Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Five things white people should know about cultural appropriation [View all]blackspade
(10,056 posts)112. As an anthropologist I have an issue with the concept of 'cultural appropriation'
Cultural appropriation occurs whenever to cultures interact and it flows both ways.
Articles like this one assume that there is a distinct cultural boundary between black and white culture in this country.
In fact, that seemingly distinct boundary have been fluid and porous for centuries.
There is one part of the OP that does ring true, and that is this:
"And what makes cultural appropriation all the more infuriating for people of color rests on the fact that other peoplewhite or notcan take off their costume and return to everyday life without the discrimination or stigma commonly associated with those cultural expressions."
However, this assumes that corn rows and bleccents, helmet head hair cuts and power suits, and long hair and leather jackets are not all costumes. They are, and all can be taken off at will. For example, if I am going for a job interview at a corporation, I am going to wear a business suit and will speak without slang or other obvious 'metal' culture accoutrements. Am I culturally appropriating and wearing a costume? Yes, and I can take it off as soon as I hit the door.
The core of this problem is not really cultural appropriation, but racism and a lack of respect for people of color. It Katy Perry likes her hair in corn rows, who the fuck cares? Does she practice racism and bigotry? Same for Madonna, or George Harrison, or Black Sabbath. All have appropriated cultural aspects that are not 'white.' The question should be asked is; does this promote a positive cultural interaction that will enrich and eventually merge cultures? Or is the appropriation decisive and destructive?
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
170 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Because America really has no inherent culture, it is made up of immigrants after all, they have to borrow
Fred Sanders
Dec 2014
#2
Where does blackface still appear?..I saw a clip of it in Australian TV a few years ago
whathehell
Dec 2014
#110
Open-minded cultures and people have a long history of celebrating other cultures
bhikkhu
Dec 2014
#13
What needs to be read and understood by those who just don't 'get' it......
marble falls
Dec 2014
#15
If a white person said they were offended by a black person in a Viking costume ...
dawg
Dec 2014
#41
And you definitely didn't want a horn on the side of the helmet that would dirct the strike...
blackspade
Dec 2014
#120
Plus the fact that so many black artists often don't get the credit--or the financial
tblue37
Dec 2014
#31
In those cases, though, it's not someone stealing from "a culture", it's someone stealing
hughee99
Dec 2014
#43
And even the early Blues was a sort of cultural melding between racial groups.
cemaphonic
Dec 2014
#93
I remember when "Holiday" by Madonna came out. It was only played on the black/R&B stations
Number23
Dec 2014
#71
I guess that IMITATION IS THE SINCEREST FORM OF FLATTERY is out the window, then.
JEFF9K
Dec 2014
#53
My grandson in mostly Native America and white but there is a black ancestor. He saw my genealogy
jwirr
Dec 2014
#58
Okay. So, what's the upshot? Iggy Azalea should only sing "Tie Me Kangaroo Down, Sport"?
Comrade Grumpy
Dec 2014
#59
K&R There are a slew of interesting articles in the side nav of this piece that are great reads too
Number23
Dec 2014
#72
I am amazed by how many in this thread don't understand culture or how it works.
kwassa
Dec 2014
#119
There is history and relevance to how African American women wear their hair and why
gollygee
Dec 2014
#89
This whole thread has been absolutely revolting. And I don't mean you for starting it
Number23
Dec 2014
#90
As an anthropologist I have an issue with the concept of 'cultural appropriation'
blackspade
Dec 2014
#112
Does this concept only apply only to manners of dress and speech, or is food and architecture and
Marr
Dec 2014
#123
Actually, you're wrong. This is not a new concept, has been around for decades.
kwassa
Dec 2014
#137
Yes, Ayn Rand, it is your legal right to do a great number of irresponsible things. n/t
gollygee
Dec 2014
#160
African Americans have been more successful than any oppressed minority in history ...
redgreenandblue
Dec 2014
#167