Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Why I choose to be a counterproductive left wingnut. [View all]Fumesucker
(45,851 posts)229. ...
1. You blame Democrats for what Republicans do
Whenever the GOP does something, that becomes the Democrat's fault.
No, I blame the Democrats for being, weak, vacillating and pusillanimous.
2. You imagine that President Obama is a dictator and he's deliberately making sure that Congress doesn't help people
You argue that all Obama needs to do is "fight harder" and "show some backbone" against the thinly-disguised GOP racists, and then they'd all just fall in line.
It's pretty obvious from reading history that there's a great deal of kabuki done in Washington, everyone knows where the negotiations are going to end up but the forms must be rigidly adhered to. Is this true all the time? Of course not but it's true more often than the BOG is remotely willing to admit.
3. You're not a regular campaign volunteer. In fact, you think writing screeds on DU is activism
You don't even know what cutting-turf is. You've never actually tried to convince an uncommitted voter, rather than attack people outside your little echo chamber.
I read posts nearly every day on DU of talks, arguments debates that DUers have with people in meatspace, why say this when you have no idea what people do?
4. Most of your DU screeds are not anti-Republican, they're anti-Democratic
You constantly crow that you're just "holding feet to the fire" except the vast majority of your screeds only bash Democrats. And often take on Republican coloring, like a reflexive belief in government and Democratic administration being evil.
So people agitating for single payer think government is evil? Government is a tool humans use, probably the most powerful one we have yet invented. It's been my experience that the more powerful the tool the more judiciously and cautiously it should be employed, it's one thing to hit your thumb with a framing hammer and entirely another to drive a nail into your kneecap with a nail gun. Some things governments habitually seem to want to do like surveillance need to be controlled very carefully because history shows us those sorts of things can get out of hand with horrible consequences.
5. You refuse to credit the President for anything you actually like, instead focusing purely on your hatred of him
If the President gets a very good deal, 99% of what you want, you'll rant about the 1% he had to give up. "Compromise" to you means everyone agreeing with what you want 100%.
Who here "hates" Obama? Sure there's a few that go over the top but even the more vocal critics seem to personally like Obama, he's quite the likeable person.
6. No one can remember the last time you actually praised anyone or anything, except someone else's hate-filled anti-Democratic screed
You seem to never have anything positive to say, leading most to believe that you're a very angry, bitter, person, with little emotional maturity. And other hate-filled screeds are all you manage to praise.
Bitter, hate filled screeds like this one?
7. You refuse to acknowledge that people on the other side of a debate have any legitimate concerns at all - like trying to keep a dictatorial regime from gassing its own people
Your fellow Democrats must be obsessed with bloodlust and love war, or at least that's what you believe.
A lot of us think with reasonable justification that any interference at this juncture in MENA by the USA is going to automatically be counterproductive, unlike Americans the inhabitants of that region have very long memories and few reasons to love America.
8. You never provide a argument about what should be done instead that would address the other side's concerns
An actual argument that would potentially be agreeable to both sides might actually change minds, but that would deprive you of your ability to feel sanctimonious. In fact, "Third Way" is an anathema to you.
That goes on here in GD constantly. For many of us "Third Way" means halfway between Republican and Democrat and we already feel the Democrats are too far to the right, of course it's anathema. You're taking what amounts to a technical term used to describe a set of policies and applying it where that definition doesn't fit. You know this.
9. You counter any moral argument with a diatribe about some past bad action taken by the U.S. - nearly always done during Republican leadership 10 to 50 years ago
All reprehensible actions taken by anyone outside the U.S. can be justified in a kindergarten "we did it once too" by bringing up some ancient cold-war wrong, nearly always done during a Republican administration.
What you mean is we remember from our personal experiences the US doing exactly or very nearly what it now condemns, it's really hard to avoid feeling your government is hypocritical when you remember them doing it too.
10. Instead of congratulating Democratic leaders on making what you feel to be the right choice, you imagine you have "defeated" the people who were actually mature enough to change their minds
You live in a black and white world of a zero-sum game, where someone else's winning means your losing and vice-versa. Therefore anything you like that happened is due to a "defeat" of the Democratic President.
The single group most obsessed with "winning" for the sake of winning on DU by far is the BOG.
11. You see no difference between Democrats and Republicans
Boy, there is not a single whit of difference, because you haven't gotten your maximalist position on everything.
Wrong, Democrats and Republicans differ a lot on social policy, markedly less so on economic and military policy.
12. Your arguments reference no facts, but are instead filled with unsubstantiated assertions. Your counter-arguments are ROTL icons
Did you know that President Obama is secretly twisting arms to destroy Social Security? Well, just because it isn't true doesn't keep you from stating it as fact. Any vague rumor is automatically true if it shows Democrats in a bad light. Your counterarguments typically run like this: "You're Quoting the New York Times?!? " You aren't actually laughing.
The ROFL smiley is practically Sid Dithers damn trademark.
13. You dismiss facts that don't fit your worldview, and personally attack people who provide them
ProSense drives you crazy, what with all her facts and figures and research that disprove your assertions. You attack people specifically when their references refuting your made-up B.S. are long and well documented.
14. You Godwin political discussions, liberally attacking other Democrats with words like "Authoritarian", "Police State", "Hitler", "Fascist", "Corporatist"
the new dog-whistle for fascist)
You call people who explain mainstream Democratic thought Obama "apologists", ignoring that there is absolutely nothing to "apologize" for. Paradoxically, taking actions to actually stop a dictator from gassing little children to death is something you are against. You never acknowledge that Hitler wasn't stopped with a sternly-worded letter either.
You talk about others Godwining discussions and then play the Godwin card yourself during the same point. Own goal, big time.
15 You imagine that the DU is representative of mainstream Democratic thought, instead of being a place for the very liberal left to gather
And further, you actually argue that your positions are correct simply because the majority of the D.U. hold it. Here is a small point of fact: President Obama's approval rating among Democrats is 85%.
You defeat one argumentum ad populum with another arugmentum ad populum. Own goal again.
16. You have "left" the Democratic party and/or are sole-arbiter on who is actually a "Democrat" and who isn't
Anyone who actually likes President Obama clearly can't be a real Democrat in your mind. You have also written a "Goodbye cold cruel DU - because people don't support me right or wrong - I will never vote Democratic again". For bonus points, you've done both.
No I haven't.
17. You continue to make excuses for Nader
And others who strengthen the GOP by dividing the Democratic coalition.
And centrists make excuses for conservadems who vote for cutting food stamps.
18. You imagine that anyone would pay to try to convince people like you that mainstream Democratic thinking is correct
Any time you lose an argument, or someone shows your assertion is complete bullshit by referencing established facts (see ProSense), they are clearly being paid to do so. Never mind that actual Koch propaganda is as nutcase and unconvincing as you are, it's all a grand conspiracy, I tell ya! A conspiracy!
Most of the long time posters long since quit clicking on ProSense's links because so often they are bogus and link to her own posts that have nothing to do with the subject matter. Call wolf enough times and people stop responding.
19. You recognize many of these behaviors in the Tea Party, and recognize how much they're damaging the Republicans, but don't acknowledge the same in your own behavior
Your few moments of clarity come when you look at the GOP and see how their extremists are destroying their brand. But the similarities between the Tea Party and you (including a reflexive hatred of the U.S. government and conspiracy mongering) is something that you refuse to acknowledge.
Has Dubya found those WMDs under the Oval Office rug yet? Practically every poster on here remembers a conspiracy to go to war in arguably the worst foreign policy disaster in US history, such an experience changes a person's perception of government or should if they have a functioning neuron or two left.
20. You are incredibly offended by this list
Are you pissed off by this list? Maybe there is a reason for that.
Not pissed off, wearied. At one time DU was a refuge from overwhelming right wing thought, this was particularly true for those of us living in heavily Republican areas, I don't personally know any other liberals and not that many who aren't wingnuts.
Bear in mind that it takes a great deal of personal integrity to maintain a political stance when you are surrounded and overwhelmed by people who think you are evil and should just drop dead due to your politics.
Now no longer is DU a refuge for those of us who are further left, the right hates us and the centrists loathe us, they certainly have that in common.
Whenever the GOP does something, that becomes the Democrat's fault.
No, I blame the Democrats for being, weak, vacillating and pusillanimous.
2. You imagine that President Obama is a dictator and he's deliberately making sure that Congress doesn't help people
You argue that all Obama needs to do is "fight harder" and "show some backbone" against the thinly-disguised GOP racists, and then they'd all just fall in line.
It's pretty obvious from reading history that there's a great deal of kabuki done in Washington, everyone knows where the negotiations are going to end up but the forms must be rigidly adhered to. Is this true all the time? Of course not but it's true more often than the BOG is remotely willing to admit.
3. You're not a regular campaign volunteer. In fact, you think writing screeds on DU is activism
You don't even know what cutting-turf is. You've never actually tried to convince an uncommitted voter, rather than attack people outside your little echo chamber.
I read posts nearly every day on DU of talks, arguments debates that DUers have with people in meatspace, why say this when you have no idea what people do?
4. Most of your DU screeds are not anti-Republican, they're anti-Democratic
You constantly crow that you're just "holding feet to the fire" except the vast majority of your screeds only bash Democrats. And often take on Republican coloring, like a reflexive belief in government and Democratic administration being evil.
So people agitating for single payer think government is evil? Government is a tool humans use, probably the most powerful one we have yet invented. It's been my experience that the more powerful the tool the more judiciously and cautiously it should be employed, it's one thing to hit your thumb with a framing hammer and entirely another to drive a nail into your kneecap with a nail gun. Some things governments habitually seem to want to do like surveillance need to be controlled very carefully because history shows us those sorts of things can get out of hand with horrible consequences.
5. You refuse to credit the President for anything you actually like, instead focusing purely on your hatred of him
If the President gets a very good deal, 99% of what you want, you'll rant about the 1% he had to give up. "Compromise" to you means everyone agreeing with what you want 100%.
Who here "hates" Obama? Sure there's a few that go over the top but even the more vocal critics seem to personally like Obama, he's quite the likeable person.
6. No one can remember the last time you actually praised anyone or anything, except someone else's hate-filled anti-Democratic screed
You seem to never have anything positive to say, leading most to believe that you're a very angry, bitter, person, with little emotional maturity. And other hate-filled screeds are all you manage to praise.
Bitter, hate filled screeds like this one?
7. You refuse to acknowledge that people on the other side of a debate have any legitimate concerns at all - like trying to keep a dictatorial regime from gassing its own people
Your fellow Democrats must be obsessed with bloodlust and love war, or at least that's what you believe.
A lot of us think with reasonable justification that any interference at this juncture in MENA by the USA is going to automatically be counterproductive, unlike Americans the inhabitants of that region have very long memories and few reasons to love America.
8. You never provide a argument about what should be done instead that would address the other side's concerns
An actual argument that would potentially be agreeable to both sides might actually change minds, but that would deprive you of your ability to feel sanctimonious. In fact, "Third Way" is an anathema to you.
That goes on here in GD constantly. For many of us "Third Way" means halfway between Republican and Democrat and we already feel the Democrats are too far to the right, of course it's anathema. You're taking what amounts to a technical term used to describe a set of policies and applying it where that definition doesn't fit. You know this.
9. You counter any moral argument with a diatribe about some past bad action taken by the U.S. - nearly always done during Republican leadership 10 to 50 years ago
All reprehensible actions taken by anyone outside the U.S. can be justified in a kindergarten "we did it once too" by bringing up some ancient cold-war wrong, nearly always done during a Republican administration.
What you mean is we remember from our personal experiences the US doing exactly or very nearly what it now condemns, it's really hard to avoid feeling your government is hypocritical when you remember them doing it too.
10. Instead of congratulating Democratic leaders on making what you feel to be the right choice, you imagine you have "defeated" the people who were actually mature enough to change their minds
You live in a black and white world of a zero-sum game, where someone else's winning means your losing and vice-versa. Therefore anything you like that happened is due to a "defeat" of the Democratic President.
The single group most obsessed with "winning" for the sake of winning on DU by far is the BOG.
11. You see no difference between Democrats and Republicans
Boy, there is not a single whit of difference, because you haven't gotten your maximalist position on everything.
Wrong, Democrats and Republicans differ a lot on social policy, markedly less so on economic and military policy.
12. Your arguments reference no facts, but are instead filled with unsubstantiated assertions. Your counter-arguments are ROTL icons
Did you know that President Obama is secretly twisting arms to destroy Social Security? Well, just because it isn't true doesn't keep you from stating it as fact. Any vague rumor is automatically true if it shows Democrats in a bad light. Your counterarguments typically run like this: "You're Quoting the New York Times?!? " You aren't actually laughing.
The ROFL smiley is practically Sid Dithers damn trademark.
13. You dismiss facts that don't fit your worldview, and personally attack people who provide them
ProSense drives you crazy, what with all her facts and figures and research that disprove your assertions. You attack people specifically when their references refuting your made-up B.S. are long and well documented.
14. You Godwin political discussions, liberally attacking other Democrats with words like "Authoritarian", "Police State", "Hitler", "Fascist", "Corporatist"
You call people who explain mainstream Democratic thought Obama "apologists", ignoring that there is absolutely nothing to "apologize" for. Paradoxically, taking actions to actually stop a dictator from gassing little children to death is something you are against. You never acknowledge that Hitler wasn't stopped with a sternly-worded letter either.
You talk about others Godwining discussions and then play the Godwin card yourself during the same point. Own goal, big time.
15 You imagine that the DU is representative of mainstream Democratic thought, instead of being a place for the very liberal left to gather
And further, you actually argue that your positions are correct simply because the majority of the D.U. hold it. Here is a small point of fact: President Obama's approval rating among Democrats is 85%.
You defeat one argumentum ad populum with another arugmentum ad populum. Own goal again.
16. You have "left" the Democratic party and/or are sole-arbiter on who is actually a "Democrat" and who isn't
Anyone who actually likes President Obama clearly can't be a real Democrat in your mind. You have also written a "Goodbye cold cruel DU - because people don't support me right or wrong - I will never vote Democratic again". For bonus points, you've done both.
No I haven't.
17. You continue to make excuses for Nader
And others who strengthen the GOP by dividing the Democratic coalition.
And centrists make excuses for conservadems who vote for cutting food stamps.
18. You imagine that anyone would pay to try to convince people like you that mainstream Democratic thinking is correct
Any time you lose an argument, or someone shows your assertion is complete bullshit by referencing established facts (see ProSense), they are clearly being paid to do so. Never mind that actual Koch propaganda is as nutcase and unconvincing as you are, it's all a grand conspiracy, I tell ya! A conspiracy!
Most of the long time posters long since quit clicking on ProSense's links because so often they are bogus and link to her own posts that have nothing to do with the subject matter. Call wolf enough times and people stop responding.
19. You recognize many of these behaviors in the Tea Party, and recognize how much they're damaging the Republicans, but don't acknowledge the same in your own behavior
Your few moments of clarity come when you look at the GOP and see how their extremists are destroying their brand. But the similarities between the Tea Party and you (including a reflexive hatred of the U.S. government and conspiracy mongering) is something that you refuse to acknowledge.
Has Dubya found those WMDs under the Oval Office rug yet? Practically every poster on here remembers a conspiracy to go to war in arguably the worst foreign policy disaster in US history, such an experience changes a person's perception of government or should if they have a functioning neuron or two left.
20. You are incredibly offended by this list
Are you pissed off by this list? Maybe there is a reason for that.
Not pissed off, wearied. At one time DU was a refuge from overwhelming right wing thought, this was particularly true for those of us living in heavily Republican areas, I don't personally know any other liberals and not that many who aren't wingnuts.
Bear in mind that it takes a great deal of personal integrity to maintain a political stance when you are surrounded and overwhelmed by people who think you are evil and should just drop dead due to your politics.
Now no longer is DU a refuge for those of us who are further left, the right hates us and the centrists loathe us, they certainly have that in common.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
250 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
“Given the choice between a Republican and someone who acts like a Republican, people..."
Hissyspit
Sep 2013
#29
Of course not. Actual history shows that their ideology has a failure rate of 100%.
Egalitarian Thug
Sep 2013
#148
You mean the actual history of Ronald Reagan, Bob Dole, George Bush Sr, Newt Gingrich...
baldguy
Sep 2013
#149
It's cool that you mention Franco. Everyone always ends up comparing the right-wingers ...
dawg
Sep 2013
#18
this is why Latin American history is so important: it shows what They want when They're
MisterP
Sep 2013
#226
What I do beleive is that you can provide a cite for that policy that you claim.
Cryptoad
Sep 2013
#140
Yes. There was a derogatory post about the Democratic wing of the Democratic Party
MsPithy
Sep 2013
#47
Well, I've had exchanges, if you could call them that with the 'conservatiive'
sabrina 1
Sep 2013
#156
I wouldn't call any of this being "counterproductive" or being a "wingnut"
ConservativeDemocrat
Sep 2013
#42
"When I do it, it is disagreeing, when the (unspecified) "other" does it, it's hate"
Democracyinkind
Sep 2013
#105
Calling out specific posts and posters is forbidden by D.U. rules
ConservativeDemocrat
Sep 2013
#191
This list is just not stupid. It is you that I don't find offensive, at all.
Warren Stupidity
Sep 2013
#53
because I rememebr b'back in the day' when we here on DU used to laugh at the Repubs
azurnoir
Sep 2013
#87
why is that some here wish to give Obama credit for what the SCOTUS actually did?
azurnoir
Sep 2013
#184
I had, unfortunately, just run across the rather disturbing post to which this is a response, and
niyad
Sep 2013
#69
Proud to be a leftwing nutjob with you and the many other fine folks on this thread.
AllyCat
Sep 2013
#71
It's public information, anyone can see it by clicking on the yellow box above the rec button.
scarletwoman
Sep 2013
#77
Well if that post you made was in the BOG then you've also been banned from there.
cui bono
Sep 2013
#86
Republicans transitioned twice, becoming the party of corporate isolationists after WWI
Agnosticsherbet
Sep 2013
#82
Thank you. I agree completely. When the president is right, I will say it.
Nanjing to Seoul
Sep 2013
#97
I like the defiance. Let them know what we believe and how many of us there are.
Democracyinkind
Sep 2013
#101
But we have more billionaires than any other nation, and that's what really matters, isn't it?
Egalitarian Thug
Sep 2013
#211
I will continue to be a left wing moonbat with no hesitation. At least facts back up what I say
Nanjing to Seoul
Sep 2013
#117
A post worthy on the level of bvar, sabrina, manny, and woomewithscience.
Efilroft Sul
Sep 2013
#137
Look in a mirror, Julie, if you want "snotty little pieces of crap like your post."
WorseBeforeBetter
Sep 2013
#239
I posted such a thread the other day, it got considerably more recs than replies
Fumesucker
Sep 2013
#217
The way to find those kind of posts is look for ones with more recs than replies
Fumesucker
Sep 2013
#238
One of our society's greatest problems imo is there are far too right wing-nuts and
indepat
Sep 2013
#186
Why do you have more recs than the other post about the "counter productive left"??
kentuck
Sep 2013
#205
"libdems are just a third of a third!" "DU isn't representative of the party or America!"
MisterP
Sep 2013
#227