General Discussion

Beastly Boy

(13,283 posts)

23. Are you willing to acknowledge that the culpability for starting the war is on Hamas?

Fri Feb 21, 2025, 12:01 AM

Feb 2025

Are you willing to acknowledge that Israel's actions were a response to what Hamas initiated?

If not, you have no standing to ask about Israel's culpability.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

13 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

madaboutharry KayossZero rollin74 adnoid The Revolution Mossfern Earl_from_PA MarineCombatEngineer Mosby calguy cabotnn22 Arazi Raine

103 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Israel brutally killed at least 17,400 children in Gaza. How can anyone defend that? [View all] HereForTheParty Feb 2025 OP

Easy, you just blame it on Hamas. Big Blue Marble Feb 2025 #1

I was gonna say Traildogbob Feb 2025 #27

Thank you malaise Feb 2025 #2

It would have been impossible to bomb around the children. maxsolomon Feb 2025 #3

I've seen many posters defend it on this site Sewa Feb 2025 #4

NOBODY Mossfern Feb 2025 #46

I must have been hallucinating or arguing with myself for 15 months. AloeVera Feb 2025 #93

What bullshit is this? MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #59

In your post denying anyone was defending Israel's bombing of children, you did exactly that. Ms. Toad Feb 2025 #69

Bullshit. MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #75

Thank-you, that is exactly right. Hamas owns this tragedy. If they didn't do October 7, this would have never happened JohnSJ Feb 2025 #80

And those children would be alive today if Israel has not bombed civilian targets in Gaza. Ms. Toad Feb 2025 #83

I'm curious, MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #84

You are not the only person reading this thread. Ms. Toad Feb 2025 #86

With all due respect as a fellow DU'er calguy Feb 2025 #78

Nonsense. Ms. Toad Feb 2025 #81

Why is it when something is said that makes Hamas look bad sarisataka Feb 2025 #5

Retraumatization Bad Thoughts Feb 2025 #7

No. Because we have been hurting for 15 months. AloeVera Feb 2025 #88

The Gazan children should have mattered to Hamas Bad Thoughts Feb 2025 #89

Exactly, thank you. MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #91

Gaza's children should matter to everybody. AloeVera Feb 2025 #92

Very telling Mountainguy Feb 2025 #9

Why is it when something is said that makes Israel look bad ratchiweenie Feb 2025 #41

It is easy to say, but is not true sarisataka Feb 2025 #64

Lack of any comments by the OP. Just throwing a flame and then moved to other areas question everything Feb 2025 #68

Strange isn't it. nt MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #60

Strange? No. Expected? Absolutely. n/t Behind the Aegis Feb 2025 #62

Damn it, MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #63

LOL! I know. I was adding to your sarcasm, with some of my own... Behind the Aegis Feb 2025 #65

Hamas started the war. Bad Thoughts Feb 2025 #6

This "war" was started a long time ago. Big Blue Marble Feb 2025 #11

On October 6, 2023, there was a ceasefire. Bad Thoughts Feb 2025 #12

Breaking a ceasefire is not starting a war. Big Blue Marble Feb 2025 #13

Gazans have spoken for themselves Bad Thoughts Feb 2025 #15

Your compassion and your ability to process Big Blue Marble Feb 2025 #16

My compassion is fine Bad Thoughts Feb 2025 #18

Are you willing to acknowledge that Israel has culpability in this "war?" Big Blue Marble Feb 2025 #20

Are you willing to acknowledge that the culpability for starting the war is on Hamas? Beastly Boy Feb 2025 #23

I'm still trying to wrap my head around how Mountainguy Feb 2025 #99

You think dancing and singing in front of dead kids LeftInTX Feb 2025 #25

Can I find your comments of condemnation somewhere moniss Feb 2025 #29

That's also wrong. But it's OK if Hamas does it? LeftInTX Feb 2025 #30

Did I say that? I have been unequivocal for a very, moniss Feb 2025 #33

No I think it is horrible. Big Blue Marble Feb 2025 #35

Nearly half of the current population hadn't been born yet when "they voted for Hamas". Mariana Feb 2025 #17

Those are fantastic arguments for the all-out destruction of Hamas Orrex Feb 2025 #19

Why stop there? Let's eliminate just one other bullshit rationalization, OK? Beastly Boy Feb 2025 #34

When you violate a cease fire by crossing the international border, massacring 1000 civilians on the other side, Beastly Boy Feb 2025 #22

Well then maybe HAMAs shouldn't have broken a working cease fire MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #61

And Israel was breaking international law by continuing to expand their settlements EdmondDantes_ Feb 2025 #24

In Gaza? Beastly Boy Feb 2025 #36

Israel was caught conducting covert operations in Gaza during moniss Feb 2025 #28

Did any of those alleged covert operations involve taking hostages? Beastly Boy Feb 2025 #37

An argument can be made that covert operations restarted the war. intheflow Feb 2025 #45

That argument cannot be made: the fact is the covert operations didn't restart the war. Hamas attack on Israel did. Beastly Boy Feb 2025 #47

Is spying illegal? intheflow Feb 2025 #50

Yes it is. So is jaywalking. Neither constitutes violaion unless it disregards the specific terms of the agreement. Beastly Boy Feb 2025 #90

Where do you get the idea spying is a war crime? sarisataka Feb 2025 #49

First, the Hague decision only applies to wartime spying. intheflow Feb 2025 #52

It can be illegal but it is not a "war crime" sarisataka Feb 2025 #53

Fair enough. intheflow Feb 2025 #54

That's not a justification for needlessly trusting BB not to murder uponit7771 Feb 2025 #82

Hamas killed 17,400 kids. Mosby Feb 2025 #8

Hamas killed children in Gaza, not Israel cabotnn22 Feb 2025 #10

A questionnaire n for everyone who recced that post Violet_Crumble Feb 2025 #31

As someone who rec'd the post, I must point out that its premise has been taken completely out of context. Beastly Boy Feb 2025 #39

You misspelled Hamas. nt RandomNumbers Feb 2025 #14

The Israel / Hamas conflict needs a good leaving alone here. TomSlick Feb 2025 #21

I think it was Israel's 9/11. OAITW r.2.0 Feb 2025 #26

And like 9/11 the response was ultimately crazy. Sneederbunk Feb 2025 #32

I'd argue it was a normal expected response for homo sapiens, not crazy. maxsolomon Feb 2025 #44

Killing babies & children is wrong. H2O Man Feb 2025 #38

IDF: Captors of Bibas children 'brutally murdered them with their bare hands' question everything Feb 2025 #42

Question Everything... unless it comes from IDF's spokespeople. intheflow Feb 2025 #48

Did you bother to read? Yes, IDF spokespeople. And their father was notified and saw the unspeakable question everything Feb 2025 #51

Hamas videotaped the father getting the news that his kids were murdered Arazi Feb 2025 #56

The bodies have indeed been seen. madaboutharry Feb 2025 #57

"Mutilated to cover up their crime" is what I read. AloeVera Feb 2025 #96

Their father, Yarden Bibas, has verified the findings. madaboutharry Feb 2025 #97

I see. AloeVera Feb 2025 #98

We're getting into Jeffrey Dahmer territory now. Mosby Feb 2025 #66

Any person of basic decency cannot. However, the AIPAC type peoples, the Fundies and MAGAs accept any talking point to artemisia1 Feb 2025 #40

AIPAC type people? madaboutharry Feb 2025 #58

Post removed Post removed Feb 2025 #94

The definition of The Dual Loyalty Canard. madaboutharry Feb 2025 #95

Take it outside. artemisia1 Feb 2025 #101

Hamas started a war it knew it couldn't win and hid behind civilians Jose Garcia Feb 2025 #43

Wait till you hear how many kids died in WWII.... Happy Hoosier Feb 2025 #55

Curious why the OP just threw a flaming comment, and never bothered to respond question everything Feb 2025 #67

Are the Bibas children innocent? People want to know. Mosby Feb 2025 #70

Oh the fucking goddamned irony. Behind the Aegis Feb 2025 #71

I have to wonder, if these were Jewish trans kids sarisataka Feb 2025 #77

Repulsive cabotnn22 Feb 2025 #87

This sums up my feelings. Mosby Feb 2025 #72

May those who supported the Palestinians be haunted forever Mosby Feb 2025 #73

They celebrated killing little babies. Mosby Feb 2025 #74

To paraphrase Shakespeare: A Pox upon both your Houses! no_hypocrisy Feb 2025 #76

Palestinians get paid to murder, up to 40K per year. Mosby Feb 2025 #79

I haven't seen anyone defending that on DU. Progressive dog Feb 2025 #85

How can anyone refer to Hamas as freedom fighters? nt LexVegas Feb 2025 #100

These IDF soldiers served in Gaza and the West Bank. I do not doubt their patriotism or their love of Israel. C0RI0LANUS Feb 2025 #102

Thank you for your post. David__77 Feb 2025 #103