Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Forget 'evil' Putin - we are the bloodthirsty warmongers [View all]NuclearDem
(16,184 posts)104. Oh good God, the whataboutisms. This almost isn't even worth replying to.
jailing dissidents - just about every country, including the US, jails dissidents. Two come to mind, here: Chelsea Manning, John Kiriakou. Pot/kettle.
Do I need to get out my "Free Chelsea Manning" shirt?
I don't represent the US government; there's absolutely zero hypocrisy in my condemning Russia for jailing its dissidents, because I've been wholeheartedly supportive of keeping our whistleblowers and dissidents out of prison.
Whataboutism count: 1.
Assassinating the above - really? is Putin assassinating these people by his own hand? Who?
To name two right off the top of my head, Alexander Litivenko and Anna Politovskaya, one a defector to the UK who was highly critical of the Russian government, the other a journalist who covered corruption and Chechnya.
I highly doubt they're the only ones.
Leveling his own cities - see Sabrina's post, upthread.
Not happening. What Putin did to Grozny was nothing short of a war crime, and if I have to see one more fucking poster here defending that, I'm going to blow my lid again.
Seizing parts of neighboring countries - would you be referring to Crimea? That train has left the station. Russian troops were already there. And Russia wasn't going to give up its only warm water port. Duh!
Russian troops were there and relegated to their bases. That was their agreement with Ukraine. The second they left those bases and annexed Ukrainian territory, that was an invasion and illegal land grab. Glad to know you think it's just fine to commit an act of aggression against another country as long as it's for strategic/resource reasons. Guess that makes Iraq alright in your book.
Pogrom against the LGBT community? Definition of Pogrom: massacre. slaughter, butchery, genocide. Isn't your allegation a little over the top?
He's damn well in the process of starting one. Too many parallels with the lead up to the Holocaust for my taste.
Make no mistake.. I am wholly committed to gay rights. I am also vehemently opposed to the discrimination that gays endure in Russia. I also recall when "don't ask, don't tell" was the law in the US, and when Pres. Obama was, as he stated, "evolving" on some gay rights issues. He got a pass on that. I seem to detect some hyprocrisy in terms of the present situation I Russia.
Wow, that's one of the biggest loads of horseshit I have ever read on DU, and that's saying something.
First of all, if you're making excuses for one of the worst enemies of the LGBT community abroad, then you're not committed to LGBT rights.
Second, you go right back to assuming I was in favor of DADT or made excuses for Obama's position. I fucking didn't, and I'd appreciate you not attributing beliefs to me that I don't hold.
Third, another goddamn motherfucking whataboutism. That the US had anti-gay policies on the book is utterly fucking irrelevant with regards to Russia. Both are wrong.
Goddamnit, that was horrible.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
144 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
You won't get any from me. Putin is an asshole who should be standing trial at the Hague. .
Initech
Dec 2014
#33
"Stupid, ill-informed people nowadays like to compare Mr Putin with Hitler. I warn them--
eridani
Dec 2014
#68
Really! I think using the right-wing DAILY MAIL as a club to convince us is a particularly unique
MADem
Dec 2014
#130
Fortunately the younger generation wasn't subjected to that. World travel and the internet has
sabrina 1
Dec 2014
#44
That was hatred for all things communist. Russian had little to do with it. But Russian communism
NewDeal_Dem
Dec 2014
#46
"Since 1989, Moscow, the supposed aggressor, has – without fighting or losing a war"
EX500rider
Dec 2014
#4
I see your Georgia and Chechyna, and raise you Afghanistan, Yemen, Somalia, Iraq, Iraq again...
Comrade Grumpy
Dec 2014
#22
Article wasn't about the US...but it did claim the Russians had been in no wars...BS
EX500rider
Dec 2014
#32
Chechnya yes, Georgia was a different story. McCain and his far right buddies thought
sabrina 1
Dec 2014
#45
"I see some people here on the same page as the far right when in the past"
NewDeal_Dem
Dec 2014
#47
I happen to know that the Republican Party is in love with this KGB agent
NoJusticeNoPeace
Dec 2014
#76
My right-wing nephew thinks Putin is a great guy and a wonderful leader!
greatauntoftriplets
Dec 2014
#55
"Stupid, ill-informed people nowadays like to compare Mr Putin with Hitler."
NuclearDem
Dec 2014
#12
You are ignoring the fact that an entire section of the Ukraine has gone and elected
truedelphi
Dec 2014
#27
This is a liberal website. Not a place to post fascist Big Lies straight from Moscow.
True Blue Door
Dec 2014
#59
I won't read Peter Hitchens on Christmas, that's something akin to a black mass I think.
Bluenorthwest
Dec 2014
#23
It's the same MIC that is now turning on Americans and dividing them against each other
CJCRANE
Dec 2014
#24
How members of the Nobel Peace Prize committee overlooked Vladimir Putin is a total mystery.....
Rowdyboy
Dec 2014
#30
I'll compare Putin to Hitler all I want if he's going to murder my people just like Hitler did.
DemocraticWing
Dec 2014
#34
Hmmm..."Tongue bathing" and "sack". Makes sense, I suppose. But seriously...
truth2power
Dec 2014
#66
Your replies reflect a sense of disingenuous Irony or perhaps Hypocrisy is a better word?
KoKo
Dec 2014
#101
It saddens me daily that so many here look for the worst from Russia and Putin.
snappyturtle
Dec 2014
#129
Thanks, Snappy. It's good to know that there are a few DUers who get it. n/t
truth2power
Dec 2014
#136
I am sorry but I don't trust Putin at all. Given the opportunity opportunity he would invade
hrmjustin
Dec 2014
#57
No, what's wrong is apologizing for NAZI behavior on the part of America's leaders.
Octafish
Dec 2014
#92
The ones where you implicate 4 presidents and countless individuals with the exception of
zappaman
Dec 2014
#138