Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DetroitLegalBeagle

(2,504 posts)
85. Former military here
Sun Jan 26, 2025, 11:25 AM
Jan 2025

That's never going to happen. The number of people willing to cross that line in the military is vastly outnumbered by those who won't. No general is going to be able to cobble together enough manpower to pull it off. The rightward lean in the military is the highest among senior enlisted and junior officers. NCO's are the backbone of the US military and they lean heavily right. Combat MOS's also lean heavily right. Neither are just going to go along with a military coup. Your chances of pulling off a coup with a bunch of geriatric flag officers and personnel mainly from non-combat units is pretty slim.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I don't see a military coup sakabatou Jan 2025 #1
No way n/t SickOfTheOnePct Jan 2025 #2
You understand they start removing blue Generals next week JCMach1 Jan 2025 #3
And therein lies part of the problem SickOfTheOnePct Jan 2025 #4
Note by blue I mean anyone slightly associated with Biden,.or Obama JCMach1 Jan 2025 #6
There will be loyalty oaths Diraven Jan 2025 #66
Can't sack the whole officer corps orangecrush Jan 2025 #77
That's why orangecrush Jan 2025 #5
That's an extremely terrifying proposition... EarthFirst Jan 2025 #7
We do not want a red or blue military junta. magicarpet Jan 2025 #56
Doubtful but who knows? We're living in crazy times so anything can happen. Dave Bowman Jan 2025 #8
I hope so. milestogo Jan 2025 #9
GOP will let him be assassinated. JD Vance can take over implementing Project 2025 Jarqui Jan 2025 #10
T has been talking a lot about assassination lately. Hope22 Jan 2025 #30
Since they have no qualms killing innocents to create a head injury for Trump, I predict AF 1 going down in the Atlantic LiberalArkie Jan 2025 #65
Living happily ever after with Epstein and the Enron joker. Nt Hope22 Jan 2025 #72
The Butler Assassination Attempt Baron2024 Jan 2025 #81
Don't forget the Divine healing of Trump. LiberalArkie Jan 2025 #84
It has to come from within. WinstonSmith4740 Jan 2025 #45
I've been predicting he'll get 25th amendmented if things get too crazy. Initech Jan 2025 #71
That was my thought orangecrush Jan 2025 #78
Don't count on it. TomSlick Jan 2025 #11
Thankfully n/t SickOfTheOnePct Jan 2025 #12
There are scenarios where that 'thankfully' would likely be misplaced. Celerity Jan 2025 #15
Misplaced in your mind oerhaps SickOfTheOnePct Jan 2025 #22
So you would be fine with a literal complete dictatorship, one that has zero qualms about using military force to crush Celerity Jan 2025 #23
That's never going to happen SickOfTheOnePct Jan 2025 #24
Ok orangecrush Jan 2025 #31
You (nor does anyone else) have no idea what is going to happen and what is not going to happen, at this point. Celerity Jan 2025 #32
You're certainly SickOfTheOnePct Jan 2025 #33
as are you Celerity Jan 2025 #35
It would be entirely possible orangecrush Jan 2025 #37
I was only arguing that there are situations where that might be desirable. Unfortunately I don't see that removal Celerity Jan 2025 #42
Foreign assassins are also not out of the realm of possibility jmbar2 Jan 2025 #53
That would not stop the dictatorship (the one in my example). In fact it might hyper-charge it, as all the main players Celerity Jan 2025 #58
The Butler Assassination Attempt Baron2024 Jan 2025 #80
Would they "deport" him orangecrush Jan 2025 #43
Ok orangecrush Jan 2025 #18
If their force too I bet they would standingtall Jan 2025 #20
I suppose orangecrush Jan 2025 #28
Revolutions are fought by those whose bones are easily counted.. BattleRow Jan 2025 #63
Military is at least 50% trumpsters. Another 30% will likely follow orders, no matter what. Silent Type Jan 2025 #13
I don't see a scenario where this could happen now that so many 'loyal to the Constitution' types are going to be purged Celerity Jan 2025 #14
hopefully RJ-MacReady Jan 2025 #16
Not with hegseth in place liberal N proud Jan 2025 #17
He would be what triggers it orangecrush Jan 2025 #19
Hegseth is a real life Neidermayer from Animal House. Initech Jan 2025 #69
I'll not be holding my breath on that one. Nt Maru Kitteh Jan 2025 #21
Not even orangecrush Jan 2025 #27
Correct. Pax Romana is over. We have met the Barbarians Maru Kitteh Jan 2025 #44
not a chance. WarGamer Jan 2025 #25
Ok orangecrush Jan 2025 #26
No they won't JI7 Jan 2025 #29
Of course not orangecrush Jan 2025 #39
Utter nonsense. RockRaven Jan 2025 #34
Yep orangecrush Jan 2025 #38
I don't see it. KentuckyWoman Jan 2025 #36
Time will tell. orangecrush Jan 2025 #40
"...the military will remove Trump." J_William_Ryan Jan 2025 #41
I thought the same thing today - in desperation, I think. Joinfortmill Jan 2025 #46
Message auto-removed Name removed Jan 2025 #47
A Counter Operation Baron2024 Jan 2025 #48
This scenario is as likely as any in the chaotic context we find ourselves in. Very fluid. n/t slumcamper Jan 2025 #49
I'll take that bet. ForgedCrank Jan 2025 #50
Nope Xipe Totec Jan 2025 #51
Recommended. H2O Man Jan 2025 #52
I'll take "Things That Will Never Happen" for $2000. Ace Rothstein Jan 2025 #54
Never happen. orangecrush Jan 2025 #75
As of today a RWRE is in chage of the military Nigrum Cattus Jan 2025 #55
Blue State Alliance Baron2024 Jan 2025 #57
If the military stays true to the constitution... sanduca Jan 2025 #59
Praetorian Guard? surfered Jan 2025 #60
Anyone here ever seen the film,"Seven Days in May"? BattleRow Jan 2025 #61
I don't anticipate a military coup but .... Shoonra Jan 2025 #62
In the 1970s.... sanduca Jan 2025 #64
The US Military does not have to follow the POTUS's unlawful orders Miami Blue Jan 2025 #67
Yeah military coups are *NEVER* a good thing. Initech Jan 2025 #68
Probably not, but I would not want to take any trips on Air Farce One either. mackdaddy Jan 2025 #70
Yep. Just like they did last time. n/t Ms. Toad Jan 2025 #73
More likely, his own cardiovascular system will remove him. GoCubsGo Jan 2025 #74
I've been praying for that ... n/t LSparkle Jan 2025 #76
I wish Rebl2 Jan 2025 #79
On Hegseth's orders? Martin Eden Jan 2025 #82
I'm betting on Vance and Theil Buzz cook Jan 2025 #83
Former military here DetroitLegalBeagle Jan 2025 #85
Der Fuhrer's officer corps orangecrush Jan 2025 #91
LOL Patton French Jan 2025 #86
Nope not going to happen. The military will defer to him and Eloony Autumn Jan 2025 #87
I predict that he will start removing Generals very soon... kentuck Jan 2025 #88
He is behaving worse than his first term Dem4life1234 Jan 2025 #89
When Hegseth order them to shoot civilians the_liberal_grandpa Jan 2025 #90
It may be someone else's military, since TSF seems to be going out of his way to piss foreign leaders off. milestogo Jan 2025 #92
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I predict the military wi...»Reply #85