General Discussion

BootinUp

(50,950 posts)

47. I understand and agree with your opposition to the recent action but,

Sat Jan 3, 2026, 10:04 PM

Saturday

I am not sure that I would agree that a person in the military should have deduced they were being given an illegal order. With the information I have heard so far, it seems like the plan was well designed and carried out to minimize collateral damage. Now, if we don't want limited actions, like this one, to be taken by our government, then we have to get the right people in office, we have to convince our fellow Americans to vote better. But I wouldn't expect efforts to change the military in the way you suggest to be fruitful. And this latest action is quite different than the boat strikes where there were clearer lines crossed with regards to indiscriminate killing.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

ShazzieB

72 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

I am assuming that those who still cherished a hope that our military [View all] niyad Saturday OP

I think there's a huge difference between this and them shooting protesters Polybius Saturday #1

Assignment for today: Read about Kent State. TBF Saturday #3

Exactly. Alliepoo Saturday #6

National Guard, though TimeToGo Saturday #7

Should Not Have Had Loaded Rifles On Campus. At PSU, 1969, I.... ColoringFool Saturday #15

You know EXACTLY what they will do. nt TBF Saturday #38

Or NON-Protesting Students Walking In The Vicinity (Kent State). ColoringFool Saturday #13

I wish I could share your hope. niyad Saturday #4

Just the memory of that MuseRider Saturday #14

Polybius I think you are wrong. Irish_Dem Saturday #28

It's the Traildogbob Saturday #31

Ive lost hope in them now uponit7771 Saturday #34

They've ALREADY done it--- just not with actual bullets.... yet... Jack Valentino Saturday #48

They're already shooting protesters in Chicago, they shot a woman 5 times and lied about it. Blues Heron Saturday #55

That was Border Patrol Polybius Sunday #67

Same shit -us agents with guns, camo, and ammo. Just a different branch, but the bullets are the same - us bullets Blues Heron Sunday #70

No, I'm not splitting hairs Polybius Monday #72

4 dead in Ohio jaymac Sunday #59

I meant the actual US military, not ICE, Border Patrol, or the National Guard Polybius Sunday #68

I don't see this as a huge difference. This is about AllyCat Sunday #60

Most in the military are young and may not have known much about Venezuela Polybius Sunday #69

Indeed. I think this falls under "unlawful orders". Reminds me of Bush the Lesser invading LoisB Saturday #2

So far it reminds me more of markodochartaigh Saturday #17

How can it not be the same as Iraq!? The boots on the ground are to protect the oil we're gong to steal. You can't Solomon Saturday #22

I think that it is possible that Venezuelans will be used to protect the oil production. markodochartaigh Saturday #24

First for me yankee87 Saturday #23

I agree with you in a way and yes, let us hope it does not get to the "Iraq" level so far as LoisB Saturday #27

Yes, brought back all same memories for me too MerryBlooms Sunday #62

Nope. Alliepoo Saturday #5

That could change quickly when they receive angry phone calls and nasty-grams from their constituents FakeNoose Saturday #12

The Reich-wing cancer has metastacised into all parts of our country Jerry2144 Saturday #8

I wish I had an answer as to how we cleanse. niyad Saturday #9

Too many people are getting richer, more powerful from the GOP blight. Irish_Dem Saturday #29

Our neighborhood Duppers Saturday #36

Given how I witnessed the military being overrun by self-righteous GOPers, I knew this wasn't going to happen. Crowman2009 Saturday #10

Especially after they got rid of all who might have stood up to them. niyad Saturday #11

Based on the quick success with Venezuela, does anyone think an attempt to take over Greenland is next? Lonestarblue Saturday #16

Have to wait until we pull out of NATO officially... malthaussen Saturday #20

With no real main stream media anymore popsdenver Saturday #25

Yeah so much for that orangecrush Saturday #18

Southern Command certainly won't. malthaussen Saturday #19

Yeah we've always been good róisín_dubh Saturday #57

It will be interesting to see what we've gotten ourselves into. malthaussen Saturday #21

People who spouted that crap or reposted hopium/copium grifters doing so RockRaven Saturday #26

Whoever believed that? choie Saturday #30

We saw any number of posters here saying that, oh-so-hopefully, since 20 Jan. niyad Saturday #37

Well now we can all wallow in the told ya so's MorbidButterflyTat Saturday #49

Your disdain is noted. However, you are not the only one with military niyad Saturday #56

A soldier but takes orders Dawson Leery Saturday #32

Hey popsdenver Saturday #39

WTF Skittles Saturday #40

Agree. MorbidButterflyTat Saturday #50

I don't think many people understand restrictions military folk live by Skittles Saturday #53

Some know them all too well. niyad Sunday #64

Here we are again. Regime change! BidenRocks Saturday #33

I did have some hope there Bettie Saturday #35

I'm not convinced that the order to strike Venezuela TomSlick Saturday #41

Again, unlawful orders abound. And our military leaders..nowhere to be found. Scalded Nun Saturday #42

Moral courage in the abstract collides with the reality of career, home mortgages, kids in college... surfered Saturday #43

Well, we had Panama & Grenada that were similar operations so I still have hope. Callie1979 Saturday #44

Why? niyad Saturday #45

Because there's not much difference between the 3 operations. Callie1979 Sunday #58

Don't trust the military Indyfan53 Saturday #46

I understand and agree with your opposition to the recent action but, BootinUp Saturday #47

Yep. Some people only learn the hard way. calimary Saturday #51

What makes this any more illeagal than Veitnam doc03 Saturday #52

Those situations were much more complex. ShazzieB Sunday #61

It has been obvious with the military buildup that we were going to war doc03 Sunday #63

A lot of people have certainly been expecting something to happen, or fearing that it might. ShazzieB Monday #71

How was Vietnam "illegal"? EX500rider Sunday #66

I had ZERO expectation that today's military would ho or their Oaths.... Bread and Circuses Saturday #54

ICE will shoot people. They already have. Kennah Sunday #65