her next election? BComplex Apr 2024 #84
2026, according to a post upthread. niyad Apr 2024 #216
Thanks niyad! BComplex Apr 2024 #222
I think her "gravel pit" needs to be excavated. Solly Mack Apr 2024 #85
That is a most excellent, horrifying point. niyad Apr 2024 #219
Everything about that story - and her - is horrifying. Solly Mack Apr 2024 #225
Sadly true. niyad Apr 2024 #229
This story makes me sick to my stomach. I can't believe she told it. There go her VP chances. beaglelover Apr 2024 #86
I try, I really try Aviation Pro Apr 2024 #87
the party of sociopaths. nt Javaman Apr 2024 #88
This message was self-deleted by its author maxsolomon Apr 2024 #92
I have one wish for the universe... llmart Apr 2024 #93
Are the pup's body parts displayed on the walls to exhibit her skills as a hunter and Ping Tung Apr 2024 #94
What a sick person she is. Progressive dog Apr 2024 #95
I rarely wish physical harm on an individual, but it would be really nice if her fucking Vinca Apr 2024 #96
She will never get elected in this country again... JCMach1 Apr 2024 #98
Isn't she worthless as a thinking governor? GreenWave Apr 2024 #99
What an absolute piece of sh*t awesomerwb1 Apr 2024 #100
She has probably ruined her political career. Sky Jewels Apr 2024 #101
MAGAs will love it BannonsLiver Apr 2024 #103
I won't say what I would like for her fate to be get the red out Apr 2024 #102
I took a dog whose owner didn't want him because he wasn't "fit to hunt". Midnight Writer Apr 2024 #106
Horrible woman. Disgusting. I would not mourn her passing. Liberal In Texas Apr 2024 #107
A HIT PIECE? Jimvanhise Apr 2024 #112
The story is blowing up, and we know why. yardwork Apr 2024 #164
She admitted to it, in part I think, to demonstrate her utter disregard for life - and her ruthlessness.. Harker Apr 2024 #116
Those qualities are seen as positive in her sicko, warped Maga bubble. Sky Jewels Apr 2024 #120
I hope so. n/t Harker Apr 2024 #153
Kristi Noem the Puppy Killer is a piece of shit JoseBalow Apr 2024 #117
My heart cries for that dog JustAnotherGen Apr 2024 #121
Noem is human garbage GenThePerservering Apr 2024 #123
Wow, what a truly colossal piece of shit! Initech Apr 2024 #125
What is with Republicans and dog abuse? anglesphere Apr 2024 #126
She should be imprisonment for animal cruelty BlueKota Apr 2024 #127
doesn't sound like she tried very hard. unblock Apr 2024 #129
What a piece of shit. ismnotwasm Apr 2024 #133
A misbehaved dog (of any type) slightlv Apr 2024 #134
I called on Nemesis, Goddess of Divine Retribution. niyad Apr 2024 #221
All power to you and Nemesis, Niyad.. slightlv Apr 2024 #223
I call on Hecate for some things, as well. They are very busy! niyad Apr 2024 #224
Trump will probably admire her for it, but he has to wonder if she was that ruthless, what might she do to him if Liberal In Texas Apr 2024 #135
Not only does she not deserve a place on the presidential ticket. She doesn't deserve a place in the human race. usaf-vet Apr 2024 #141
At least Mitt only made the kids' dog ride on the station wagon's roof. sop Apr 2024 #144
She probably shot it just to be able today she shot it. Renew Deal Apr 2024 #145
Health care w/ Noem in charge. oasis Apr 2024 #146
She's useless as a governor geardaddy Apr 2024 #148
What's Wrong With Cold heartless Noem?!! Cha Apr 2024 #150
She is disgusting! red dog 1 Apr 2024 #151
Wire haired pointer Sanity Claws Apr 2024 #152
How long before she utters the phrase, "that dog won't hunt" in reference to a political disagreement... Harker Apr 2024 #154
Sociopath scum I_UndergroundPanther Apr 2024 #155
Mitt Romney has never lived down strapping his dog to his car roof. Emrys Apr 2024 #159
She's less than worthless as a governor and human, so... Lucky Luciano Apr 2024 #162
One sick bitch. No offense to mother dogs or women in general. That slur (or name) should be eliminated but I find it Evolve Dammit Apr 2024 #167
Fuck that evil woman... LudwigPastorius Apr 2024 #168
Who's a good boi? GenThePerservering Apr 2024 #196
The Lincoln Project-It's so tragic that Kristi Noem didn't see this important PSA before she did what she did. LetMyPeopleVote Apr 2024 #173
Isn't that illegal? Someone went to jail for leaving a puppy on the side of the road ecstatic Apr 2024 #174
Pity her poor children, they must live in constant fear. KY_EnviroGuy Apr 2024 #179
Noem is less than worthless as a human dai13sy Apr 2024 #181
And, apparently , shot and killed a goat, the same day, soldierant Apr 2024 #182
Kristi Noem: Puppy Slaughterer Blue Owl Apr 2024 #183
This message was self-deleted by its author LudwigPastorius Apr 2024 #194
Now they're bragging about killing puppies! Mr. Mustard 2023 Apr 2024 #184
Cold, cold heart. Joinfortmill Apr 2024 #188
A responsible opposing viewpoint..... brooklynite Apr 2024 #195
Republicans prey on the weak and defenseless. This one is the worst of the worst. GoodRaisin Apr 2024 #199
A complaint was filed against Kristi Nome with the Pierre SD Chief of Police, ( @cityofpierresd ). LetMyPeopleVote Apr 2024 #200
Her action was wrong. Full stop. Layzeebeaver Apr 2024 #201
Wow! This Thread has more "recs" and "replies" BigmanPigman Apr 2024 #203
May this repulsive act follow her for the rest of her sick life. Paladin Apr 2024 #208
The dog was likely dangerous. A lawsuit waiting to happen. JohnnyRingo Apr 2024 #209
should I shoot my dog in the head and dump her a quarry? EleanorR Apr 2024 #228
If your dog goes on a killing spree you should be concerned. JohnnyRingo Apr 2024 #231
Oh so sorry, you said there's a better way to kill a dog EleanorR Apr 2024 #230
I consider her a potential threat to one of my family members Norbert Apr 2024 #210
Trump VP contender defends killing dog struggle4progress Apr 2024 #218
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»This is beyond sick. Kri...»Reply #136