General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Has Anyone Else On DU Noticed This Lately? [View all]DirkGently
(12,151 posts)Bad news IS the news. "Everything went well today" is not a news story nor much of a source of discussion. That's a journalistic maxim, and it pretty much applies to public discussion in general.
Likewise, "I sure agree with everything our party / President / possible future candidates are doing" is not much of a conversation starter.
Not to mention impossible. Take the recent failed vote to limit the power of the NSA. Supported by more Democrats than Republicans, but opposed by some Democrats, many Republicans, and the White House. Which side of that discussion is being divisive?
I don't think Dems arguing with Dems about what Dems and progressives in general ought to be doing or not doing or electing or not electing has the overall affect of causing "despair" and helping Republicans.
I have heard that line of reasoning, but it always seems to come from a compact group with the monolithic view of politics: "Vote for our team, then shut up or voice unqualified support, please."
Those people are wrong, frankly, and we'd be a weaker group if that view prevailed. Progressives and Dems are not the blindly "angry" rightwingers you mentioned, and the fact we're not easily unified is part of what ... unifies us, in the end. If we're doing it right, we figure things out from the bottom up to the leadership, not the other way 'round. That's for Republicans.
Lefties think critically and are inherently disrespectful of authority. We don't fall in line and simply enthuse about how correct we all are about everything. We disagree. We complain. We agitate. We are suspicious of calls for loyalty. Sometimes it gets messy. Sometimes it gets (metaphorically) bloody.
That's a good thing. And we can handle it.