Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Haaretz - Leading Israeli Author David Grossman Calls Gaza War a 'Genocide [View all]AloeVera
(4,274 posts)27. Unequal access to shelters is yet another form of discrimination Palestinian Citizens of Israel face.
Most Palestinian Citizens of Israel (those called "Arabs" by Israelis) live in three distinct areas of Israel, in towns and villages that are segregated from their Jewish fellow citizens. Ironically mirroring the conditions of their brethren in the West Bank.
The incident you linked to seems to have occurred in a "mixed" neighbourhood. But remember, that is not the norm.
Further, the real issue when it comes to shelters is that the State of Israel has not seen fit to provide Palestinian citizens with nearly the same level of shelters that it has provided to Jewish Israelis.
The Israel Democracy Institute (IDI), an independent research center published a report in the wake of the Tamra attack, describing how Arab communities remain unaddressed almost two years since the outbreak of war. The report points to the significant gaps in protection between Arab and Jewish communities.
Civil defense capabilities are built into the infrastructure of Israel. Israeli law requires all homes, residential buildings, and industrial building built since the early 1990s to have bomb shelters. These shelters prove crucial to protect Israelis when warning sirens go off providing the public with safe and fortified locations to hide from incoming rockets.
However, many Palestinian towns in the countrys north lack public shelters, protected areas, and shelter facilities, according to a statement from the Association for Civil Rights in Israel.
The urgency in providing such a response gains secondary validity in light of the fact that the main disparity in the field of defense in the northern district is within Arab towns, the statement continued.
Civil defense capabilities are built into the infrastructure of Israel. Israeli law requires all homes, residential buildings, and industrial building built since the early 1990s to have bomb shelters. These shelters prove crucial to protect Israelis when warning sirens go off providing the public with safe and fortified locations to hide from incoming rockets.
However, many Palestinian towns in the countrys north lack public shelters, protected areas, and shelter facilities, according to a statement from the Association for Civil Rights in Israel.
The urgency in providing such a response gains secondary validity in light of the fact that the main disparity in the field of defense in the northern district is within Arab towns, the statement continued.
https://www.cnn.com/2025/06/16/middleeast/israel-iran-tamra-shelters-latam-hnk-intl
I just love the talking point "Palestinians in Israel have the same rights as Jewish Israelis" - don't you??
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
7 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
51 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Haaretz - Leading Israeli Author David Grossman Calls Gaza War a 'Genocide [View all]
womanofthehills
Aug 2025
OP
I think he is representative of a political strain that has little to do with contemporary Israel.
David__77
Aug 2025
#1
Unequal access to shelters is yet another form of discrimination Palestinian Citizens of Israel face.
AloeVera
Aug 2025
#27
Please. Gaza is an entirely different story. Time to stop turning a blind eye to it.
brush
Aug 2025
#5
Thank you. I'm neutral except for Hamas and Netanyahu. I want them out of the picture never...
brush
Aug 2025
#7
Waaaaay too late buddy. Hindsight is going to be brutal for Israel. It will take generations to fade the stain of
Exp
Aug 2025
#8
Weird how the stain of the horrors done by Hamas didn't stick to Palestinians.
SunSeeker
Aug 2025
#10
Right. Starting a war by invading, killing and raping hundreds of teens at a music festival is no comparison.
SunSeeker
Aug 2025
#12
Palesitians were occupied. No real freedom of movement. Israeli settlers were steeling their land, bulldozing their
Exp
Aug 2025
#15
Butchering teens at a music festival is not "fighting back against the occupation."
SunSeeker
Aug 2025
#17
Sad for sure, but to Hamas supporters it was their way fighting back against the occupation, the murdering, the
Exp
Aug 2025
#20
"Sad"? Butchering babies is an atrocity. Canadians would never kill teens at a music concert.
SunSeeker
Aug 2025
#25
If I were to post pictures of actual dead babies - around 1,000 of them - would you think that was atrocity propaganda?
AloeVera
Aug 2025
#29
Your heart didn't break for the Jewish teens raped and killed on October 7? nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2025
#43
You think those videos of Hamas parading a dead girl through Gaza streets is "atrocity propaganda"?
SunSeeker
Aug 2025
#44
There's a reason that respected world leaders are defining Israel's actions as GENOCIDE. Is genocide an atrocity or
Exp
Aug 2025
#31
And Israel has their own 'River To The Sea' as well. But WHO IS ACTUALLY committing GENOCIDE?
Exp
Aug 2025
#46
So Hamas gets the benefit of not being able to carry out their dreams of no more Israel?
EdmondDantes_
Aug 2025
#49
If Canada launched an attack on a music festival and raped/killed kids, yes
EdmondDantes_
Aug 2025
#48
A people is being killed by Americans bombs, while the Israel is protected by the US diplomatically.
David__77
Aug 2025
#13
It's called war, David_77. Hamas could surrender and end the killing and starvation. nt
SunSeeker
Aug 2025
#16
Nazis waged war to oppress. Vietnamese waged war for independence. Not all war is worth defending.
David__77
Aug 2025
#18
I am thankful that most Democratic senators voted against weapons for Israel.
David__77
Aug 2025
#23
Hirohito called upon his country's forces to surrender after the bombing. Hamas should do the same.
SunSeeker
Aug 2025
#42