Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

lapucelle

(21,177 posts)
14. Whistleblower reveals corruption of IAGS standards and practices in a rush to pass its anti-Israel genocide resolution.
Sat Sep 6, 2025, 12:36 PM
Sep 2025
In the rush to vilify Israel, genocide scholars ignored the truth

This week, [21.6%] the International Association of Genocide Scholars passed a resolution stating Israel is committing genocide in Gaza

Under normal circumstances, [genocide scholar Dr. Sara] Brown said, any member can propose a resolution, which goes before a committee for comments and feedback. Controversial or high-stakes resolutions are brought before a virtual town hall to discuss the text. This time, when the resolution was proposed on an IAGS listserv, Brown said that she and others attempted to publish a dissent that was deleted by the moderators.

“One of the executive board members who moderates the listserv refused to publish it and said they are going to have a town hall,” Brown recalled. “Weeks passed as we waited for the town hall … I reached out to ask the president of the executive board when it would happen, and was told ‘we don’t have to hold one and we’re not going to.'”

In addition, Brown said, the resolution was posted anonymously, and the executive board refused to reveal its authorship, an unusual move that “raised red flags.

“It’s very telling about the biases and agenda of the leadership that they refused to host a town hall … There is no interest in having a transparent dialog and debate about such an important and damning [resolution] in terms of the reputation of the IAGS,” Brown said.

https://jewishinsider.com/2025/09/international-association-of-genocide-scholars-resolution-israel-sara-brown/

---------------------------------------------------------------------

"86% of the members who voted" was the tip off.

Out of 500 members, 126 voted. In other words, 25.2% of the members voted for the anonymous resolution distributed through a listserv. 109 of the those who voted wanted the resolution passed.

In other words, 21.8% (not 86%) of the IAGS members voted in favor of the resolution vilifying Israel. And due to its "you too can be a genocide scholar if you pay us $30" policy, 20% of the IAGS members are currently located in Iran. That information was available to journalists at the time that the story about the scam resolution broke.

However, IAGS has deleted its twitter account and closed down access to its membership list in an effort at damage control concerning the scam resolution that 74.8% of the IAGS members did not vote for.

---------------------------------------------------

The Guardian (and any other media outlet) that fell for this scam without doing even the most research should be ashamed.

Rage baiting clicks is a great way for the MSM to raise revenue, but a downright disgusting abrogation of journalistic duty.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Ya think??? Evolve Dammit Sep 2025 #1
In other news, scientists confirm gravity is a thing. thought crime Sep 2025 #13
Recommended. H2O Man Sep 2025 #2
Anyone can lay claim to being one of "the world's top scholars on genocide" lapucelle Sep 2025 #3
You don't have to be a bona fide genocide scholar choie Sep 2025 #5
Correct. H2O Man Sep 2025 #8
I wouldn't call Senator Sanders a "bona fide genocide denier". lapucelle Sep 2025 #11
Of course not. H2O Man Sep 2025 #12
Nor do you have to be a bona fide genocide scholar lapucelle Sep 2025 #9
"Adolf Hitler" is a member. Mosby Sep 2025 #10
Ok, it's officially genocide now Sewa Sep 2025 #4
Democrats (77 - 11 percent) and independents (51 - 34 percent) think Israel is committing genocide, Ping Tung Sep 2025 #6
And a majority of elected Dems are silent Sewa Sep 2025 #7
Whistleblower reveals corruption of IAGS standards and practices in a rush to pass its anti-Israel genocide resolution. lapucelle Sep 2025 #14
I would agree with some of what you post but the entity most responsible for any Uncle Joe Sep 2025 #15
Like I've had to say twice already, "Quick, look over here!" does not work on me. lapucelle Sep 2025 #17
I was addressing your post. You're the one that brought up "journalistic integrity" without mentioning that Netanyahu, Uncle Joe Sep 2025 #18
My post corrects misinformation concerning a scam resolution. lapucelle Sep 2025 #19
Your post # 14 also blames the media without addressing Netanyahu's role in this. Uncle Joe Sep 2025 #20
Now that the truth is known about the anonymous resolution passed by a mere 21.8% of IAGS members, lapucelle Sep 2025 #24
This message was self-deleted by its author lapucelle Sep 2025 #25
Leila Fadel talked this up on NPR, harming NPR in the process gulliver Sep 2025 #16
Why should it be ignored? iemanja Sep 2025 #21
The poster above (lapucelle) makes it clear gulliver Sep 2025 #22
I most certainly will not agree iemanja Sep 2025 #23
No. Here is the response from the IAGS to Brown's failed attempt to delegitimise the resolution: Celerity Sep 2025 #26
Kick for the truth malaise Sep 2025 #27
IAGS, resolutions, personalities, and politicians aside indusurb Sep 2025 #28
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Israel committing genocid...»Reply #14