General Discussion

H2O Man

(78,939 posts)

40. Recommended.

Mon May 11, 2015, 08:43 AM

May 2015

I had been provided with an early copy of this, and was waiting to post it on DU. Glad to see that you have it here, and that DUers are reading it.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

79 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Sy Hersh Stunner: The Killing of Osama bin Laden [View all] markpkessinger May 2015 OP

Unless this writer had first hand knowledge of the events leading up and the actual mission Thinkingabout May 2015 #1

Do you believe everything the government tells you? starroute May 2015 #20

Yes, I believe that Jessica Lynch was rescued... JayhawkSD May 2015 #21

The raid did indeed go down essentially how it was told to us. FarPoint May 2015 #33

Hersh isn't saying he wasn't in Abbottabad starroute May 2015 #41

Who cares what Pakistan says about that.... FarPoint May 2015 #44

This message was self-deleted by its author PragmaticLiberal May 2015 #61

No, and I do not believe everything a writer writes. Thinkingabout May 2015 #34

Let me explain one last time, I understand how negotiations work, it is not a final draft, plain Thinkingabout May 2015 #36

For sure. All those reliable Pakistani Officials. Why not trust them? redstateblues May 2015 #2

For sure. All those reliable Pentagon Officials. Why not trust them? Maedhros May 2015 #56

Huge K & R !!! - Thank You !!! WillyT May 2015 #3

Dumping OBL's body was fishy. Bonobo May 2015 #4

If people had been such sticklers about unnamed sources . . . markpkessinger May 2015 #5

And if people hadn't been so willing to believe unnamed sources ... 1StrongBlackMan May 2015 #53

I thought of the Jessica Lynch story, too gratuitous May 2015 #6

Smell is a vastly underrated sense in media studies as well as real life. nt Bonobo May 2015 #7

And in reading DU posts bashing the president geek tragedy May 2015 #18

"Smell" being a metaphorical phrase meaning "my prejudices" Bucky May 2015 #74

Absolutely fishy. nt SusanCalvin May 2015 #8

Fishy as hell BrotherIvan May 2015 #9

We live in a propaganda state now. woo me with science May 2015 #10

We're nothing but customers. Spitfire of ATJ May 2015 #19

We are ruled by Philosopher Kings. nt Fantastic Anarchist May 2015 #54

Witnessing Sy Hersch's fall into this nonsense is moderately sad alcibiades_mystery May 2015 #11

Remember his mass casualty "scoop" from Iraq ten years ago? Recursion May 2015 #13

He also did a full Benghazi. Sad. KittyWampus May 2015 #15

Remember when he warned us in July 2002 that W. wanted to invade Iraq? McCamy Taylor May 2015 #22

Yep, and how every 8 months or so since then he's warned of an Iran attack (nt) Recursion May 2015 #23

I'm with you. Warren DeMontague May 2015 #26

He wasn't the only one, and definitely wasn't the first. Now he is just another tin foiler still_one May 2015 #29

Any person on the street following the trail of crumbs Skidmore May 2015 #62

The threat from al Qaeda was exagerated by our politicians so they could be our heroes. Spitfire of ATJ May 2015 #12

BS nt kelliekat44 May 2015 #14

Careful now, Sy. Maedhros May 2015 #16

People who want to call Obama a liar will lap this drivel up geek tragedy May 2015 #17

Absolutely, and to even throw the theory that it was used to justify the killing of bin laden shows still_one May 2015 #28

Bin Laden was planning more attacks too.. he wasn't some mass murderer who got his and then Cha May 2015 #32

you mean he didn't have a 401K? still_one May 2015 #37

That he was planning more attacks is precisely one of the things Hersh's essay disputes n/t markpkessinger May 2015 #49

He was such an innocent guy treestar May 2015 #65

Nobody's saying that and you know it n/t markpkessinger May 2015 #66

If he was not planning more attacks treestar May 2015 #67

Poor bin laden.. wah wah wah.. Cha May 2015 #78

Yeah, the usuals who have been throwing ignorant cheap pot shots for 7 years.. oh yeah hersh calls Cha May 2015 #31

Three things lend the story credibility. JayhawkSD May 2015 #24

+1 n/t markpkessinger May 2015 #50

you should do more research snooper2 May 2015 #52

Chill. You can support Obama and still not trust the government. The two things are not mutually McCamy Taylor May 2015 #25

No way should that POS be taken into custody. He deserved exactly what he got. As for these third still_one May 2015 #27

I didn't particularly lose sleep over bin Laden being killed either . . . markpkessinger May 2015 #64

See #64 below markpkessinger May 2015 #68

Poor Sy Hersh. He's being dragged down the garden path in a big way with this "tale." MADem May 2015 #30

Excellent post, Creative Speculation over whelms some folks. Thinkingabout May 2015 #38

So the Pakistani military sold Osama out and allowed sufrommich May 2015 #35

Kinda My Reaction, Too RobinA May 2015 #39

Recommended. H2O Man May 2015 #40

Dead men tell no tales /nt jakeXT May 2015 #42

Get your tinfoil hat on tight before reading this... Dr Hobbitstein May 2015 #43

Why This Nonsense Now? itcfish May 2015 #45

for 2 years he said it, the event happened before an election then jakeXT May 2015 #46

Good point . . . markpkessinger May 2015 #55

Not Buying This erpowers May 2015 #47

What doesn't make sense is the throngs of drone war apologists that claim our only recourse Maedhros May 2015 #58

This is all UNAPPROVED for your reading FlatBaroque May 2015 #48

I belittle and triviliase those which do not share my opinion too LanternWaste May 2015 #51

*trivialize FlatBaroque May 2015 #59

Sy, meet Alex Jones KamaAina May 2015 #57

Appearly they've been in communication with Mr. Hersh according to Jones 951-Riverside May 2015 #60

as I posted in the other thread, Hersch was very accurate during The Idiots terms Doctor_J May 2015 #63

Okay Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin May 2015 #69

I find it scary that so many are unwilling to at least consider the possibility that it may be true markpkessinger May 2015 #70

Uh Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin May 2015 #72

I don't think anybody can honestly say it is true or not true at this point . . . markpkessinger May 2015 #73