Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CincyDem

(7,399 posts)
12. Elgin vs. Chicago is actually and important point.
Wed Sep 17, 2025, 08:31 AM
Sep 2025

From the perspective of growing up in Chicago (really really in the city - as in voting for Daley...lol)...

Elgin is way out there with lower than the national average crime rates. It's probably on the edge of "Chicago/not-Chicago" argument but I'm sure there are people who live in Elgin that commute into the city for work.

To me, this is a great choice for Noem's BS staged participation where the WH can use the footage to bolster their "Chicago is a mess" mantra. Chances of them busting down a door in Elgin and finding 4 guys strapped to the nines sitting in the living room playing GTA VI are nil and zero. No chance of an errant shot clipping her.

But...head into Austin, Englewood, or a dozen other neighborhoods that are actually in the city and those odds go up. Not way up, but there are areas where the response to a no-knock warrant are more dangerous than it is in Elgin.

Geographically...yeah, it's Chicago to most of the country but culturally, safety-wise, "feel"...it's no more Chicago (as most American's know it) than Ohama, Kansas City, or Fargo.

Let's say it a different way: If you won a free weekend for two in Chicago and they took you to Elgin, you'd sue the promoters for false advertising...and probably win.


Recommendations

7 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

That's not Chicago Prairie Gates Sep 2025 #1
I've Said It ProfessorGAC Sep 2025 #2
That's fine Prairie Gates Sep 2025 #3
Elgin vs. Chicago is actually and important point. CincyDem Sep 2025 #12
Yes, there's substance to it as well -- nicely said Prairie Gates Sep 2025 #13
Safety is paramount with those types haele Sep 2025 #24
I was born in "a Western suburb of Chicago." If any one cares enough to ask, "which one?", I'll be specific. Harker Sep 2025 #15
I've Used "Chicagoland" On A Few Occasions ProfessorGAC Sep 2025 #18
I usually say I'm originally from the tri-state area xmas74 Sep 2025 #37
Joliet Mark Baker Sep 2025 #22
The Blues Brothers 💙 Sequoia Sep 2025 #28
In China? ProfessorGAC Sep 2025 #34
In this context, does that really matter? Scrivener7 Sep 2025 #5
I mean, they're screaming about all the crime in the cities Prairie Gates Sep 2025 #14
It makes MAGA sense. As long as SOMEBODY gets arrested. Who is a detail, as is guilt/innocence. eppur_se_muova Sep 2025 #38
This makes Rebl2 Sep 2025 #25
My brother lived out that way. LeftInTX Sep 2025 #32
It's a quiet neighborhood. My Grandparents used to live there. progressoid Sep 2025 #33
I hope he sues the shit out of her. nt GoCubsGo Sep 2025 #4
Yep. Have wondered whether the gubmint ends up replacing all the damage ICE allegorical oracle Sep 2025 #35
So in 11 days with an army of ICE goons they've only found 250 people?! Arazi Sep 2025 #6
Didn't ICE kill one?................ Lovie777 Sep 2025 #9
Yup... a devastating event for us, something to celebrate for ICE 🤬 Arazi Sep 2025 #30
Didn't Noem blow through her annual budget by June or July? CrispyQ Sep 2025 #26
She just got a few billion in the Big Ugly Bill Arazi Sep 2025 #29
Why isn't this front and center on every news cast?????????????????????? Vinca Sep 2025 #7
The news is too busy showing the burning EV being circled by a guy on a mini-bike with a flag . rubbersole Sep 2025 #16
G.O.P. violently enters an innocent man's castle (home) BoRaGard Sep 2025 #8
He's somewhat lucky tho............. Lovie777 Sep 2025 #10
Acting like Nazi stormtroopers. Emile Sep 2025 #11
"I told them I was a U.S. citizen, that my ID was in my wallet." dalton99a Sep 2025 #17
But are Puppy Killer's hair and lips OK?!? travelingthrulife Sep 2025 #19
ICE, along with the FBI, are now Trump properties/reality tv programs, hosted by KKKristi Noempathy and Kooky Kash. RedWhiteBlueIsRacist Sep 2025 #20
Were there any K9 units involved? Any collateral damage through friendly fire? Ping Tung Sep 2025 #21
Blowing the doors off of someone's house for a DUI? Beaverhausen Sep 2025 #23
In rifling through what's left of my possessions, I came across a way-overdue library book. Buns_of_Fire Sep 2025 #31
They think this is like Call Of Duty. What the actual fuck. Initech Sep 2025 #27
America's Gestapo at work. republianmushroom Sep 2025 #36
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Kristi Noem joined ICE in...»Reply #12