General Discussion

paleotn

(22,722 posts)

136. I'm not making the extraordinary claims

Mon May 18, 2026, 10:30 AM

5 hrs ago

You are. I’m merely stating there is no conclusive proof from any reputable source that confirms the claims. Since you’re making the claims, the burden of proof is on you. Not on the one stating there are is no conclusive evidence. And the source you claim is neither reputable or conclusive. See how that works? Did you learn those basic concepts in college? Perhaps not.

Telling that you found it necessary to make a personal attack. Very telling.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

142 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Is anyone familiar with Edgar Cayce, the "Sleeping Prophet"? [View all] kentuck Yesterday OP

Edgar Cayce. Yes I'm familiar with him raccoon Yesterday #1

Ironically, I was thinking about him a few months back and was going to research a bit more... hlthe2b Yesterday #2

He was quite a fascinating fellow bucolic_frolic Yesterday #3

The Association for Research and Enlightenment The Blue Flower Yesterday #9

Not sure how it could be secure from climate change? hlthe2b Yesterday #10

I cant's answer that The Blue Flower Yesterday #11

Message auto-removed Name removed 23 hrs ago #82

Hey, welcome to DU! The Blue Flower 22 hrs ago #93

............ paleotn Yesterday #32

Lucid dreaming is realizing you are dreaming, while you are dreaming jimmy the one 22 hrs ago #91

Yes, I am familiar with him. it's been years since I have tried to read anything by him. mwmisses4289 Yesterday #4

He supposedly knew where Atlantis was -- somewhere in the Bermuda Triangle? -- which displacedvermoter Yesterday #5

Cayce died in 1945, during WWII, so unless it was an old movie reel, I don't see how he was on Nimoy's show (1976-1982). Celerity Yesterday #13

A couple of episodes of "In Search Of" went into Cayce's theories. Beartracks Yesterday #25

Ok. Makes sense. Celerity Yesterday #31

He wasn't on the show himself, unless, perhaps in another astral dimension.. displacedvermoter Yesterday #45

Yes, another poster above already explained it. Celerity Yesterday #60

Probably??? paleotn Yesterday #23

The clock isn't broken. mr715 Yesterday #69

......... paleotn 21 hrs ago #99

displacedvermoter...... Upthevibe Yesterday #73

Yes, I read quite a few books about Edgar Cayce PatSeg Yesterday #6

When facing problems or tasks I need help with... MiHale Yesterday #7

I understand that technique has been quite successful. Joinfortmill Yesterday #33

There's a lot of recent research into "lucid dreaming" which mirrors some of what you talk about. erronis Yesterday #47

I also lucid dream...not always... MiHale Yesterday #75

Quite an effective method! SheltieLover Yesterday #51

I've used some of his remedies. Here is one. Maraya1969 Yesterday #8

Yes! I was in a study group in the 80's discussing his writings hauckeye Yesterday #12

I think his writings about this time... kentuck Yesterday #14

I'm reading one of his books now and find it very interesting. MLAA Yesterday #15

When I was a sophomore in college... ananda Yesterday #16

;-{)..... Goonch Yesterday #17

Crazy shit. paleotn Yesterday #34

Barnum and Bailey meets Carter's Pills nt Maru Kitteh 23 hrs ago #81

I have many books about him karin_sj Yesterday #18

I e heard of both of them and read about both of them. AllaN01Bear Yesterday #19

George Carlin said Cayce was not a medium, Sneederbunk Yesterday #20

Ah, don't we all miss George Carlin? hlthe2b Yesterday #28

George Carlin was always right. Srkdqltr 18 hrs ago #127

He predicted that San Francisco would be destroyed SCantiGOP Yesterday #21

After it was destroyed in 1906. By an earthquake. paleotn Yesterday #35

This is insane Wifes husband Yesterday #22

I would venture that some on DU have never heard of him... hlthe2b Yesterday #26

So there's value delving into the works of a con and nut? paleotn Yesterday #30

One has to read and understand a figure in history before determining that he is a "con" hlthe2b Yesterday #44

I'm not precluding a goddamn thing. I'm merely pointing and laughing. paleotn 21 hrs ago #106

Your cursing at me doesn't help your argument, paleotn. Not one bit... hlthe2b 21 hrs ago #107

What? That's silly. paleotn 20 hrs ago #111

Since I have argued the exact opposite, you show that you are just posting to see your own words hlthe2b 20 hrs ago #113

Oh please. To some degree? i.e., you want it both ways. paleotn 20 hrs ago #115

Desperation and ridicule for sure hithe2b Clouds Passing 20 hrs ago #112

Got any evidence? Didn't think so. paleotn 4 hrs ago #138

Message auto-removed Name removed 16 hrs ago #130

Hmmm. Wonder about Jesus, Moses, etc., etc. erronis Yesterday #49

I'm sure many shared this thought stopdiggin Yesterday #68

Cayce was a HEALER not a murderer. That could be the difference between the two Clouds Passing Yesterday #71

Bwahahahaha! paleotn 21 hrs ago #105

Verify evidence that he didn't heal anyone. People have a right to question and explore. live love laugh 12 hrs ago #134

Prove a negative?? Really? That's your response?? paleotn 5 hrs ago #137

Ooooo! Cussing! paleotn 4 hrs ago #139

I was really into him in my younger years bif Yesterday #24

Oh, please. He was equal parts con and nutter. paleotn Yesterday #27

We heard you the first time. Joinfortmill Yesterday #37

Plus several more MorbidButterflyTat Yesterday #61

I get the inclincation to boil everything down to "woo" hlthe2b Yesterday #40

Thank you. Well said. I tend to be very skeptical having been taught that the scientific methods are best. erronis Yesterday #53

No one would call vaccines woo TxGuitar 22 hrs ago #92

Oh, REALLY?!!! Where have YOU been the past decades-- and especially the past five years hlthe2b 21 hrs ago #95

Did you just invoke Hitchens's razor!? mr715 21 hrs ago #101

This message was self-deleted by its author paleotn 21 hrs ago #102

" There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of niyad Yesterday #65

Very true. SheltieLover 23 hrs ago #79

Yup. Fascinating person and his work was all documented. Joinfortmill Yesterday #29

Documented as complete BS. paleotn Yesterday #36

Back off. Joinfortmill Yesterday #38

Or what? Wifes husband Yesterday #46

My response was not directed at you. Joinfortmill Yesterday #54

I will not. paleotn 21 hrs ago #104

Why? Truth hurts?? paleotn 21 hrs ago #103

would you please provide NJCher Yesterday #57

Where is Atlantis? mr715 Yesterday #67

post was directed to paleotn NJCher Yesterday #72

Don't blame me, I was just astral projecting. mr715 Yesterday #74

... reACTIONary 22 hrs ago #83

Ahem, my post was directed to NJCher mr715 22 hrs ago #85

Unfortunately.... reACTIONary 18 hrs ago #125

I kant handle philosopher puns. mr715 18 hrs ago #126

Give me some documentation that his conman ramblings are actually true. paleotn 21 hrs ago #100

Did you go to college? NJCher 14 hrs ago #132

What does "Did you go to college?" have to do with anything. Abolishinist 13 hrs ago #133

You don't know how to argue either NJCher 6 hrs ago #135

You're arguing without a shred of evidence. paleotn 4 hrs ago #141

I'm not making the extraordinary claims paleotn 5 hrs ago #136

And all bull shit Wifes husband Yesterday #43

Nostradamus only "predicted" things in reverse. Gore1FL Yesterday #39

That right. Nostradmus predictions are retrofitted Buckeyeblue 22 hrs ago #94

I visited his research center in Virginia Beach beveeheart Yesterday #41

I think there is a relevance that is helpful to these times we are living in.... kentuck Yesterday #42

Interesing subject kentuck. I do beleive that as we sleep, our unconscious does 'communiicate' c-rational Yesterday #48

I wouldn't know. kentuck Yesterday #52

"Little Death" JoseBalow Yesterday #50

Being a cat person I know that Edgar Cayce had a lot of interesting things to say about cats. flashman13 Yesterday #55

Cats have a sixth sense, I am sure. kentuck Yesterday #59

Cats most certainly have a sixth sense. Several years ago an elderly stray orange cat wandered in and came flashman13 23 hrs ago #80

Yes, he was a fraud. mr715 Yesterday #56

Message auto-removed Name removed 22 hrs ago #86

Science is falsifiable mr715 22 hrs ago #87

Message auto-removed Name removed 22 hrs ago #89

Pluto being a planet or not is a matter of definitions. mr715 22 hrs ago #90

"you're" ( contraction for "you are"), not "your" (possessive). niyad 21 hrs ago #96

Ooof, that is always embarrassing mr715 21 hrs ago #97

When I was in my twenties I read Cayce. 1WorldHope Yesterday #58

Well said PatSeg 19 hrs ago #120

Too me he was Faux pas Yesterday #62

just the name Kali Yesterday #63

Thanks for this thread! MorbidButterflyTat Yesterday #64

I'm more familiar with Carl Jung's similar work Brother Buzz Yesterday #66

Although Jung was pretty woo too. mr715 Yesterday #70

kentuck........ Upthevibe Yesterday #76

Yes, I've read some of his work and I agree. ms liberty Yesterday #77

Did read some of his stuff when I was a teenager because it was allegorical oracle 23 hrs ago #78

He still has a following in Virginia Beach. GreenWave 22 hrs ago #84

me ma read his books duckworth969 22 hrs ago #88

Fraud, huxster and con man edhopper 21 hrs ago #98

Message auto-removed Name removed 15 hrs ago #131

The sleeping profiteer? usonian 20 hrs ago #108

I believe there is much we do not know. kentuck 20 hrs ago #109

Quantum and consciousness get lumped together because of woo. mr715 20 hrs ago #110

That is what is being questioned. kentuck 20 hrs ago #114

It is a challenging question... mr715 20 hrs ago #116

In some unexplainable way... kentuck 20 hrs ago #117

These are not supernatural, though. mr715 19 hrs ago #118

That is how I tend to see it PatSeg 19 hrs ago #119

Poe "Up Through The Spiral" 1971 Concept Albums,Psych Omaha Steve 19 hrs ago #121

I have a copy of that album. PurgedVoter 4 hrs ago #140

My great Aunt in Portsmouth, Va once saw him speak SomedayKindaLove 19 hrs ago #122

He cured my great aunt's TB jcboon 19 hrs ago #123

I heard an interview with one his followers on the Art Bell Radio Show years ago. Jacson6 19 hrs ago #124

I find him fascinating MustLoveBeagles 17 hrs ago #128

Familiar with him but not aware of any 2026 RubyRose 17 hrs ago #129

Well this fellow wrote a book after studying the Great Pyramid in Egypt FakeNoose 1 hr ago #142