Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(37,048 posts)
14. I have struggled my whole adult life to understand the ethics of...
Wed Jul 2, 2025, 10:36 AM
Jul 2025

...the nuclear bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. At different times I've been on different sides of the question.

As the end of my life approaches, having studied the literature on the Japanese internal debate on surrender, I am inclined to agree with your father.

As an advocate of nuclear energy, regarding it as the only acceptable form of energy, I have made it a point to understand nuclear weapons, which I generally oppose, but one could argue that their existence may have brought a sobering restraint on the outbreak of another World War, leaving it a "cold" war.

These questions do not yield easily to simplistic reasoning. It is disturbing that large nuclear arsenals are controlled by men lacking ethics and in the case of the orange creature in the White House, an already low level of intellect further compromised by clear dementia.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

My father told me something similar. mommymarine2003 Jul 2025 #1
My first husband was older. murielm99 Jul 2025 #2
A Japanese friend said the bomb ended feudalism Easterncedar Jul 2025 #3
An interesting point well worth thinking on Attilatheblond Jul 2025 #11
We know he is unfit but kacekwl Jul 2025 #4
Thank you for this most excellent viewpoint, my dear PCIntern. CaliforniaPeggy Jul 2025 #5
Thank you my dear CaliforniaPeggy.... PCIntern Jul 2025 #6
Your last sentence...yes. ChazInAz Jul 2025 #7
I don't think so... PCIntern Jul 2025 #9
This! We must all live in a reality based world. Idealism is a good thing. Facing reality will save our asses. Joinfortmill Jul 2025 #8
"...there is nothing beneath you..." hay rick Jul 2025 #10
TRUMP IS NUTS! Kid Berwyn Jul 2025 #12
Remember the old adage: DENVERPOPS Jul 2025 #13
True. Trump isn't the end-all-be-all of the Republican problem. He's a useful tool for rightwing extremists... Beartracks Jul 2025 #21
There is an element to being a cult leader that isn't easily replaceable or reproduceable. Vance sure doesn't have it. CrispyQ Jul 2025 #27
Hey DENVERPOPS Jul 2025 #32
I agree with your post. Once the bill is passed all bets are off. -nt CrispyQ Jul 2025 #35
I have struggled my whole adult life to understand the ethics of... NNadir Jul 2025 #14
Three, or four, elderly Psychotic Men DENVERPOPS Jul 2025 #33
Agreed. We will "beneath us" right in to oblivion with these zero integrity magats sarchasm Jul 2025 #15
Two topics in the o.p. - the asshole and the bomb. 3Hotdogs Jul 2025 #16
Then there are those who didn't have to go serve during that wartime nitpicked Jul 2025 #17
Before you degrade Carter DENVERPOPS Jul 2025 #34
That is one point of view. Let's try another POV. There was no need for an invasion of Japan. flashman13 Jul 2025 #18
Interesting story! Doodles Jul 2025 #19
So it was just a pure coinkydink that they surrendered PCIntern Jul 2025 #22
No not at all. We didn't let them surrender until after we dropped the bombs. flashman13 Jul 2025 #28
And the bombs allowed the emperor to save face rather than just outright surrender because they were beaten. flashman13 Jul 2025 #29
Utter rewriting of a horrifying time. PCIntern Jul 2025 #31
Replying to my own comment: PCIntern Jul 2025 #36
I am not going to argue the point with you. I stand by everything I have said. It is historical fact. flashman13 Jul 2025 #37
You're not going to argue and then you write three expository paragraphs doing just that: PCIntern Jul 2025 #38
" ...there is nothing beneath you when you're fighting for your life and your children and grandchildren's lives." OldBaldy1701E Jul 2025 #20
That was the story at the time, it wasn't true Nigrum Cattus Jul 2025 #23
A Bomb. A Radioman. A River. And a Father I Almost Never Knew. usaf-vet Jul 2025 #24
This jives with my family history.... PCIntern Jul 2025 #30
Let's remember that Donald Trump is a pathological liar with zero credibility Martin Eden Jul 2025 #25
It would be nice to have a propaganda network of AM radio stations and Cable News channels maxsolomon Jul 2025 #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»We are going to do this t...»Reply #14