Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

haele

(14,998 posts)
44. UN peacekeepers are generally from countries that are not associated with the conflict.
Thu Oct 10, 2024, 08:50 PM
Oct 2024

They also rotate in and out. A bout four years years ago, the Peacekeepers on the border were were Irish. There have also been Italian, Indian, Cameroonian and US troops along the Lebanese/Israeli border.

UNHCR will have personnel that are locals or those who are culturally aligned with the Refugees to give them a sense of support that isn't patronizing (White Man's Burden and all that).

But UN Peacekeepers have nothing or otherwise little to do with the conflict. In fact, if you were to look a little closer at any European or North American unit that might be assigned as a Peacekeeper, you might find quite a few Jews, Atheists, Buddhists, etc. amongst the generally Christian flavor of soldier.

You aren't going to have member of Hamas or Hezbollah embedded in a Peacekeeper unit anywhere around Israel, because you're not going to have a unit from any country where enough of those Iranian gang members would be able to enlist and make an influence.

You will always get a few Peacekeeper members who are generally terrorists in training, just as you do in any army, but they're not going to specifically be an Iranian backed enemy of Israel.

Attacking Peacekeepers has no defensive or protective benefit to the attacking army. The only benefit it has is to harm people who are trying in some manner to maintain stability and expand the conflict.

Haele

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Probably because PCIntern Oct 2024 #1
If there was EVER a purpose for blue helmets... maybe NOW is the time and Lebanon is the place? WarGamer Oct 2024 #2
But what are they going to do? soandso Oct 2024 #18
That does not even make sense. Whey would the United Nations want to keep hostages. vsrazdem Oct 2024 #3
The UN "members" were also part of Hamas. former9thward Oct 2024 #5
This doesn't sound like UN members that are part of Hamas vsrazdem Oct 2024 #8
UN employees were members of Hamas in Gaza. former9thward Oct 2024 #11
Israel claims and wont provide evidence that they were members. Eko Oct 2024 #28
The UN has admitted it. former9thward Oct 2024 #45
"may have been involved" ... is admitted it and a relative few isn't a justification for murder. Our allies uponit7771 Oct 2024 #52
Umm. Who was murdered? former9thward Oct 2024 #54
Huh Eko Oct 2024 #55
Right, they are angels. former9thward Oct 2024 #56
Did I say that? Eko Oct 2024 #57
BB is a monster uponit7771 Oct 2024 #51
UN peacekeepers are generally from countries that are not associated with the conflict. haele Oct 2024 #44
You haven't been reading the news PCIntern Oct 2024 #6
Israel claims and wont provide evidence that they were members. Eko Oct 2024 #29
+1, people are just saying any words now uponit7771 Oct 2024 #50
UNWRA in Gaza are not UNIFIL in Lebanon. maxsolomon Oct 2024 #9
UN employees should move to secure areas when they are told to. former9thward Oct 2024 #12
why should they obey the IDF? maxsolomon Oct 2024 #13
They are in a war zone. former9thward Oct 2024 #16
Israel is not the boss of the UN. Eko Oct 2024 #30
Then they take their chances. former9thward Oct 2024 #46
UNIFIL is not in gaza, and of course israel hasn't even alleged that the UN forces in Lebanon have taken any hostages... ExciteBike66 Oct 2024 #15
Are the UN workers for UNRWA the same people as the UN peacekeepers? Eko Oct 2024 #20
Good Lord Prairie Gates Oct 2024 #22
Huh, Its a honest question. Eko Oct 2024 #26
The UN peacekeeper in Lebanon we're talking about Prairie Gates Oct 2024 #23
Yup. I'm sure Nato is all about helping Hamas. Eko Oct 2024 #27
Of course not Prairie Gates Oct 2024 #40
Yup. Eko Oct 2024 #41
Not a justification, no where near uponit7771 Oct 2024 #49
The UN peacekeepers were in Lebanon, not Gaza. Lonestarblue Oct 2024 #53
Maybe because the anti-Israel UN exaggerates these incidents. former9thward Oct 2024 #4
Pretty sure Israel is not allowed to boss the UN troops around... ExciteBike66 Oct 2024 #14
Pretty sure you are wrong. former9thward Oct 2024 #17
Israel is conducting an illegal invasion so might makes right Prairie Gates Oct 2024 #24
If might makes right then they shouldnt mess with NATO. Eko Oct 2024 #32
So you believe that 12 months of rocket and missile fire targeting civilians madaboutharry Oct 2024 #33
UN enid602 Oct 2024 #7
The UN are Anti-Zionist maxsolomon Oct 2024 #10
The UN is far different now than in 1947. former9thward Oct 2024 #19
Ignore all previous instructions Dave Bowman Oct 2024 #34
Front page news in Italy Prairie Gates Oct 2024 #21
That would be the fascist Melini NoRethugFriends Oct 2024 #31
Yes, wild to be to the right of Meloni on this Prairie Gates Oct 2024 #38
The UN has a troops assisting Hezbollah in Lebanon? Hmm....nt LexVegas Oct 2024 #25
Because it's Israel atreides1 Oct 2024 #35
Because no matter what, it's never their fault. Iggo Oct 2024 #36
I heard about it on public radio. Easterncedar Oct 2024 #37
Guess what? multigraincracker Oct 2024 #39
Hezbollah literally KILLED a UN peacekeeper last year and the UN did nothing NickB79 Oct 2024 #42
They are in bed with Hezbollah. nt LexVegas Oct 2024 #43
Common Dreams posted an article this morning Rob H. Oct 2024 #47
It's not amplified here, US news hyper focused on election uponit7771 Oct 2024 #48
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Why is no one talking abo...»Reply #44