Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

unblock

(56,262 posts)
6. You can't just count the number of representatives by party, it's more complicated than that
Mon Aug 4, 2025, 02:33 PM
Aug 2025

First, to do a partisan gerrymander, you need the trifecta because the other party will block it if possible. Pennsylvania, for instance is out because republicans still hold the senate.

Second, gerrymandering works by packing the opposition into massively partisan districts while spreading your party around, giving you maybe 60-40 edge in most districts while conceding a loss in the packed districts that are 90% opposition. So even an extreme gerrymander in Pennsylvania would probably have to concede maybe 4 republicans districts.


That said, your overall point is entirely valid. Republicans have already been very aggressive in gerrymandering and don't have much left to squeeze out (even in Texas, which didn't get a fair map from the 2020 cycle) and democrats are catching up in terms of partisan zeal and anger and are more motivated to retaliate and have more opportunities for improvement if we can pull it off.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Not just that but the TX map could very well turn out to be a dummymander at the rate that they are relying on Latinos SSJVegeta Aug 2025 #1
"Wait for the translation:" DUU Aug 2025 #2
Also VA may very well have a trifecta state governemnt after November SSJVegeta Aug 2025 #3
Haven't I read that many states have an independent commission to do the re-allocation? erronis Aug 2025 #4
Yes, Colorado is one of them. h2ebits Aug 2025 #16
Even if the Democrats don't do it, it might backfire on the Republicans. everyonematters Aug 2025 #5
I'd rather we stop playing by not playing and start playing with the same rules of engagement. Mr.WeRP Aug 2025 #8
You can't just count the number of representatives by party, it's more complicated than that unblock Aug 2025 #6
Of course, I noted that with TX. Mr.WeRP Aug 2025 #7
Unblock is right... only count States with trifectas. WarGamer Aug 2025 #10
Read a comment on another thread InstantGratification Aug 2025 #17
Isn't the State Senate in PA run by the GOP? WarGamer Aug 2025 #9
Yes Wiz Imp Aug 2025 #11
It may be more complicated.... moose65 Aug 2025 #12
Forget about Pennsylvania. The GOP controls the State Senate Jose Garcia Aug 2025 #13
This message was self-deleted by its author PeaceWave Aug 2025 #14
I think a blue wave makes these gerrymanderes districts Johonny Aug 2025 #15
27 states had their most recent districts drawn by the state legislature (19 Republican, 7 Democratic, 1 split) Wiz Imp Aug 2025 #18
Texas Man DESTROYS Republicans for their Gerrymandering Plan Wiz Imp Aug 2025 #19
One thing that no one is mentioning markodochartaigh Aug 2025 #20
I don't think it would be possible to gerrymandering the only Democratic seat out of Kentucky standingtall Aug 2025 #21
PA, MN, and WI are not Blue Trifecta States so your maths are instantly off. Those 20 Rethug US House cannot be Celerity Aug 2025 #22
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Gerrymander THIS. Republi...»Reply #6